New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Why are end grain joints weaker.....

Posts

Why are end grain joints weaker.....

#1

Why are end grain joints weaker.....

Bill Tindall

Some years ago I happened to meet the chief chemist from Frainklin glue company. This was an opportunity not to be wasted. While weeding(the mind does wander whilst weeding) I pondered the question of why end grain joints were weaker. Pasted below is the answer I received to this question.

As you are aware, the geometry of wood is similar to a bundle of straws. Those straws or tubes are designed to take up the sap and the nutrients that are needed for growth and transport them out to every part of the tree. While the edges and faces of a plain sawn piece of wood are comprised of the sides of those tubes and form a nearly solid layer, the ends of the same piece are comprised of only the open ends of those "straws" or tubes. That results in two different facts that create problems in achieving successful end joints. First of all, the fact that the end grain is so open means that there is comparatively little actual wood surface available for bonding. Perhaps even more significant, however, is the fact that the open tubes that form the end of the piece are highly absorbent. That means that when what would normally be an appropriate layer of any water based glue is applied and the joint closed, the porous end grain literally steals

all the glue from the joint. Taken together, those factors drastically reduce the chances for forming a meaningful bond.

"Thus, whenever possible, an assembly should be designed in such a way as to avoid bonding end grain. Yet, when bonding end grain cannot be avoided, recognizing the factors involved can usually allow at least an adequate bond to be formed. My suggestion is that one of two approaches be employed. First, consider diluting a small amount of the glue that is to be used in a separate container - perhaps a jar lid. Then take that thinned glue (diluted with at least one part of water to one part of glue) and apply a coat over the end grain in question. That thin mixture will be rapidly drawn into the wood and have little effect on the bonding surface, but it will partially plug those pores, and prevent the undiluted glue used in the actual bonding operation from disappearing into the wood. The fact that that "sizing" does not fully coat or seal the end grain allows the real glue to anchor well to the wood and leaves enough porosity so that the glue

can dry. When using this approach, the sizing should be given at least a few minutes to dry, but this process could be also be done hours or days before the actual assembly occurs as long as care is taken to assure that the surfaces to be mated are still well matched. .

The alternate approach merely involves a two step application of the glue being used for bonding, with the initial coat applied and allowed a minute or two to soak in, followed by a reapplication of fresh glue. While the initial coat serves to quench the thirst of the open end grain, the subsequent application assures that there is enough fresh glue left in the joint to achieve some reasonable bonding."

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

#2

Thanks for this, Bill

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I had read this suggestion at another time, perhaps from you (feeling those memories slipping away...). It's good to understand the process and to know that a glue authority supports it as a workable approach when it's necessary.

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

#3

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

Pam Niedermayer

I think once one understands the straw structure, it all becomes pretty obvious (not to denigrate your post, since it's probably not a fact that sits in one's fore brain). So, are you also saying that your solution for end grain (to sand it 'til it drops) related? Does the sawdust also plug the straws?

Pam

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

#4

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

eliot d

What about a mitered edge. say 45 degrees -- part end grain?

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

#5

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

Bill Tindall

Indeed, the discussion applies to miters which behave more like end grain than long grain. I suggest they always be sized first by one the two ways described in the Franklin discussion.

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

#6

?

Bill Tindall

I sand end grain till it shines before staining it, but I would never consider sanding a surface to be glued. I don't have the means to maintain a surface sufficiently flat while sanding to use it as a surface to be glued.

Which reminds me that I never made magnified images of end grain, planed vs sanded, to see what was going on. I'll bet the pores on the sanded surface are blinded over by deformed, bent or mutilated fibers.

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

#7

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker..... they aren

TomD

Didn't read all of that, but the premise is not correct.

What is correct is that if you glue end grain to end grain, it is not stronger than the surrounding wood. If you glue side grain to side grain, the joint is stronger than the surrounding wood. The reason is because wood is anisotropic. So the comparison is not fair since the stronger than examples are for materials with different strength in the 0 than 90 direction. If you glue end grain to side grain, as with say a balsa core sandwich, the glue will pull away from the side grain, not the end grain. No special glue preparation is required.

To better understand this imagine 2 2x4s, 8 foot long. One is made up of little 4x4 sections cut from a regular 2x4, and joined back together end to end. The other one is made up of similar pieces glued together side to side. It isn't going to be much of a 2x4 one way or another. But I hope it is obvious that the glue joints in either case are not by themselves all that impressive.

One should not necessarily avoid end grain gluing. Just not rely on it in situations where it is not strong enough. But there are certain situations like dovetails where it is a major part of the joint, and no the part that will fail first.

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

#8

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

TomD

"Indeed, the discussion applies to miters which behave more like end grain than long grain. I suggest they always be sized first by one the two ways described in the Franklin discussion."

I would say they are precisely 50/50, by the rule of mixtures kind of principle. Sizing means to me that the material is wetted with glue that is then left to dry, then more is added for the final whatever. This may or not be necessary, but I would not do it with a glue that did not glue to itself.

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

#9

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

TomD

"I would say they are precisely 50/50, by the rule of mixtures kind of principle"

By the way, you could probably dig up some real scientist supplied info on this since at one time aircraft were built in wood commercially, and as part of military production. I have at least one book from that period that has a lot of interesting technical info. One issue there is scrarf joint ratio to wood grading. My book does not cover this, but what I am saying is this is a reality, and there was lots of technical stuff out there, since it was part of mandated standards, there must be some technical stuff on it. You get ratios from 6-1 to 20-1 depending on the underlying grade of wood.

Re: Why are end grain joints weaker.....

#10

Re: ?

TomD

"I sand end grain till it shines before staining it, but I would never consider sanding a surface to be glued. I don't have the means to maintain a surface sufficiently flat while sanding to use it as a surface to be glued."

This is relatively easy, just a shooting board and a sanding plane. I use this for guitar parts, there the joints need to be dead flat and this is the simplest way to get there. Only a few joints need this, but there are some that need dead flat assembly and some tooth.

Actually, on that last point whether sanding helps or not is a debated question. I tend to do guitars to an industry standard since returns would be disastrous.