Fundamentally, what is dulling......
Bill Tindall
In case you don't get to the end I'll ask the question up front. What feedback tells you that it is time to sharpen a plane blade? Why I am asking this question follows.
In the 1980's considerable research was done in Japan on the fundamentals of planing lumber. While this research seemed geared to understanding "planing machines" these machines seem to be essentially equivalent to hand planing lumber in terms of blade speed, angles, etc. Hence, the results of these studies are relevant to the fundamental mechanics and understanding of hand planing-chip formation, blade wear, self sharpening, etc.
"Lab" versions of these planing machines were made and they were highly instrumented to provide data on forces, for example, and they offered precise control of variables such as shaving depth, cutting speed, blade angle, etc. Bottom line, these lab machines enabled precisely controlled planing experiments to be performed. Furthermore, these studies were done at universities that had state of the art imaging to observe factors such as wear of plane blades and chip breakers.
One of these papers was published in English when one of the Japanese professors was on sabbatical in NC State. The citations in this paper led to several preceding publications about planing, all in Japanese. Steve Elliot and I have tracked down some of these publications and we have the one translated. It covers studies on the role of chip breakers. It is a treasure trove of fundamental data on how the blade tip and chip breaker wear as lumber is planed. These data led to a theory about what is dull that was anything but intuitive. If you will humor me with the feedback you use to determine when it is time to sharpen I, and or Steve, will over time post the conclusions from the Japanese paper concerning the role of the chip breaker and grain orientation in plane blade dulling.




