New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Fundamentally, what is dulling......

Posts

Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#1

Fundamentally, what is dulling......

Bill Tindall

In case you don't get to the end I'll ask the question up front. What feedback tells you that it is time to sharpen a plane blade? Why I am asking this question follows.

In the 1980's considerable research was done in Japan on the fundamentals of planing lumber. While this research seemed geared to understanding "planing machines" these machines seem to be essentially equivalent to hand planing lumber in terms of blade speed, angles, etc. Hence, the results of these studies are relevant to the fundamental mechanics and understanding of hand planing-chip formation, blade wear, self sharpening, etc.

"Lab" versions of these planing machines were made and they were highly instrumented to provide data on forces, for example, and they offered precise control of variables such as shaving depth, cutting speed, blade angle, etc. Bottom line, these lab machines enabled precisely controlled planing experiments to be performed. Furthermore, these studies were done at universities that had state of the art imaging to observe factors such as wear of plane blades and chip breakers.

One of these papers was published in English when one of the Japanese professors was on sabbatical in NC State. The citations in this paper led to several preceding publications about planing, all in Japanese. Steve Elliot and I have tracked down some of these publications and we have the one translated. It covers studies on the role of chip breakers. It is a treasure trove of fundamental data on how the blade tip and chip breaker wear as lumber is planed. These data led to a theory about what is dull that was anything but intuitive. If you will humor me with the feedback you use to determine when it is time to sharpen I, and or Steve, will over time post the conclusions from the Japanese paper concerning the role of the chip breaker and grain orientation in plane blade dulling.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#2

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Woodworkers use the word shaving to describe the discharge from a plane. We have done so for more than three centuries. We do not use the word chip. I think chip breaker is a machinist's term; historic terms for the second iron are top iron, cap iron, cover etc.

About dulling. An experienced woodworker does use intuition. We use a combination of tactile feedback from the tool, the quality of the surface, the amount of use the tool has seen, and more that I cannot enumerate, and unconsciously form a model of the dullness. When I had a fellow working for me last year, he learned to sharpen rather easily, but as the dullness crept up slowly, he gradually got used to the dullness and did not know when to sharpen. Even though I was doing my own work, my mind unconsciously kept track of his use. Efficient sharpening comes as the result of many many cycles of sharpening and dulling and using the mind to discern the results.

Perhaps you measure blood sugar to discover if you are hungry or not, or put a meter on your bladder to see if it is full. A discerning person with lots of experience does not need these things.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#3

Terminology

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Warren,

I agree with much of your description, but disagree that it's intuition, which one online dictionary defines as "knowledge or belief obtained neither by reason nor by perception." Rather, I think you're describing analysis of cues that you have learned to perceive.

I conclude a tool (plane, chisel) is dull when the work gets harder (I have to push more) and the action rougher, and the resulting chips/shavings are not as smooth. I don't think there's a distinct point here - it's a continuum.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#4

A different approach to life

Bill Tindall

Some, probably most, people are satisfied that they don't have a fundamental understanding why they are hungry. They are content to accept most things the way they are and worry about what's for dinner. Others are driven to know the why and how of anything of current interest. Personally, it drove me nuts not understanding why end grain joints were weaker until I finally found an answer. A great relief came over me upon learning the answer. I posted because I thought there might be some other person that was curious and would benefit from an explanation. Note how a fundamental understanding of the cause leads to a means of improving the joint.

My continuing quest is to fundamentally understand planing and in particular dulling. My objective, simply to satisfy a curiosity. Could the results be beneficial to others, maybe, but that is not the driving force.

I am bewildered by your post. What was its objective? It certainly was not helpful to my question. If the objective was to get me to stop posting my curiosities, splash cold water on them often enough and I can take them elsewhere.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#5

That creeping up dullness..

David Weaver

... is the one thing that I don't like about the couple of high speed steel irons I have. It takes so long for them to get truly dull that I generally use them until they don't cut at all. (but I don't use them that much unless I have something that my other planes don't plane well, like cocobolo, and that's not often).

I also think that's another reason that a novice user needs to either have a tight mouth on their smoother or a properly set second iron. If not, they will create tearout as they dull a tool and continue to try to force the shaving thicker to compensate.

That's just my opinion, though.

Everyone has their own habits. One of mine as I get tired is to bear down on a plane more than necessary. That creates a sensation that a plane is duller than it really is. that's mitigated easily by thought and wax, but when I was a beginner, I sharpened before edges stopped providing a good surface because I though the edge of the plane was resisting when it wasn't.

Aside from that habit, sharpness is a perception issue with me with the smoother. With heavier cutting planes, I'll usually let them get closer to dull than smoothers, unless I need a break.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#6

now that is helpful...more

Bill Tindall

Can you or others elaborate on "work gets harder (I have to push more) ". The pushing force can be broken into two components, one parallel to the direction of travel and the other perpendicular to the plane of the board. The problem is confounded by the fact that more force down results in more friction and hence more force to move forward. But more description of the feed back on forces to move a dull plane will be helpful to interpreting the data in the Kato paper.

When I get it organized I will post some data from the Kato paper relevant to this discussion that may be of interest.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#7

A list ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill and all

It is tempting to say that we intuit when the blade is dulling. I think that this is just another way of recognising the various cues that we react to as a blade dulls.

Firstly we watch the shavings. Are they changing in shape and texture?

Secondly, we can feel the effort that is required to push the plane. This is probably less reliable since we may adjust the depth of cut as we work.

Thirdly, there is the sound of the blade. The change from a high note, which reflects a clean slicing action, to a lower note, which reflects the increasing resistance akin to scraping.

Fourthly, we look at the quality of the surface of the wood. Does it change in shine?

There is a start. I'll leave room for others to add a few more.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#8

If it's dull, you've waited too long

wilbur

The best piece of advice I've ever heard about when to sharpen was this: "Sharpen before you think you need to sharpen."

Another piece of advice that really is saying the same thing is "The more you sharpen, the less you sharpen."

In practice, I've found this to be true. The problem with all sharpening demos is that they start off with a tool that is pretty dull to start with, whereupon you grind the bevel, go through your 1000/4000/8000+ grit waterstones, or your 15/3/1 micron diamond pastes, or your soft Arkansas/hard Arkansas/strop, and you have your sharp edge.

But sharpening shouldn't be like this. I leave a natural Japanese waterstone on a table next to my bench all the time. The fact that it's a natural Japanese waterstone isn't the important thing. It could be a strop with green compound on it, or a cast iron plate charged with 1 micron diamond paste. The fact that it's always available and convenient is.

I'll use it to hone my plane blades and chisels fairly frequently: before I start working on a new panel, before I start chopping a new mortise, after about 10 minutes of planing or so. The honing is quick and easy — 30 seconds tops. This keeps my tool sharp, which is a lot easier than letting it get dull, in which case you have to go through three or more steps to get it to sharp again.

In this sense, I think that Warren is right in that experience will tell you a lot. I've hit on my routine after spending time trying to make things. In my case, it's working with North American hardwoods with Japanese tools. I've figured out that the routine I described above works well for me. If I was using A-2 tools on tropicals, I might come up with something different.

If you need some sort of quantification, I think that Steve Eliot's photo probably does it better than anything else I've seen on this subject:


I'd sharpen somewhere between the 200-300 LF stages. That's the point where the degradation of the edge starts to spill over into changing the geometry of the tip, and up to that point freshening up your blade with the last step of your sharpening process is still going to be relatively easy. That seems pretty reasonable. If I was making a bookcase with 12" deep shelves about 3 feet wide, that's the equivalent of making 4 passes with a smoothing plane over the entire show surfaces of three shelves (actually, 3-1/2 shelves) before stopping to resharpen the blade. In practice, I can go a bit longer, but that's probably because Japanese tools held their edge really well.

In any case, my main point is that waiting until your tool seems to be dull is probably not the best strategy for sharpening. I've found that frequent honings is more time efficient than waiting until the tool gets dull, whatever you wind up deciding that is.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#9

David Barnett

I think Warren hit it dead on...

David Barnett

...although I might have chosen a different term than intuition, I think it's that very synthetic model that Warren describes that tracks a liminal balance, a threshold, a feeling, if you will, almost the antithesis of analytical, I'd say.

Although I tend to sharpen sooner than I probably need to, it's because I'm taking lots of breaks, partly because of health factors; asthma, cardiac, and so on, but also because I like to think about and sometimes just savor the process; the quality of the wood, the tool, the work.

In addition to Warren's factors, I'd add auditory and kinesthetic to the mix. I can hear differences in sharpness, and I can feel differences in my stance, the amount of skeletomuscular bracing, the width of stance, balance and the weight added to the stroke, timing between strokes, and any of increase required to get the desired effect, not the easiest thing to deconstruct or model.

A hand tools class I once took was one of the only times I've been in a shop with multiple workbenches and everyone working on the same task. One could quickly pick up on how another person might change his stance and increase effort as his blade dulled, or hear the differences at other benches.

I know exactly what Warren means when he was unconsciously tracking another woodworker (great example), but I know it from music, where I could hear all manner of things just from passing piano practice rooms. Warren's sensitivity for hand tool processes surely is far more acutely attuned than mine and probably most of us here; the result of decades of experience, and I'd put that up against any measuring protocols and instrumentation any time.

Funny how humans now check the thermometer to decide if we should feel too hot or too cold.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#10

Experience tells you

Ron in Kokomo

Lots of factors have been listed as clues. Experience interprets the clues . Probably not an acceptable answer to Bill's question. But I really don't think he expected one.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#11

Good point

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

As I think about it, another element when planing is the tendency of the plane to "fall out" of the wood as the edge gets dull - when it's sharp, the plane will grab ahold of the grain easily, almost eagerly*. Not so as it dulls. This is the "downforce" to which you refer.

So, yes, it's harder both ways, down and forward.

With chisels, I think (I'd have to watch myself working, which isn't always easy) I change the angle of attack to compensate; but of course, you can't do that with a plane.

*Yes, yes, I know, tools hate to be anthropomorphized.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#12

David Barnett

You mean to say...

David Barnett

...you don't name your tools?

"*Yes, yes, I know, tools hate to be anthropomorphized."

Mavis, Buford, Dagmar, and Linda the deep throat bar clamp are so offended when I don't call them by name.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#13

craigd

Re: I think Warren hit it dead on...

craigd

I agree with both Warren and David, I sharpen when the plane doesn't work like I know it should. How I determine this, I have no idea. I'm pretty sure it isn't pushing effort (although it is probably a factor) as I use planes with different attack angles, blade widths and cut depths (eg scrub to jack to jointer to smoother).

As a counter example to Wilbur's comment, probably most of my planes need sharpening at any one time, I just grab another one if something isn't right. I dislike reseting the blade so I (generally) wait until I feel like sharpening several.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#14

Re: A list ... One more

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

When the plane stops pulling itself (downward) into the cut.

Wiley

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#16

When an edge stops doing...

Bob Hackett

what I want it to do the first thing I do is sharpen.

there really are far too many variables to make a complete list and even on the same project using the same wood from the same tree the feedback and standards may change.

So when the edge stops meeting my expectations I sharpen it.

Some days I`m fussier and have more time to explore than others.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#17

boring deeper.....

Bill Tindall

I would like to bore a layer deeper into your response.

My purpose here is to get at the fundamentals, not to be picky or critical of your thoughtful response.....you list(in summary)....shaving texture and sound, and, effort and surface appearance.

The 3rd and 4th factors are practical and fundamental factors to determine when to sharpen. The first two are symptoms of some more fundamental reason to sharpen, for no one cares what the plane sounds like nor what the shavings look like(other than the guy in the April 1 LV video!) . Sound and shaving appearance must be symptoms of some more fundamental and practical failure of the cutting action, such as quality of surface or effort. Is there anything other than "effort" and "surface appearance" that would cause one to sharpen?

There are two objectives in planing, achieving a surface appearance and removing wood. There is a great diversity among woodworkers as to the relative importance of these two objectives. I have come to recognize from the responses that the clues one uses to detect dullness could be fundamentally different depending on the planing objective.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#18

I'll add yet another one..

david weaver

Japanese or western, when a plane has planed a significant amount of wood, you can see the wear bevel on the edge, even if the wear is a "pure" wear and no chipping.

The adage in razors is that before you strop a razor you should not be able to see anything at all at the edge. And as far as I can tell, that's true. On a freshly sharpened and stropped razor, I can actually see the wear that a strop has put on the edge, even though it is a tiny amount, it is still enough to reflect light (I might have better sight than some, a tinge better than 20/10, but it is something I can see). This reflection exists even on a harder (like horse butt) strop with almost no draw and pressure only enough to actually execute the stropping.

If I can't see just that tiny amount of strop wear on the edge of a razor, I know i'm in for a rough shave with some weepers.

At any rate, a good iron will do a macro size exhibit of that, and it's easy to see even shortly after you've started planing. When I carry a plane into my shop (if I'm using something I don't usually use), or if i pick up a plane at the beginning of a session, I will always turn it over and look at the edge to examine the wear.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#19

Re: A different approach to life

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Bill, you asked how one knows when it is time to sharpen. You did not ask for an analysis of what is going on.

I have been constructing models of what is going on in sharpening for nearly fifty years. My chemistry teacher told me in 1967 that a model needs to do three things. It is needs to explain the known phenomena, it needs to explain new phenomena as it is observed, and it needs to be able to predict phenomena that has yet to be observed. One of the problems with sharpening is that workers with less experience or less sensitivity do not even notice subtle phenomena that affect performance.

As an example, a tool that is more dull needs more of a burr to become sharp than one that is still in good shape. It takes a lot of experience to notice this. Steve Elliot's photographs suggest why it might be so (there is more portion rounded over that has to be sharpened away). But in practical terms one needs experience to know how bad the tool is and how much extra sharpening is needed. And to judge these things as one is sharpening.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#22

Well.... my wife names the cars...

John in NM

Best one yet is she named my Horrible Old Truck "Boris".... that one really stuck, even I use it.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#23

Re: A different approach to life

James Watriss

I honk I'm with Warren on this one, Bill. I do understand and appreciate your ongoing curiosity, and I try to keep a little bit of that alive in my own work.

At the same time, there's not a lot of scientific data that I use either. When I'm not getting the results I want, I choose either to sharpen, try a plane with a different pitch, or live with the end product. I don't wonder why the blade got dull... I already know the reason: tools get dull when you use them. There are various factors at work, but at the end of the day, that's one of those unchangeable facts of shop life, and the why and wherefore doesn't play into it for me.

The end grain glue thing has merit in my mind because it has the potential to change how I approach some things. But irons will continue to get dull.

Re: Fundamentally, what is dulling......

#24

Re: A different approach to life - end grain

TomD

"The end grain glue thing has merit in my mind because it has the potential to change how I approach some things. But irons will continue to get dull."

Yeah, but it isn't true, large parts of my boat are held together out of balsa composites that are prepared in flat end grain sheets. If you want to pay extra money, you can get the end grain sized from the factory, precisely to retard glue penetration so the joint isn't starved. Presumably Franklin tech people know of what they are speaking at some level, but that level is not making stuff out of wood, and that advise is not good.

Another example of an endgrain joint can be found in Spanish guitar construction, where the sides are glued into endgrain in the neck/heel, normal woodworking, works fine. By the way the most popular white/yellow glue, the only one commonly in use because everyone knows it will work under the loads of guitars, is Franklin Titebond 1. Hide glue is a step up, but that is another story.

one can get back to learning from each other.