New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Krenov style scrub plane

Posts

Krenov style scrub plane

#1

Krenov style scrub plane

jimbo

Ladies/Gents, I am planning to build a "krenov" style scrub plane modiifed to have a saw type handle and a tote. Questions: is the krenov style appropriate, what size blade (I plan to use Hock) and do you recommend a chip breaker for the appllication. Is the 45 degree bed angle appropriate? your comments welcomed. Thanks , j. smith

Re: Krenov style scrub plane

#2

Re: Krenov style scrub plane

John Pappas

jimbo, any comments from me on this question should be taken with a grain of salt. I have an Ulmia scrub plane. The blade is 1 1/4 inch wide with no chip breaker, set at 45 degrees. It is ground with a significant camber, about equal to the curve of a tuna fish can. If I were to make a scrub plane, I would use this one as a pattern. However, I think you could get 'satisfactory results' from a Krenov type plane made with a wide mouth, using a thick blade that was not too wide, without a chip breaker and ground with considerable camber.

Re: Krenov style scrub plane

#3

Re: Krenov style scrub plane - got one

TomD

I have a Krenov style plane that uses the ECE blade. It is one of my most useful planes. I put up a video of it, and maybe you can take something from that, however, the wood is very tough maple, the end grain is not even, the piece is not secure, just resting on the horses, and the angle is awkward. So it would be hard to find a way of more thoroughly sabotaging it's performance.

The other plane is also fun, it is a western style woodie, with an LV japanese blade. Kinda a weirdo, but fun to use.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-tHCxu0PF0k&context=C49bfc85ADvjVQa1PpcFM94tyKIRBi2taPkxfdFefeexbl8Z_Hjv0=

I just re-added this vid, so it may not show immediately.

Re: Krenov style scrub plane

#4

Re: Krenov style scrub plane *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I don't see why it wouldn't be. I made a hinge mortise plane some years back using the same approach, and it's worked fine. For what it's worth, I've attached the link to the article that Ellis was kind/foolish enough to post on my plane.

I don't know how much the Hock irons cost, but Lee Valley sells a replacement iron for their scrub plane that's pretty reasonably priced.

I'm not altogether sure you need an elaborate handle knob on the plane; shaping the front and back of the body so you can grip it comfortably may well be enough. Scrub plane are rough-work planes; you mainly want something you can grip well without raising blisters (on that subject, don't use a hard, lacquer-like finish; linseed oil or a long-oil varnish [like Danish oil] is probably better).


Article on the subject