New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

A different approach to dovetail chiseling

Posts

A different approach to dovetail chiseling

#1

A different approach to dovetail chiseling

Bill Tindall

....more precisely a different approach to any chopping procedure with a chisel.

Just back from a long and tedious road trip about the SE which ended well with a class with Will Neptune sponsored by the Georgia chapter of SAPFM. Will is a former North Bennett school teacher who currently works out of his own shop in MA doing mostly Period furniture work.

The Will did two classes and for those associated with a club I encourage you to consider offering one of these classes. My two day class employed only hand tools and hand tool techniques presumed to have been used in the NE shops making Period furniture. We covered Period correct case, table and chair joinery. The other two day class covered this same case chair and table joinery using only power tools.

Pounding a chisel through wood to efficiently remove waste will quickly dull the edge by chipping or crumbling, depending on the steel. But, the bulk waste removal does not require a highly refined edge for the blows of the hammer will penetrate a small chisel no matter it edge keenness. However, that last paring cut to the blase line does require a refined edge to make a precise, clean, effortless cut.


Will's approach to this problem is to use a "beater" chisel for bulk waste removal. As shown in the picture his "beater" chisel is a narrow Stanley butt chisel and he used it any time waste needed to be quickly chopped away. Its edge did not need to be highly refined. Finish cuts were done with a short, thin, and very sharp, chisel that we have described as a "dovertail" chisel. Will's edged tools were hollow ground, sharpened on a fixed diamond plate and refined by honing on a fine stone and stropping. In this picture Will is demonstrating preparation of a what he called a "housed dovetail", which is more often called a "sliding dovetail" as would be used to fix a shelf. BOTH male and female elements of the joint were tapered which created a joint which locked together with extraordinary tightness.

Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

#2

Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

Pam Niedermayer

Very interesting about tapering both male and female (actually, it was all interesting, but I'll have to give this a try). Now, how does he hollow grind with stones?

Pam

Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

#3

Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

david weaver

>>Will's edged tools were hollow ground, sharpened on a fixed diamond plate and refined by honing on a fine stone and stropping.<<

Not surprising. Fastest way to an accurate and refined edge.

Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

#4

the double tapering "sliding" dovetail

Bill Tindall

First the female part was made by plowing a dado across the board and then creating the angled face of the socket with a chisel and an angled guide block. This operation took but a minute or two. Then with the aid of an orthogonal guide block the straight face of the dovetail socket was tapered by chiseling from its original width to something about 3/32" wider at one end. It is this tapering operation shown in the picture.

Next with the aid of a guide block the "pin" or male portion of the dovetail, was chiseled on the end of a board(see picture). Again this operation took but a minute at most. At this point the male or pin end was too thick to just enter the widest part of the tapering socket. The pin board was then turned over and using a plane with a fence (I don't recall the plane's name) a rabbit was made on the end , so as to thin the dovetail pin. By eye and trial and error the rabbit was then tapered by planing. Trial fits revealed whether the angle of the taper was correct as well as whether the the leading or trailing edge of the taper was too thick or too thin.

This trial and error fitting of the male part to the female part sounds tedious but in fact there is quantitative feedback between how many shavings were taken and how far the tapered fit advanced and whether the angle of the taper was right. No more than 6 trial fits brought the joint to perfection and it was nearly impossible to disassemble it even in its dry state.

In all the joints Will made he pointed out the role of the torn wood fibers. These fibers fold down as joints are slid together. They must be stood up and reversed to pull the joint apart. When stiffened with glue this locking mechanism results in joints of astonishing withdrawal strength.

By shimming with 0.003" thick pieces of paper Will demonstrated that a well fit joint must be created with accuracy in the neighborhood of this tolerance.

The picture show the dovetail chiseling operation on a drawer blade.


Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

#5

Re: the double tapering "sliding" dovetail

Pam Niedermayer

Weird, I've mistakenly turned "hollow grind" into an adjective, forgetting that "grind" is a verb. Must be all the talk about sharpening lately.

On the sliding dovetails, I kind of like St. Roy's method of sawing both male and female. If marked properly before hand (one end narrower than the other), there's much less fitting involved. Especially since the male or female coulc be marked from the other. Guess the better method depends on how many of these honeys one is making.

Pam

Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

#6

Efficient and relaible

Bill Tindall

Woodworking is all about "efficient and reliable". What is efficient and reliable depends on one's ability and proficiency. Chiseling off a guide block is reliable to 0.001" for anyone of modest ability and experience. This class of mostly persons that had never hand cut these joints demonstrated this fact. Sawing a dovetail across an 8" board to 0.001" is not something a novice can do.

Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

#7

Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think it is much faster and easier to remove bulk with a sharp chisel, rather than a dull one. When I make drawer dovetails I use the same chisel for chopping the waste as making the final cuts, usually without sharpening midstream, but maybe if I got "chipping and crumbling" I would want to do differently.

Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

#8

Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

Charles

I do bulk chopping of dovetail waste with a sash mortise chisel. Same difference, I think. Pare to the line with a Blue Chip.

Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

#9

Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

TomD

I imagine we have all noticed that dichotomy, where pounding a dull chisel, it still cuts. But it is sorta a self-fulfilling prophesy if using crap chisels. I remember once noticing that a router bit or table saw blade would deliver surfaces at times that were equivalent to razor sharp hand tools, yet the bits were really dull in comparison to the hand tools. But the cutting power was equivalent because of the higher velocity. Cutting power comes from a number of sources and we tend to just emphasize the "sharpness" aspects.

Overall I would say that 1) A lot of these tricks work well till you try them at home. If you do a lot of poplar, your results will vary compared to ebony. The traditional fine furniture was built in easy to work woods like Mahog... I had the classic example of this at a climbing school in the 70s where they rappelled with the rope just wrapped around the body rather than using a mechanical brake. Worked great, like all the books from the 50 and before. But I was a little surprised because I had tried this before and it always hurt. The literature was full of bad stories also. Anyway got home gave my new found technique a try and almost cut myself in half. Turned out the Swiss Army ropes at 13 mm made all the difference compared to the standard 9-11mm ropes...

2) If you sharpen with hollow bevels then keeping an edge is a trivial task, why work with a bad one.

Re: A different approach to dovetail chiseling

#10

Re: Efficient and relaible

Pam Niedermayer

Excellent point. But perhaps it would have saved some time if we'd discussed the intended audience? :) What I forgot to say was that St. Roy's method is best for through work, a little more trouble for stopped sliders.

Pam