New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Identify these plough blades?

Posts

Identify these plough blades?

#1

Identify these plough blades?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

This is a long shot but I must ask whether anyone here can identify these plough plane blades from the UK?

They are a set of 8 (numbered 1 through 8 ) that I purchased for a plough plane I am about to build, and run from 3/16" through to 5/8". The blades are tapered and laminated. There are no maker's marks and the only markings are the number and "Warranted Cast Steel". The grooves are nicely done (clean and straight), so these are not likely to be shopmade. They have the look of cared-for vintage steel that were made by a known blademaker.




Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#2

Re: Identify these plough blades?

TomD

Derek, what design are you planing to build. I have a similar project, though I have an unmatched set of blades that may not be usable, or might require me to modify the backs, not sure yet.

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#3

Re: Identify these plough blades?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

I'm planning a handled, bridle plough plane.

I think it will be a struggle to build a plough with unmatched irons. The 8 I have are a matched set, with identical width, depth and v-grooves. Re-machining the body profiles of an unmatched set will be a lot of work - at the least you would have to re-groove the backs. Alternately, you would need a separate wedge for each iron.

Regards fro Perth

Derek

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#4

Re: Identify these plough blades?

Paul M.

Those look to be a well matched set. I have no idea about the maker.

One thing you should check is to make sure that the taper is the same on all of the blades. I bought a mismatched set from an online dealer, and some of the blades have a slightly different taper than others. This makes the wedge not seat correctly on some of the blades. As long as you have the same taper on all blades, you can make the wedge seat properly on all of them.

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#5

Re: Identify these plough blades?

TomD

This is what i don't get, never having owned a wooden plow plane. There are basically two tapers, the general profile grind, and the angle through the v groove. What do these things do? Does the wedge retain against the groove only? Which would make sense. I need to get them out and have a good look, but it would be easier if someone would just explain it.

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#6

Theoretical knowledge

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I believe the groove sits on the metal skate on the plough.

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#7

Re: Theoretical knowledge

TomD

That is what I figured also, and that the skate is above the level of the wood ramp. Still a little unclear as to the transition, given that at some point the ungrooved part of the blade would run into the elevated part of the ramp. And at some point of withdrawal, the skirt around the v would foul the ramp. Or simpler would be that the only contact is between the skate and the groove, which would reduce the number of surfaces that need to be congruent.

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#8

craigd

Re: Theoretical knowledge

craigd

Pulling out my Mighty Mathieson Plough, I see that 2" of the iron is sticking out past the wood body, the final 1" of that is resting against the skate, with the pointy end of the skate in the groove in the [back of the] iron. The wedge only goes a little bit past the wood, so the the last 2" of iron has no wedging action, ie no wedging action against the groove, the skate needs to protrude a bit forward to be able to keep the iron centered and provide a solid bed (the iron beds against both the wood and skate).

The problem is the screws holding the skate to the body get sloppy and the skate moves back a bit and things don't work as well as they should.

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#9

Re: Theoretical knowledge

TomD

Thanks!

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#10

Re: Identify these plough blades?

Brian Rabinovitch

hi Derek

I believe yours set of large plough plane irons are for a Clarke and Williams (now Old Street Tools). We (IBC) made copies of these for the Barrett and Sons Tools version of that plane. Chris Shwartz did a 4 page article on this plane brand in PWW February 2009 issue.

I have some nice pictures of the complete sets of 8 IBC blades but wasn't sure about how to post them. This is my 1st post on this forum. If you send me your e-mail address I could send you those to look at and then post them if anyone else wanted to see that.

Hope this helps

Brian (IBC)

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#11

Re: Identify these plough blades?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Brian

I would like to see photos of your blades. I will email you, and then post them here for others to see.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#12

Re: Identify these plough blades?

Brian Rabinovitch

Hi Derek,

My e-mail is ibcinc@rogers.com

Thanks

Brian (IBC)

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#13

Re: Identify these plough blades?

Larry Williams

"I believe yours set of large plough plane irons are for a Clarke and Williams (now Old Street Tools)."

They're not, those are old irons.

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#14

Re: Identify these plough blades?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Larry

I said the same to Brian (about the irons being vintage).

Since the orignal post I have discovered that Tyzack used to supply many of the planemakers, who then either stamped their own names on the irons, or not.

The other item, which will interest those with unmatched sets, is that many of these irons appear to have the same profile. They may well work together, and do so quite well.

Perhaps you can comment on this.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Identify these plough blades?

#15

Re: Identify these plough blades?

Larry Williams

There were a number of makers in Great Britain, particularly Sheffield, who supplied edge tools to other makers or dealers. There's no way to know who made those irons, one couldn't even be sure if they were marked.

There's a lot going on in real plow plane irons. Things as simple as the taper and the depth of the groove on the back vary, even among irons with the same maker's marks. None of this was standard and I'm convinced plow planes were made to fit the irons on hand rather than the other way around. There's a slow curve in the back of the iron and it's critical to the way the iron fits the skate and that fit is critical to the performance of the plane. Figuring out how to make irons with that curve and do it so that everything remained uniform was a bit of a challenge for me. Maybe a better machinist or one with a horizontal CNC mill would have an easier time of it. There's a lot more going on in the mating of the iron's groove to the skate than just registering the location of the iron. The shapes and angles should all mate properly and I can't say for sure how careful the earlier plane makers were with the fit, I just know what I try to do.