We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
On a bevel-down plane, the unbeveled side of the blade hits the wood first does the shape of the bevel (concave, convex or flat) matter at all? It seems to me that any bevel shape, so long as the edge straight and is adequately supported, should be the same.... Thanks -Howard
A convex bevel is going to limit the relief angle more than it needs to. If it is a matter of the convex bevel changing relief from something like 20 to 15, it's not that big of a deal. if it's a matter of it effectively changing relief from 15 to 5, then it's a problem.
I don't see any practical reason to have a convex bevel on a plane blade, unless it's a product of necessity from the sharpening method. That would lead me to change my sharpening method.
It's going to occur somewhat on thin plane irons freehand, but you don't necessarily need to encourage it to happen more than absolutely necessary on purpose.
I'm not sure I'd say the unbeveled side touches first. It's the edge, defined as the juncture of both sides coming to a point, that touches first. No?
On to your question about the bevel shape, I go for flat; but as David said, there's not much good to say about convex bevels and probably not much bad to say about some concavity as in a hollow grind.
On the old western wooden planes that I've looked at, many of them had convex bevels as they came to me. However, the convexity didn't seem to affect the effective bevel angle. The convexity seemed to be more a tailing away of the bevel as you went up the bevel away from the edge, as opposed to an increase of the angle at the cutting edge.
I wound up putting a flat bevel on these blades, but in checking the bevel angle with a gauge before doing that, all of them have been in the typical 25-30º range. There may be reasons not to have a convex bevel, but compromising the clearance angle doesn't have to be one of them.
Mine have been like that, too. It think it's from one of two things:
1) someone honing a bevel freehand on a grinding stone
2) someone honing the bevel freehand on a coarse stone
I think it was a matter of necessity if you'd use either of those methods, because if you don't have such a shallow primary bevel without the ability to make a flat secondary bevel, you'd end up with too steep of an effective angle at the end.
It may be that every single one of my old planes was sharpened like that, with a long and very shallow primary stoned or ground onto the blade, and a convex bevel as a product of freehand honing.
With the availability of a tormek, a belt grinder, a dry grinder or a even a guide and a long run of sandpaper, I can't think of any reason to hone the way those old planes were honed, especially on a laminated iron, where a flat precise primary bevel will provide more support to the edge of the plane. Those irons usually aren't that hard, though, so that may be an improvement in theory rather than practice.
When I get an old "junker" japanese plane on ebay, they are often sharpened that same way, suggesting they were used for imprecise work and sharpened as quickly as possible with the grind done by a coarse stone.
True, the back does contact first. I get Pam's point, but that face is the one that meets the wood. If only the edge touched, it would skim, not cut, and back-beveling for squirrelly woods would have no effect.
That said, something to be said about a convex bevel is that, if done properly, not with a secondary bevel, the blade would remain thicker, much closer to the edge. Drawn on paper, it basically looks like a micro-beveled blade, but with a 'bellied out' primary bevel. In theory, this should result in more edge support, and probably a longer lasting edge as a result.
In practice, I would think this is probably more a function of people sharpening in a hurry... Except that carvers generally sharpen their tools this way, too. And if there's any demographic that would have to deal with sharpening on a really advanced level, it's carvers.
In my own practice, I'll stick to hollow and flat bevels for now, because it's just easier to maintain them that way, which translates to higher likelihood of it happening in a reasonable amount of time... Or simply happening at all, some days.
The condition of an old 19th century plane is little indication of how planes were used traditionally. Unless you look at plane irons which you know have been untouched since 1810 or something, you are probably not looking at an iron which has been sharpened by someone skilled in the use of a plane. Most of what you find in flea markets were originally made for carpenters and were later used by farmers, handymen and collectors. Lots have been sharpened by tool dealers who have no idea what they are doing.
I'd figure that most of the planes that I have that are pretty beat have been sharpened a lot by a tradesman in the field somewhere. Perhaps someone who takes only one stone in their toolbox (as an english carpenter father of a friend of mine did).
I indirectly inherited two of his planes, he "used them up" pretty good, and owned only two stones that I'm aware of, a carborundum stone and an arkansas stone.
I do have two planes that I believe were not passed to the plane beaters because they are in just about new 175 year old condition. I can't remember what the bevel looked like exactly, but they weren't sloppy. Still a bit rounded, but not sloppy.
Warren, have you been able to find many planes that are little used?
I know someone who told me a very prominent blacksmith provided unfinished rounded irons for all of the carpenters to whom he supplied irons because that's how every one he found looked (beat).
In 1975 I was in the attic of a 200 year old house. There was a tie beam between two rafters and I jumped up to take a swing on it and came down with a plane iron in my hand. It was uncut (single), thin, laminated, tapered in thickness, slightly tapered in width, mild camber, flat bevel. It could have been there 200 years or so, probably a carpenter's iron.
When I was young I used to interview old craftsmen, guys who were born in the 19th century. Some would tell me how their fathers or grandfathers did things. My conclusion was that they were not in the same league as the 18th century craftsmen. The surviving furniture tends to support this notion. That is why I am sceptical that one would find a plane whose bevel was configured by some great craftsman of the past. It is rare enough to find 18th century tools, let alone those that are untouched.
I've found the same sort of convex bevel thing with used Japanese planes and chisels that I bought on eBay. I'm sure the same caveat about craftsmen vs. farmers applies here, but it's interesting to me that I found the same sort of thing going on in both types of tools.
"I know someone who told me a very prominent blacksmith provided unfinished rounded irons for all of the carpenters to whom he supplied irons because that's how every one he found looked (beat)."
Which brings up the old machinist's joke about the apprentice who spent hours replicating all the wear, burrs, and dings on an old worn-out shaft brought into the shop because the foreman said, when he dumped it on the apprentice's bench, "Make a new shaft, just like this one."
>>Also, I guess Paul Seller's sharpening method must be accommodated, in which case the desired result is a convex bevel. <<
I got a chuckle out of this.
A rounded bevel is the new lastest best every way to do things.
Soon , someone else will make videos and use a different method and then we'll be talking about how horrible this method is and how much better the new method is
Yeah, well this topic is "plane" bevels, but I do have a couple of fairly massive chisels that seem to benefit from convex bevels, which seem to be a natural result of using Sellers' method. I also have a couple or ten planes that have massive chisel like blades, but I haven't yet played with convex bevels on these. They arrived quite used with flat bevels.
My "good" ones have also arrived with flat bevels, and I have generally kept them that way.
I have gotten a couple of junkers (to practice tapping out) that arrived with rounded bevels. The rest of the plane suggests they weren't being used for fine woodworking.
It is possible to make convex bevels on a consistent basis, for instance on a draw knife, axe, Bowie, mortise chisel, etc... But I like flat bevels on most tools. And it is a classic hacker mistake to dub over the edge with each attempt.