New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Posts

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Woodworking and woodturning are creative pursuits that start with an artistic vision or a functional need and end with a solution to the design problem we articulate for ourselves. Whether it’s a piece of furniture or a turned object, or some fixture or process, our creative problem solving ability is what brings it to life.

Creativity is an elusive term. Loosely defined, it is a measure of originality -- in our aesthetics, in our methods of work and in our approach to posing and solving design problems. It is what gives our work its style and individuality.

So, this month's survey is all about creativity and mindsets. How do you design stuff? What styles or embellishments do you prefer? Do you find it easy to come up with new ideas and processes? Is creativity an innate ability or a skill you can learn or both? What else can you tell us about your approach to your work?

As usual, we’ll distill your insights into our next column in Woodworker West magazine.

Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#2

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Ron in Kokomo

Very provocative topic. After millennia, the collective mind of the users has pretty well discovered the useful forms for furniture. So for the most part, creativity is limited to "tweaking" instead of producing truly new forms. There are some who build chairs and chests that stand at a 45 deg. angle. Interesting, for a minute. But then one wonders about utility and the ability to endure.

I know very little about turning, but I think it is different.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#3

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

When I was in high school and early college, I tried writing poetry (along with lots and lots of other people that age...). Most of it was/is pretty dreadful, but there was one poem that wrote itself. I can still remember the moment when it came into my head, as I was getting on a bus in the Financial District of San Francisco (I was working in the Federal Reserve Bank that summer). I did a little more work on it, but it was close to a perfect sonnet when it came to me.

But I doubt I'd have been able to imagine a sonnet if I hadn't learned how they're constructed and spent some time writing really awful ones.

I guess I'm offering an example of the old saying, "Genius is 2% inspiration and 98% perspiration."

I think useful creativity grows out of thinking about whatever the subject is, practicing it, and using that learning to know how to capture the ideas that float through your head and put structure around them.

I've got a notebook of ideas - none of which I've had time to put into actual existence yet - that express ideas that have come into my head, building on what I've learned; and then developed further as I've thought about them.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#4

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

TomD

For the average person, I think creativity is helped along if 1) you have the knack for it. Everyone has it to some degree. 2) Knowledge etc... the wider your appropriate resources, the better. 3) Personality that embraces it, or the courage to risk it.

Aesthetic part is a developed eye. Study of classical forms. Derivative of natural ones.

.

Technical creativity is the putting together of disparate solutions, innovations.

Largely I just think of what I want and if it isn`t available I develop something.

In the last few days I was thinking up a solution for making bowstrings using some of the newer materials. They allow very few strands, but they need the old number of strands at the limb tip or they would tend to make like a cheese cutter. There is a preferred old style of string, but makers find adapting the two tiresome, and some have even left the trade because of it. I have a 40 year accumulation of cordage techniques, from mu boyscout merit badge days. :) I have what i think is a solution, but so fare the extreme slipperiness of the fibers has me on prototype 3.

Likewise I have been thinking of a new approach to arrows, both wood and others. These have to be a perfect match for bow, and other parts. I have an idea that will allow the shafts to be softened which is not currently done. This would make getting a match easier, and also make using heavier shaft easier. I have to work on that one, it is a bigger project.

The other day I was thinking of a different way to make a quick access shotgun belt for SASS. I can`t say what I have in mind, but a normal leather worker without woodworking tools might not have though of this method.

Another thing I was thinking about was a wooden version of the 51. I have quite a few tricks I use for planes, but I have a few ideas, for this one that are novel, and probably silly. Overall though, I need to make something that will stop me from buying the LN tool when they swing through town.

That's some of what I was working on this past week, and there are many other things. Over time

something useful comes out of it and even gets done.

There are a lot of people doing these kinds of things all the time these days, if the internet is anything to go by. And that is just the top of the pyramid who actually write their experiences up. The rest of us are just quietly going about it.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#5

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Bob Hackett

For me the real creativity begins after the skills are mastered. When I first start to learn a new craft or skill I am driven by and focus on learning the tools and techniques. Once I understand and master the technique I can see into the mechanics behind that technique. The understanding and relative mastery of it allow me to reshape it and make it my own. Once I have come to that point I am operating at a level where things are working on an "auto-pilot" level and my hands do the bulk of the work which frees my brain to consider "what if". When I`m in that zone and feel like I am capable of making most any vision manifest then I have the freedom to be creative. It changes the "I can`t " factors that limit me into "why not" and I just figure out how to do what I want to do. I find simple hand tools really help foster this as I don`t have to be so much a slave to my machines or worry about things going horribly wrong in the blink of an eye.

I have found that being able to harvest and season my own wood has also reduced my limitations. Having plenty of what others might consider " free wood" at my disposal allows me to waste all the material I need to and try numerous variations prior to committing the work to the good stuff. I have noticed that once I make something out of "scrap" lumber I do have a tendency to lose a bit of my enthusiasm when making what has now become a copy unless the wood is spectacular or I change at least a few of the aspects of the project.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#6

1% Inspiration, 99% Perspiration

James Watriss

I understand the 'it's all been done' mindset, but I'm not trying to come up with a new version, or an ugly impractical novelty.

Some of the creative process isn't so much design, as figuring out a process. Just having the idea isn't enough. Rough sketches and almost have it down rough drafts and patchy prototypes don't really count either, because a fully developed idea should manifest cleanly. I've tried different routes to the end result, deliberate craftsmanship, and free-form improvised sketching in wood. Both have their merits, but finding a solid way to appropriately use both takes a while to really master, and I don't know if I'm there yet.

Creativity isn't just novelty for novelty's sake. It's not anarchy.

Creativity also isn't mindless repetition or rearranging of traditional forms.

Real creativity involves the long process of taking a spark to finished fruition. Some of the creative effort goes into designing the piece. Most of it goes into figuring out how to make the idea into something real... And I find that the ideas only flow when I'm in the midst of that effort.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#7

Sorry... Was a response to the original question


Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#8

Spot on as usual

Bob Hackett

I think that final paragraph was exceptionally well worded.