New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

restoration vs cleaning antique planes

Posts

restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#1

restoration vs cleaning antique planes

tcarlson

I started going through my plane collection and have been restoring some of them, after restoration they are much more appealing for display and they are still totally useable. A friend told me I am nuts for restoring these and told me, he would just store them. After recently aquiring a near perfect bedrock 608 smooth bottom flat-top, I am looking at making the cast iron look new. I am just looking for some opinions and ideas, thank you. TC

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#2

Your call

ron in kokomo

As nice as they are, 608's are not part of the priceless antique treasures of America. They made a bunch of them. I have a nice one and have had others.

Get it the way you want it.

My $.02

Ron

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#3

Re:  restoration vs cleaning antique planes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

They're tools. Clean them up and use them.

If you have a plane that was in very limited production and is highly valuable - maybe that's different. But there are darned few of those.

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#4

Moses Yoder

Re:  restoration vs cleaning antique planes

Moses Yoder

What are you doing to "restore" them? What are you doing to make the iron look like new? Obviously, they are your planes; you can do what you want with them, so far there is no government regulation. On the cast iron, how long will it look new? I once received a 603 that was lightly rusted and polished the sides to remove the rust; I couldn't wait for it to get some patina back so it would look "right".

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#5

Re:  restoration vs cleaning antique planes

TomD

Back in the day, I used to blue a lot of my tools to get rid of the new car smell. Same thing with not overly restoring tools, a nice dark stain is pretty nice. If there is rust, use the battery charger method, it just gets rid of the red stuff, and leaves the rest. As a craftsman you should be able to repro whatever finish you want at the end of the day. Also, you should be able to add to the used value of the tool, always assuming anyone cares about these kinds of things in a 100 years, anyway.

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#6

Re:  restoration vs cleaning antique planes

tcarlson

I plan on just using steel wool and wd40, the 608 dosn't get much use anyways, its like two feet long and not all that practical, the last time I really used a hand plane, a #5 would pretty much do anything I wanted it too. Thanks for all the responses and ideas, have a good day.

tc

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#7

Re:  restoration vs cleaning antique planes

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

With most old tools there is no way to know any past tool owners mindset on tool maintenance. Your pristeen tool may have gone through several sandings to remove surface rust in the past. :\

Clean away.

Joe

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#8

Injustices I've visited upon my planes

James Watriss

I have (no particular order, and not to all planes)

-Lapped the soles flat on a long flat surface

-Ground sole and sides flat and square with a (dull) disc grinder.

-Used said disc grinder to flatten the sole of an old, cast iron infill.

-Drilled and tapped the sides of cast iron planes to install set screws near the mouth to make lateral adjustments more controllable. (Even did this to my L-N #4.)

-(No comment on doing this to the infill plane.)

-(No comment on installing a second set of screws towards the top of said infill, to fix lateral play, and make set-up easier.)

-Followed David Charlesworth's advice (found in the first book) about using carborundum powder to grind mating surfaces to match each other after scraping them down, filing the forward part of the mouth to clear chips, and so on.

-Smoothed out and refinished totes.

-Ground and sharpened blades.

-Swapped knobs and totes with other planes that I found to be more comfortable.

-Used black nail polish to touch up chipped japanning.

-Very seriously considered painting a buddy's Bedrock #8 with a lovely shade of pink after he stole the bolts out of my bench.

All of the above is fair game... It's all about making a more useable tool.

But if I find out you drilled a hang hole anywhere on the plane, you're out of the club.

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#9

Out of curiosity....

John in NM

What is really wrong with a hang hole? I think one of mine has one, thanks to a previous owner. To tell the truth, I can't even remember now - because it does not effect use at all. Sure it's a bit ugly, but that would be my only complaint. Even if LN started adding factory hang holes it wouldn't keep me from buying their stuff now and then :D

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#10

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Injustices I've visited upon my planes

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I've done everything on that list, except for the infill modifications - and that's only because I've never owned an infill. :|

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#11

Moses Yoder

Re: Out of curiosity....

Moses Yoder

That's an interesting question. I think if I won a couple billion in the lottery I would buy the Mona Lisa painting, take the hanging mechanism off the back, drill a hole right above her forehead and hang it with a nail.

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#12

Clearly its not interesting...

John in NM

Open and shut from your view :D

While I do not advocate drilling holes in planes and hanging them on pegboard, I do not see the big deal if it has been done. You have not convinced me that this is an evil on the level of defacing a unique work of art, but then hyperbole rarely convinces anyone of anything :D Formulating a rational argument will be more effective.

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#13

But what if it's a not a hang hole

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but the first step in drilling out excess metal for making a racing plane?

Really no different in function from corrugations.

I'd never do it, but my only objection to finding one on a plane is when it's been badly done - off center, for instance.


img

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#14

Re: But what if it's a not a hang hole

James Watriss

I've heard of belt sander races, this is a new one on me.

I can't wait to see where the shavings come out...

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#15

Re: Clearly its not interesting...

Pam Niedermayer

If you're going to use those nasty metal planes, probably better not to drill new rust spots.

Pam

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#16

Like this one, for instance *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

One of the better-known racing planes - light, ready to go really fast. See linky


http://www.supertool.com/etcetera/deadends/hardy.htm

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#17

rust pitting... nature's corrugation   


Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#18

Re: Out of curiosity....

david weaver

The only thing wrong with a hang hole is that you can't undo it.

You know, it's strange that people are so offended by a hang hole when the collectors of early american planes are not quite so bothered by them - where much prettier (than a bench plane) moulding planes had a hole drilled right through the grip at the front so workmen could hang the plane.

But like everyone else, I won't pay full price for a hang hole plane, because nobody else will. I see a lot of flea market flippers trying to sell planes for what I'd consider full price, despite the hang hole, but I guess a person trying to make money will always look for a mark.

It wouldn't bother me at all on a plane I intended to keep indefinitely, but I'd want the discount on purchase to make it worth my while.

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#19

Re: Injustices I've visited upon my planes

TomD

"-Drilled and tapped the sides of cast iron planes to install set screws near the mouth to make lateral adjustments more controllable. (Even did this to my L-N #4.)"

A simple way to get part of that is a droplet of epoxy glue on each side of the mouth. Completely reversible.

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#20

Re: Injustices I've visited upon my planes

James Watriss

Fair point, if I was interested in reversibility. But I'm more concerned with usability than in maintaining any pretense of a 'like new' condition.

I believe that all tools which are destined for use, arrive in your hands as raw materials for making something better. Sometimes it's just a matter of sharpening the iron. Sometimes you need to overhaul and modify.

Re: restoration vs cleaning antique planes

#21

Re: Injustices I've visited upon my planes

TomD

+1 Though I would probably still use epoxy.