New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Name those stones!

Posts

Name those stones!

#1

Name those stones!

Scott in Douglassville

Okay, probably a long shot, but as I was getting ready to buy new waterstones, I remembered I had some in a box. Any able to give me a clue as to what I've got, or the order in which to use them?


I know, likely not. Any help is appreciated.

Scott

Re: Name those stones!

#2

The left one...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Looks like a honyama suita (I think) finishing stone I bought from LV some years ago (and still to be used yet :| )

The other three I have no clue, but you should clean them up, that would help a lot in ID'ing them...

DC

Re: Name those stones!

#3

Re: Name those stones!

wilbur

Can't help with actual identification, as I'm not that good, but a good way to figure out how to use them is to take a spare chisel and use each one to get a quick idea as to which ones are coarser, and which ones are finer, and take your best guess at ordering them. Then work the chisel on each one from coarsest to finest, and use a magnifying glass to check out the scratch patterns to confirm that you are really going from coarse to fine. You should be able to see the scratch patterns get smaller as you go along.

Re: Name those stones!

#4

Fred, Barney, Betty, and Wilma. Done!


Re: Name those stones!

#5

DAMMIT!  Now I have to clean the Coke

Bruce, a MN Galoot

off my monitor :D

Re: Name those stones!

#6

Re: Name those stones!

John Aniano in Central NJ

Scott,

I have to disagree with Denis - I believe the one on the left is a rather coarse stone - I have one that looks virtually identical. Same colors and same swirly pattern. But I don't know the name of it though. I guess mine is around 300 grit or so. I flattened all the sides with my slotted Norton SiC flattener and the resulting stone is very nice to have! Mine will sharpen HSS blades. The other stones I can't identify, sorry.

John

Re: Name those stones!

#7

The first stone..

david weaver

.. looks to be an iyo type stone. The same stones that fujibato shows either being used as stones or being used as pottery. It does look fairly coarse. It wouldn't make a lot of sense for it to be followed by the naniwa (or similar) second stone if it were in the usual range fujibato sells iyo stones (800-3000?).

Using it would tell really quickly, though.

I could get by with that set no problem, maybe with the addition of either MDF and honing compound, or a finer finishing stone.

You can get a surprisingly good edge with a tanba aoto and a piece of clean bare leather strop, but it is a sloppy stone and that appears to be a small piece.

Still, I wouldn't discard them as junk, I would try them out and see how you like them and make your purchases around what you need.

If the iyo stone seems to cut slowly and it's hard, then do something to abrade the surface. Those types of stones will cut fairly fast when they have a slurry, but not so fast if they're hard and the surface is allowed to wear a little.

Re: Name those stones!

#8

No! That's Mick, Keith, Ronnie and Charlie


Re: Name those stones!

#10

Re: second from right.

Gordon Thomas

is a natural aoto blue mountain stone. around 2500 grit. a little gem. Hida carries them.

cheers,

Gordon