New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Miller's Falls No.1 Cigar Shave

Posts

Miller's Falls No.1 Cigar Shave

#1

Miller's Falls No.1 Cigar Shave

Jim O'Neal

I recently purchased a Miller's Falls No.1 Cigar Shave. I thought I had properly sharpened the blade but now it will not cut. Does anyone know of any references to which I can refer to learn how to properly sharpen a blade for a cigar shave?

Re: Miller's Falls No.1 Cigar Shave

#2

Re: Miller's Falls No.1 Cigar Shave

James Watriss

Well, there's not much to it. Keep the inside radius polished, (Find an appropriate radius maple dowel, and charge with sropping compound) and sharpen the bevel on the flat. But I'm assuming you checked to see how the edge 'felt' before use. The truth may simply be that you haven't gotten used to the tool yet.

In use, the cigar shave's genetic heritage is somewhere between a really weird spokeshave and an autistic draw knife, with a lot of unique quirks that are all its own. Regular spokeshaves will allow you to register on the sole, and you don't need to pay as much attention to approach angle, you just slap them down and pull, and they work. You can't do that with a cigar shave. And a draw knife has angled handles, and doesn't have a throat, so it's pretty easy to play with skew and approach angle, and get what you want by feel. The way the handles were designed on the cigar shave, there's no obvious intuitive way to hold the thing. If you tilt it back, you lose your relief angle. If you tilt too far forward, you may very well roll the blade out of the wood. Without angled handles, you really have to roll it back and forth until you feel that it's cutting the right way, and just 'roll with it.' (pardon the pun.)

And on top of THAT, if you keep the throat too tightly closed, you lose a lot of the relief angle behind the edge that you need to get a blade to cut anyway. So regular smoothing plane wisdom will avail you naught: tight mouths don't help much with a cigar shave. Quite to the contrary. It's very possible that the throat is what's giving you problems. You need a large enough throat to get your relief angle, but small enough to keep the chips flowing through.

Even if it was pretty dull, you should theoretically be able to make it work. It would be a rough and torn out surface, but the tool would be functional. My suggestion is that you go back, open the throat up some, and play with the tool some more. Roll it back and forth while you draw it along the wood... close our eyes, and pay attention to what your hands are telling you. There's a much greater need to work by feel with this tool than there is with most others.

Re: Miller's Falls No.1 Cigar Shave

#3

Pulling

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've not used mine much - being deeply committed to carpentry on our house at the moment - but I did find that pulling it worked better than pushing, at least on inside corners. My sense is that this is so because our wrists are better designed to rotate in than out.