New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Help please - sawing technique issue??

Posts

Help please - sawing technique issue??

#1

Help please - sawing technique issue??

Guillaume Dery

Hi guys,

For those who aren't aware, I am getting more than my fair share of handtool time while finishing 1200 square feet of basement space. As the only time I get to work is when my daughter and wife are asleep, everything is done by hand. This will be the subject of another post at another time.

This leads me to my problem. After the first few hundred framing members were cut by hand, I was quite smug about my ability to split a line with a panel saw. I was even joking that I was more precise with the handsaw than I was with my dovetail saw. Well... pride goeth before the fall.

I seem to have developed an issue with my saw technique. I don't even understand how it is possible.

Lately my sawcuts are dead on my line across the face of the cut, perfectly square down one side but seem askew by a few degrees down the other side. How is this possible?

I thought it it may be the saw plate so I tried another western handsaw and the LV toolbox folding dozuki... same results. The only common denominator is me so I am obviously the source of the problem.

Please help me gain insight into this problem so I can try to correct my now horrible technique.

Thanks,

Guillaume

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#2

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Hard to diagnose "over the wires."

Are you holding the saw lightly, and keeping your body aligned straight to the cut? The saw plate is obviously twisting a bit in the cut, and/or the deviation from straight isn't obvious at the top and edge facing you but is more so on the far side.

One thing I've learned when I'm trying to do "finish"* cuts in large-section wood like a framing member is to work in two cuts: cut with the saw held kind of flat on the top of the stock, then lean over and get a cut going vertically on the far edge. Work back and forth until these have enough depth to guide the saw, then begin tilting it to the normal 45 degrees of a crosscut. Once you have a good kerf going, it'll guide the saw to a cleaner cut.

Sawing, like hammering, is one of those skills that looks dead simple but actually requires a very subtle dance of fine and gross motor skills that can be acquired only with lots of practice.

*Meaning I don't want to have to fuss around cleaning them up.

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#3

Ellis Walentine

No help here

Ellis Walentine

It sounds like the saw is actually twisting in the kerf, which is quite a trick, and especially confusing because you say you have the same trouble with quite different saws that no doubt have wide variations in plate thickness and set. I don't think I could even duplicate those results.

What are we missing?

Ellis

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#4

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

wilbur

If you've gone from cutting framing members to joinery cuts, one habit you might have picked up is forcing the saw through the cut. I find that for me, whenever I find myself going off line, it's usually because I am rushing the cut.

Try slowing down and see if the problem goes away.

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#5

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The set of the saw not only gives clearance so that the saw does not rub in the kerf, it also gives a small amount of freedom to alter the direction of the cut. It has to be this way because one has to be able to alter the cut slightly as he goes. Even if the sawyer is perfect the saw can wander slightly in a long kerf if the saw is less than perfect or if there is something odd about the grain.

You are probably twisting a little unconsciously. Very gentle twisting (very small persuasion) with the saw ought to correct the problem. Aggressive twisting will create bigger problems.

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#6

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I agree that there is some subtle twisting happening. One solution that has worked for me is to not grip the saw handle so hard. It doesn't need a death grip, only guidance.

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#7

I've duplicated them more than once

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

This was, and still can be, an issue for me when cutting framing-sized members. As Warren points out, the kerf is wider than the saw plate - so if there's anything causing a tendency for the cut to move to one side, whether it's uneven sharpening/set on the saw or an unconscious twist on the part of the sawyer, the saw will tend to run off in that direction. And, yes, I imagine the saw plate is twisting in the process.

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#8

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

Joe Bailey

+1 on avoiding the dreaded "death grip" -- that was one of my first two thoughts.

You are probably also "trying too hard." The natural tendency, especially when moving from cabinet work to framing, is to take a tighter grip, and give it a little more muscle. In reality, only the choice of tool should change. The other principles - such as "letting the saw do the work" - remain the same.

The other is this --make sure that your shoulder and elbow are moving in the proper (similar) axis. Tiny misalignments at the beginning of the cut are amplified over the course (length) of the cut.

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#9

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

Paul M.

One more possibility... did you recently get new glasses or contacts? Sometimes asigmatism corrections can really mess with your perception of what is or is not straight.

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#10

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

Charles

Pretty sure the only way this can happen is if the blade is being bent in the cut - the blade is slightly in winding probably by you torquing it over ever so slightly. You're putting too much 'hand' in your technique. Much like golf, you don't want your hands to take over your swing you don't want your hand to take over your sawing.

Lighten way up on your grip. Change your stance around a little to see if you can get back on track.

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#11

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

Guillaume Dery

Thanks to all for the replies. I certainly am conscious of the grip and have a very light grip on my saw (at least when I start). I will pay attention to body position and monitor my grip through the cut as well.

I will try to take pictures of the offensive cuts tomorrow.

Guillaume

Who hates devolving in his technique

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#12

Stephen Shepherd

Don't forget to squint, & hold your tongue right 


Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#13

The position of the tongue is critical!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Mine is always to the side. Which side doesn't matter, but never straight ahead :D

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#14

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

AlanWS

Could your square be off, and your cuts actually OK?

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#15

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

Curt Putnam

Just a thought. I've learned that sawing by ear is important. Is the sweet song of the saw changing as the cut proceeds? I'll bet that it is. A change in sound only alerts you to the problem, not the nature of it.

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#16

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

Guillaume Dery

Doubtful as for evaluation purposes I extended the line from the face down both sides (front and back). I am dead on splitting the line in the front but the rear of the cut is skewed about 2 degrees (I didn't really measure so this is an eyeball guess).

I seemed to have picked up a nasty habit and need to isolate and eliminate.

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#17

Get a Grip

ron in Kokomo

I would have to guess, from here that is has something to do with your grip on the saw. You may be even changing grip pressure somewhere in the stroke without even being aware of it.

I struggle with this myself.

ron

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#18

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Get a Grip

Stephen Shepherd

And try sighting the cut from the opposite side of the saw, that you do now and see if that changes the angle of the cut.

I notice that when I use my bow saw, it tends to wander to the side I am sighting on, so I sight from the other side and it corrects.

Stephen

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#19

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

Mark kuzee

I would like to hear a little more info regarding what your attempting to cut and the type of saw you have.

You mentioned "framing members" and "panel saw". When I hear framing members I think of 2 bys. I panel saw (24" or less in length) may not be the best choice of tool. For framing a good 26" 8 pt is right in the ball park for usability. Framing work is typically not to fussy work. A little out of square is no big deal.

I would suspect even with a panel saw it may be your method. Sawing is all hand/eye/arm/shoulder. No upper body. Yes grip is important but not everything. I have noticed the same tendency in myself. To much set (kerf) does allow the saw to track on its own. If your motion is incorrect the saw will telegraphs that to the wood.

Or the saw is telling you your smugness is way out of line. If this began to be a problem with the onset of smugness it may be the saw telling you your really need some humility. Who hasn't been taught a lesson by a tool.

"Don't anthropomorphize your tools...they don't like it".

Mark

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#20

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

Guillaume Dery

Hi Mark,

thanks for the reply. As to your questions, you are spot on the money. I am cutting 2X lumber and yes it's a 24" panel saw (I am planing on adding a full size handsaw to my arsenal at the end of the month but right now, the panel saw is what I have).

As to the saw, it's a 9 point Wenzloff (the ones carried by LV (a super nice gift from a fan))

You are correct that framing does not require great precision and a 2 degree slant is nothing I can't work around. My issue is that I used to saw dead square and I find this devolution of my technique quite alarming. I want to diagnose what I started doing wrong and fix it before I get back to more critical work once I finish building the workshop.

As a general rule, the Wenzloffs are set pretty tight so I don't think that is a huge factor. Plus as pretzel lumber from the Borg is notoriously wet (even though it is stamped kiln dried, that is laughable), I don't really want to reduce the set.

It absolutely has to be my technique. I just can't figure out what I could be doing to only twist through half the cut (I am consistently square on one side and off a degree or 2 in the rear).

Guillaume

(who will go apologize to his saws in case they are punishing me for my initial smugness)

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

#21

Re: Help please - sawing technique issue??

Mark kuzee

We need to try something different to resolve this.

We can rule out the tool. Mike builds a fine saw. I have one of his backsaws and it is nice.

A good tool will expose technique issues. You can blame a poorly sharpened saw for a lot of woes but that is more than likely not the case here.

Basics...

1 How high is your saw horse? Mine is 24". Most modern saw horses are designed for power tools.

2. is your dominant eye the same as your dominant hand? Dominant eye and Shoulder socket and hand should somewhat line up when sawing.

3. Point the index finger straight when holding the saw. kinda like holding a hot dog between your thumb and index finger. Only put the three remaining fingers through the handle.

My sense is the cut may be starting out square but not plumb. This would occur if you have alignment issues like in point #2. To start a cut square and plumb and have it go off in a 2 by 4 would mean your blade was flexing.

Try starting the cut and then once you go around 2" in put a combination square on the board next to the blade and see if your still plumb. OK?

Once a cut is started correctly the saw "knows" what to do. Maybe stop trying to influence the saw. Hate to get all Zen on you, but the saw like all tools is and extension of your body and mind. Don't over think it.

You can start a rather square cut by watching the reflection of the board your cutting on the blade of the saw. Just set your saw on the board and look at the side of the saw plate. The reflection should line up with the board. This will not indicate a plumb cut.

Keep your saw working in the same angle. Try not to rock it to much.

Try cutting a 2 by 8 or something larger. Same problem?

Try putting your board on your bench and hip height with the small side up and try the cut again.

Same result?

The other thing is practice....

Keep working on it.

mark