New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Japanese Chisels

Posts

Japanese Chisels

#1

Japanese Chisels

Roy Girolami------WebKitFormBoundary9yANUT8mn8C+Zo

Back in the day, I would buy chisels from the Japan Woodworker and had to choose which brand to buy. I usually picked the middle range and avoided the very most expensive and the cheapest. Back then, they didn't carry the folded, acid-etched ones that command a premium. Anyway, I ended up with a few that I have used and enjoyed for twenty years or more. They were mostly Yoshitora with boxwood handles and were categorized as temple carpenter chisels, not bench chisels. I liked the longer length. i noticed that the recent catalogs no longer carry this brand and when I google the name, I don't get too much. i have to assume the maker no longer makes them, or no longer sells them here. So if I look at the new catalogs, is there any way to figure out what level quality I have in comparison to what is on sale?

Roy Girolami

Apex, NC

Re: Japanese Chisels

#2

Re: Japanese Chisels

wilbur

Going for middle of the line is a pretty good strategy. That had a lot of bearing on my decision on which Japanese chisels to get when I was getting started.

I wouldn't hesitate to contact Japan Woodworker (or any of the other Japanese tool dealers) and see what they might recommend that would be comparable to the chisels that you have. Most of the dealers sell a "temple carpenter" chisel or an equivalent.

Re: Japanese Chisels

#3

Re: Japanese Chisels

TomD

Partly you can tell from how they are to use. I have bought chisels from all three levels, from about 15 bucks a chisel to 350. The cheaper ones are good chisels, but it was pretty obvious when I got them, even when I didn't have much experience that they weren't special. I have cheap chisels from LV back in early 80s, and also from JWW about 10 years ago, and they were not great. I have some lower to high priced chisels that are great, no question that they are outstanding. And I have used some of these for 30 years. I have a few elite, these are expensive, but not arty in my case. They are exceptional, and really it is hard to understand why they are better. There isn't something you can really see, but they are easier to cut with, and easier to sharpen , and nice to look at. I have also seen some very high end chisels that were tourist grade, designed to suck in and cheat amateurs. Same brand I should add as the best I own. I think they use their 2nds to flog at westerners.

So trust your own instincts. You can tell what you have.

Re: Japanese Chisels

#4

Re: Japanese Chisels

david weaver

I would work backwards and find out what is good anywhere.

I'd say that good service chisels that I've used are koyama-ichi and chutaro imai chisels.

They would be less than exorbitantly expensive, and what they lack vs. the really high dollar chisels would mostly be related to sharpening ease vs. edge holding (that is, they hold an edge well, but some higher dollar chisels might hold an edge as well and sharpen more easily).

I'm ignoring the decorative chisels because I think they're a waste of money unless you find a set of them somewhere for really cheap because someone is unloading them.

Re: Japanese Chisels

#5

Re: Japanese Chisels

Paul M.

Hi Roy,

I have big hands. When I pick up standard Japanese chisels they disappear in my hands. Some operations are fine with these tiny chisels, but most are rather small.

I picked up some Matsumura "firmer" chisels which are beefier all around. The handles are longer and wider, and the blade is thicker. I enjoy these and have had no issues with them over several years. These also fall into the "middle" range in price which was also where I was aiming. They are available from Japan Woodworker or from Craftsman Studios.

We think alike!

Re: Japanese Chisels

#6

Re: Japanese Chisels

Manny

You might try contacting Jay VanArsdale through the DaikuDojo.net website. He owns a few Yoshitora from the days JWW used to carry them. He can probably give you an opinion on how they compare to the newer brands that his students show up with.

A fellow I met in Hawaii, while visiting my in-laws, had a set of seven Yoshitora for sale, purchased from JWW back in the day. I asked Jay about them and he gave me an unequivocal "Buy them!" So, they must be good. This was about the time my woodworking was tapering off, so I haven't used them much and can't give you an honest assessment compared to the more recent brands. However, based on his recommendation to buy them I would venture to guess they are probably above today's selection of mid-quality chisels. That's just a guess though. He could tell you more.