New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

Posts

Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#1

Stephen Shepherd

Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

Stephen Shepherd

I want to make one of these.

Stephen


img

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

Moses Yoder

According to my autocad program, the angle as it sets in the picture is aproximately 28°, 27.8° according to my lines. I am not really good enough at math to figurer out how that would translate if the plane set flat instead of at an angle.

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#3

No, but

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you've got that plane body in your shop, and a protractor of some kind, and a suitable piece of steel that you can insert and wedge temporarily in place, it would be easy enough to figure out.

If, of course, your only contact with that plane is through the internet, it gets harder.

I've got a wooden miter plane on which the iron beds at about 30 degrees, just barely enough clearance behind (with a 25 degree bevel) to allow it to be bevel-down.

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#4

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

TomD

Looks like 35 degrees to me. It isn't the lowest end of the low. If it is 28 in cad then leveling it up will add degrees. And yet it clearly isn't 45 degrees. I have a 35 degree bevel down plane and it looks reasonably similar. I suspect if you start to draw it out, you will quickly narrow it down further, like say 30 won't stay within the block, or leave too little aft of the block.

If you cut up a 4x4 to basic dimensions, then cut the ramp area totally out. Then you made a few ramps at different angles. One could do that in less time than all this typing is taking, and it would quickly zero you in. You just shove the angles into place from the back. This is not an attempt to make a working plane, just a quick and dirty mock-up.

For instance, I made several Jack planes as an exercise. The first one I made is really an excellent plane, but I made the handle a little too high, and the blade a little too low. with the result that the blade runs into the handle and gets in the way of adjusting. The plane took a certain amount of time to make, and I would have saved all that time if I had roughed it out in 2x material. Most of the time was in carving the handle.

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#5

45 degrees

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think the bed is between 40 and 50 degrees. It is somewhat deceptive because the top of the body of the plane is not flat. It is higher at the back than at the front.

Here are the dimensions of this plane:

Length 16 cm

Height 10.5 cm (includes tote)

Width 5.6 cm

Length of bed 10.2 cm

Width of mouth 4.5 cm

I would guess that the block is about 5 cm high at the front, 7 cm maybe 7.5 at the back.

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#6

My best guess, by eye, is close to 45°, too. 


Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#7

I'm with Tom here

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

35, maybe a trifle more, but less than 40.

DC

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#8

Why ask?

James Watriss

Why not just bed the new plane at the pitch that you want, instead of simply replicating what you have?

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#9

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Why ask?

Stephen Shepherd

I don't own this plane it is in a museum in Europe, from 1596. I would like to make an exact copy as possible.

Stephen

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#10

measure it

Bill Tindall

Moses apparently imported it into Autocad (how I wish I could do that) and made the measurement, which is in error by the tilt in the photograph and perhaps some parallax error. This estimate could be refined by drawing a line at what you think is parallel to the plane's long axis along the base of the ramp and then making a measurement with a protractor. It looks to be close to 30 degrees from the horizontal. Is 30 degrees reasonable from what you know about the plane?

To further refine the measurement photograph a known plane in this orientation to determine parallax corrections.

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#11

Mercer's picture *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is a link to Mercer's picture, which shows the profile of the plane somewhat better. You can see how the top is scooped out toward the front. A 30 degree bed would be improbable for a plane like this. Mercer's picture confirms that a 30 degree bed would have the mouth at the very front of the plane. I still think 45 degrees is close.


Mercer picture, bottom of page

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#12

Agree

Bill Tindall

Measuring the angle from the more straight on picture yields something close to 45 degrees. In the original picture the plane is rotated toward the camera, an operation that lowers the observed angle.

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#13

Re: Agree

TomD

Another way of looking at it is that if the bed looks to you like in is 1.44 times the height of the side then it is 45degrees. Some of it is in shadow, but that seems unlikely to me from the link photos.

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#14

Goodman

Larry Williams

In The History of Woodworking Tools, page 65, Goodman specifically says it's bedded at 45º. "...With regard to the plane itself, it is of beech, 6 3/4 in. long and 2 1/4 in.wide, with the iron set at an angle of 45 degrees...."

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#15

Re: Why ask?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Have you e-mailed the museum staff already and gotten no results? I'd think they would be happy to help a fellow scholar.

Re: Any guesses on the angle of the plane blade?

#16

That depends

Bill Tindall

Some museums, the one in Philly for example, include in their mission a teaching/research component. These places are accommodating to persons researching a topic or making a reproduction. Other places, Winterthur for example, aim to profit from their collections and therefore erect obstacles to someone wanting to do a reproduction, but they are more accommodating to persons doing research. I would suggest approaching the question from the research angle and ask in the context of researching angles used on this sort of plane.