New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

A little (!) gloat...

Posts

A little (!) gloat...

#1

A little (!) gloat...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I must have been a good boy ;)

Background: today I had lunch with two of my former bosses. One of the two, who I worked with for something like 17 years, knows me well, especially about my interest in woodworking. He's not a woodworker, and has no interest in the hobby, but his father worked ages ago at the Stanley factory in Roxton Pond, Qc.

You know where this is going...

His father (who I gather did much more woodworking) left him some stuff... One item is a Stanley 55. Since I knew he was not using it I bugged him for over ten years to let me buy it off him. But he always resisted for some reason.

Today, when we met at our lunch place, he told me that he had something for me in the trunk of his car... And that it was kind of heavy... So we go there, and there it was, a Stanley 55 in its box!!! So I asked him how much for the plane, and he GAVE IT TO ME FOR FREE!!!

Oh, did I forget to mention that the plane is not in good shape, it is not in mint shape, IT IS BRAND NEW!!! Still wrapped in the paper! There is still a tag attached to a depth stop! Cutters look unused at all! Unreal...

The manual has a print date of Sep. 23, 1949, which suggest that the plane was sold (if sold it was) in 1950 or thereabouts... Only caveats is rust at one end of the short rods and on a part yet to be identified. And I'm counting 54 cutters only; the box says that there are 53 cutters in the box (true) and two in the plane already (but I see only one). I'll have to inventory the cutters to see if one is really missing or if Stanley doesn't count like I do...

I'm still pinching myself...

DC

And if that wasn't enough, he told me that he has some kind of dowel making machine that he will bring to me the next time we go for lunch (which happens to be on my birthday!). He told me that thing was quite heavy, can't wait to see it...

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#2

Indeed, you must have been

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

surely, your ex-boss deserves a little made-by-you box or something for that.

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#3

Re: A little (!) gloat...

Philip Duffy

Denis, You are the Great Gloat Champ!

Have not seen one of your great pens lately -- show some please. Phil

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: A little (!) gloat...

Moses Yoder

If he is talking about the Stanley dowel cutter, worth more than your mint 55, then I really am jealous. See http://www.woodmagazine.com/woodworking-tools/hand/the-stanley-no-77-dowel-and-rod-turner/ . You're not going to use that plane, are you?

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#5

the last cutter...

Patrick Gibbons

is probably the slitter with another blade in the mouth.

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#6

agree 


Re: A little (!) gloat...

#7

Re: A little (!) gloat...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

that might even be a medium gloat!

Holy moley!

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#8

Re: A little (!) gloat...

Guillaume Dery

@#$#$%%^

Lucky SOB! You better bring it for oohing and aaahing at our next meeting.

Good on you.

Guillaume

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#9

Re: A little (!) gloat...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I'll bring the plane if you bring your new "hammers" :D

DC

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#10

Re: A little (!) gloat...

Guillaume Dery

Only if you help carry them and then bring them back to my basement...

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#11

Well, that's the dilemma...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I know that by using the plane I will diminish its value. However, I do not intend to sell it, as it is a gift from a friend to start with. Yet I would not want to "steal from history" by using a new plane just for my selfish pleasure... Heck, if Pat Leach is any indication, I might not like the plane at all, then I would have wasted the "new" status for nothing...

Opinions? Suggestions?

DC

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#12

Sounds like you're right

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

What's the slitter for? I only have very basic knowledge of that plane...

DC

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#13

Jack Guzman from Maine

Use it-gently

Jack Guzman from Maine

That tool was not built as a work of art .It was designed and built to be used. I think you have an obligation to at least run it gently through a piece of perfect,straight grained wood. At least once. How much would such an act diminish the $$$ amount of it's worth? I know I would try it. Money/worth/value are given too much importance in this age.MHO---Jack

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#14

Moses Yoder

Re: Works of art

Moses Yoder

Most tools are not intentionally meant as works of art, but they are. Especially tools from that era. I have lots of tools I use in my shop, and I have some tools in the original box in near mint condition that I feel would be destroying history to use. Kind of like driving a Rolls Royce on freshly salted snowy roads. Yes, trying it out to see if it works is acceptable. Using it as a standard tool like any other tool is sacreligious. You could buy a beat up rusty #45 and use that for the same purpose.

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#15

The slitter

Patrick Gibbons

does exactly what it's called. It slits thin boards. There have been times I wish I had a slitter because ripping a narrow piece from a narrow piece is almost impossible otherwise.

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#16

Re: Sounds like you're right

Mark Nowicki

http://www.abebooks.com/servlet/SearchResults?an=jones&sts=t&tn=the+complete+woodworker&x=0&y=0

This book has a chapter titled: "The Stanley Universal Plane And How To Use It" It covers the parts, the setup for grooving, ploughing and slitting, matching and sash mouldings. It also covers chamfers, edge mouldings and hollows and rounds and many more.

Re: A little (!) gloat...

#17

This sums it up nicely.... *LINK*

John in NM

Though personally, I'd sell the thing to some one who wanted to pay through the nose for "pristine" and buy something usefull with the proceeds - usefull in terms of condition, not design - no intention of denigrating the plane, just the situation that produces this dilemma :D My decision to sell such an object would have nothing to do with sharing the dilemma, more a matter of financial advantage.

I came across the blog post below while reading about knives. Another field where the "collector" instinct has confused many a user. Those who worry about "stealing from history" do not understand history. It is not a moment in time, to be preserved for ever. It continues, you are part of it, and the tool you may or may not use is part of your participation in it. Use it with a clear conscience and know that in doing so you've lived rather than watched.


http://rumanddonuts.blogspot.com/#!/2011/04/marks-left-on-tools.html