Re: what is the secret?
david weaver
Paper needs to be stuck hard and tight to something, else you'll have dubbing at the toe and heel, and all around the edges.
You need to place your hands somewhere such that you're not going to be rocking the plane and you need to make a repetitive stroke - that is, the process will work better if the position of your hands doesn't change and the stroke is exactly the same every time.
A long lap makes this easier, because you can just lock your weight down on a plane and walk 3 feet with it, and then take it to the back of the lap and do it again, and again, and again. A totally different thing than what you'd do planing and extending your arms at the end.
Check the work with a straight edge fairly often. When people just rock violently back and forth, i can see why they would create a banana shaped plane. If you are getting a banana shaped plane, I guess the game may not be the game for you (not talking to you specifically, bill, just saying in general, if the results can't be had, either a flatter plane or a machine shop may be the answer).
I would guess that my longer planes are probably a couple of thousandths convex on the bottom, but no more. They are very nice to use, as a user, a convex plane is something a woodworker can work well with as long as the plane isn't a banana.
I use only fresh aluminum oxide (cuts nice and deep) psa stick down rolls and take care to stick the rolls down with nothing under them - the surface must be clean of grit (which will make a bump). And make sure they are stuck down properly everywhere.
when I lap something like a #7, I will often place my hands somewhere other than the knob and tote (i don't like lapping long planes, not because it's hard to get them flat enough, but because you don't get as many pounds per square inch of plane, and the paper has to be "sharper" to dig in, as in you have to change paper too early). I turn 8's over and remove material with a hard block and then mark the surface and repeat until flat, they are just too big for my 190 pounds.
I think the things above are sort of par for the course thoughts for a hand tool woodworker, to establish a controllable technique and observe results.
(by the way, the first plane I ever bought was a restored #5 that someone had lapped the pee out of and it was clean and bright, and a very good impression of a banana.)