New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

substrate for flattening a plane

Posts

substrate for flattening a plane

#1

substrate for flattening a plane

eliotandmax

I see videos and such about using granite under sandpaper or emery to flatten a hand plane. I've done it with a piece of plate glass. Is there something better about granite? Plate glass seems to work fine for me.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#2

Durability

Steve Elliott

The advantage of granite is that it won't chip or break like glass and is less likely to get scratches, which don't matter all that much anyway. Both are plenty flat enough.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#3

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

TomD

There is no needed practical advantage. I have plenty of planes that were flattened by just whacking a strip of PSA sandpaper onto the jointer table.

Granite is the reference surface plate material, along with cast iron. It is also pretty cheap in the form of good enough Chinese plates; ads for granite surface plates in local auction sites; and for some, granite suppliers. So granite is great, but there really isn't any need for flattening planes. Granite is there for reason far beyond what wooden planes do. You can flatten wooden planes with wooden planes, or blocks of wood.

All that said, good to have if you aren't short of money. I have a plan to buy 2 small 12x18 plates for a small island in our kitchen. In the shop I have a granite plate that is 24x36, and a smaller granite one, and a small cast iron one.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#4

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

david weaver

granite doesn't flex, so it doesn't matter if the surface under it is flat.

plate glass, even at 1/2" will flex a fair amount, especially under the pressure of lapping.

If the surface you're putting the glass on is flat, you'll notice no difference in the result, and even if it's not, you'll probably still not notice a difference in results for the purposes of actually using a plane.

I have lapped a lot of metal planes (either junkers, smoothers, or shop made infills) and I just make sure my bench is flat, then put down an 8x42 piece of float glass that was destined to become a cabinet shelf (meaning it was cheap production glass and not custom glass), and check that with hand pressure on the middle to make sure that I can't get a feeler under a good straight edge. It's not necessary to even do that, but it makes me feel better for some reason.

If you're only going to do a couple of planes, then there's no reason to really think too hard about it, any of the methods will improve the sole on a smoother.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#5

what is the secret?

Bill Tindall

There is more to this flattening that just having at it. In my one time experience I wound up with a plane sole less flat than where I started. Ditto for others in our club. The leading edge abraded quicker. It took a trip to the machine shop and a surface grinder to recover. I concluded, apparently incorrectly, that it was not possible to hand lap a sole flat by rubbing it on sand paper. So what is the trick to success. I am willing to give another plane a try...cheaper than a trip to machine shop.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#6

Re: what is the secret?

david weaver

Paper needs to be stuck hard and tight to something, else you'll have dubbing at the toe and heel, and all around the edges.

You need to place your hands somewhere such that you're not going to be rocking the plane and you need to make a repetitive stroke - that is, the process will work better if the position of your hands doesn't change and the stroke is exactly the same every time.

A long lap makes this easier, because you can just lock your weight down on a plane and walk 3 feet with it, and then take it to the back of the lap and do it again, and again, and again. A totally different thing than what you'd do planing and extending your arms at the end.

Check the work with a straight edge fairly often. When people just rock violently back and forth, i can see why they would create a banana shaped plane. If you are getting a banana shaped plane, I guess the game may not be the game for you (not talking to you specifically, bill, just saying in general, if the results can't be had, either a flatter plane or a machine shop may be the answer).

I would guess that my longer planes are probably a couple of thousandths convex on the bottom, but no more. They are very nice to use, as a user, a convex plane is something a woodworker can work well with as long as the plane isn't a banana.

I use only fresh aluminum oxide (cuts nice and deep) psa stick down rolls and take care to stick the rolls down with nothing under them - the surface must be clean of grit (which will make a bump). And make sure they are stuck down properly everywhere.

when I lap something like a #7, I will often place my hands somewhere other than the knob and tote (i don't like lapping long planes, not because it's hard to get them flat enough, but because you don't get as many pounds per square inch of plane, and the paper has to be "sharper" to dig in, as in you have to change paper too early). I turn 8's over and remove material with a hard block and then mark the surface and repeat until flat, they are just too big for my 190 pounds.

I think the things above are sort of par for the course thoughts for a hand tool woodworker, to establish a controllable technique and observe results.

(by the way, the first plane I ever bought was a restored #5 that someone had lapped the pee out of and it was clean and bright, and a very good impression of a banana.)

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#7

David Barnett

For metal planes... *LINK*

David Barnett

...I'd rather scrape.

You can scrape wood soles flat, too, of course. I like a straight piece of 4" long by 1" wide by 1/16" to 3/32" thick hardened steel, very sharp edges, no burr. Rock it on high spots like a short straightedge, then scrape away. No Prussian blue, of course. I especially like this for lignum vitae plane soles.


So easy, so pleasing, so flat.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#8

craigd

Re: what is the secret?

craigd

I find that gripping the plane in middle (as opposed to gripping it like you are planeing the lap) helps. I think planes flex a lot more than we think (or can measure), the mouth is a hinge, so this technique tries to mitigate that hinge.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#9

Re: what is the secret?

david weaver

I agree craig, I didn't elaborate what I meant by not putting my hand on the tote and knob in my long overdrawn explanation. I like to put my back hand under the tote and my front hand over the mouth.

If I have a plane that's already a bit banana shaped (just because the casting turned out that way), I will usually flatten it back to front, if that makes any sense.

I have never thought as much about doing any of this as I have in trying to type it out. It should just be a sensible evolutionary process for someone who works wood with their hands, I think.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#10

Re: what is the secret?

TomD

I have had some success using shorter than the plane sandpaper, always be hollowing as the t-shirt says. I also just hold the middle of the plane. I did some tests a few years back and with the pressure we are using here my wood and Record #7 both deformed about 5 thou.

I don't do this any more though, except at times on wooden planes. With wooden planes I start out with hand planing the plane. But some of these threads have been for people making some of their first planes and that isn't always possible.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#11

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Glass Table

Jim in Burlington ON

I bought a thick glass off a coffee table at the reuse store. One side has sandpaper glued to it and the other side I have used carbide powder. At 5 bucks it was a deal.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#12

Finally!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I found something cheaper! A couple summers ago, I found a glass shelf, 1/2" X 6" X 18" for $.25. It's dead flat and already has a hang hole drilled in it!

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#13

Re: what is the secret?

eliotandmax

Here's a case where my inexperience paid off: I had only a nice piece of thick plate glass that was about 14 in. square and and an even smaller square of 150 grit sandpaper --perhaps 12 in. square. The plane is about 16 in. long. Also, some kind of intuition had me griping it over the mouth, with elbows locked , and moving in only one direction. So, apparently, I did it just right! But here's another question: what kind of straight edge do you use to judge the flatness? Or do you actually run one of those micrometer dials over it? Also, I read somewhere, that some workers actually take pains to NOT have it flat everywhere. Something about some slight hollows here and there( forget where.)

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#14

Re: what is the secret?

David Weaver

I can't speak for anyone else, but I use a 24 inch steel starrett straight edge that I bought new, and that I use just about everywhere in the shop for a short straight edge.

(i think they are about $70 now for series 380, which is just a piece of tool steel ground to a really tight tolerance)

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#15

Thanks I may give it another try

Bill Tindall

I have a "mile" of 80 grit 4" roll from the Klingspor $1/pound bin. Stuck to the long bed jointer should work.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#16

Re: what is the secret?

TomD

" So, apparently, I did it just right! But here's another question: what kind of straight edge do you use to judge the flatness?"

One of the first things I did when I started out was buy a very high quality machinist's rule, probably about 200 dollars in today's money. These days it would be a pretty cheap thing to buy or make, but over the years it did pay for itself buying machines. I think a quality rule of some sort is a good think, but for checking planes I mostly don't bother. I don't care if they are flat, I care if they perform. The process of making them will get them flat enough and the rest is the proof in the pudding.

"Or do you actually run one of those micrometer dials over it? Also, I read somewhere, that some workers actually take pains to NOT have it flat everywhere. Something about some slight hollows here and there( forget where.)"

We are talking about the plane right? Japanese planes have flat bands on the sole that are made parallel to each other. Winding sticks and a scraper are used for this process. Most planes have a band at the infeed, and another at the mouth. Jointers have a band at both ends of the block, an also at the mouth.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#17

Re: Thanks I may give it another try

David Weaver

Should work well. 80 grit is my favorite grit to work with lapping a plane unless it's way way way out. When you finish off a plane on a piece that's getting worn, you can go straight to 220 and then wear that down a little and have a really nice surface without having to work through anything else.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#18

craigd

Re: what is the secret?

craigd

I use a Starrett ruler to check flatness: it is thick enough that it balances on edge, shine a light behind it and you can notice well under a thou. That said, I don't like perfectly flat soles, they are too sticky (or "wring"). A "flaked" (a side effect of scraping) sole is probably close to perfect; overall very flat but has wide spread "imperfections" (maybe like unfinished wood is never perfectly flat because of the grain). I never go much under 100 grit and don't bother to take all the mill marks off the soles of my planes.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#19

Second that

Bob Hackett

Scraping is faster, more accurate and easier to control. A whole lot less time and trouble when it ocomes to set up and storage goes too.

Once you understand what`s going on with scraping you`ll find you do more of it because it`s so much easier and you get better results than with abrasives. The finished product in metal looks way cool too.

I have to agree with one of the other posts in that I don`t worry so much about if a plane is dead flat as I do the performance. Depending on the type of work you`re doing you may even find dead flat to be a hindrance. Scrub planes come to mind here.

Much of the work I`ve done tuning tools up has been correcting mistakes made by previous owners chasing unrealistic standards that they only read about and didn`t understand. As a result they turned what were perfectly useable tools into non-functioning shelf sitters. :(

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#20

Re: For metal planes...

Pam Niedermayer

That sounds like an elegant process to flatten soles, I'll have to try it when I get the chance. Thanks.

Also, I ordered the Belomo loupe, gave them your name, hope it exceeds my cheap little linen tester. Thanks again.

And why can't you walk? Geesh, in one day I find out you can't walk and Tom had his feet lopped off by an airplane. Both events sadden me.

Pam

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#21

Re: For metal planes...

TomD

Mine are back on, but when they pulled me out which took a short 4 hours, I was looking at the soles of both feet. Cool deal - what you don't see you don't feel, I was way maxed out from the other injuries. I think when we met it was post injury, so I'm no worse than that, just a little older it happened in '97. I did search past email, but I don't have access to one of the accounts which must be where we corresponded. I'm like google, I never clean house.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#22

David Barnett

Scraping, seeing and moving about.

David Barnett

"That sounds like an elegant process to flatten soles, I'll have to try it when I get the chance. Thanks."

Scraping is even kinda fun and for machine tool ways, all that frosting holds just enough oil to keep things rust free and gliding smoothly.

"Also, I ordered the Belomo loupe, gave them your name, hope it exceeds my cheap little linen tester. Thanks again."

As for the BelOMO loupes, they're a joy to use. One of my best friends takes these on his medical missions to Haiti for minor surgeries, cleaning up dermal narsties one gets in the tropics, and even for field diagnosis. Hand loupes are held close to the eye, necessarily removing one hand from the equation, so serve best for frequent edge inspection. When you need hands free to work under more constant lower power (3.5x) and greater working distances (12 to 17"), surgical/dental binoculars do the trick, and the prices have really dropped recently. Think Chinese optics, which can be very good indeed, especially for sharpening saws and so on. But the 10x loupe is the way to go for most things and is the one lens that everyone should have.

"And why can't you walk? Geesh, in one day I find out you can't walk and Tom had his feet lopped off by an airplane. Both events sadden me."

Not to worry about my walking. Most days, I can make it from room to room with planning, canes and rest stops. It's just that both legs stay in compression casts and have for most of the last decade. As a gravity-challenged diabetic, I've been lucky to retain my feet (and sight) up to now -- just can't use 'em as easily as before. I can stand at the workbench or the bandsaw for a couple or three minutes at a stretch, so manage to get some things done. Everything but the bench is on wheels and I have help pushing things about and fetching tools when needed.

Outside of woodworking, which these days is mostly for my own needs and pleasures, nearly everything I do is chair friendly. I even have a multi-axis boom microscope and jeweler's bench that wheels right up to my bedside for those long insomniac nights. Latenight lapidary, engraving, wax carving, chainmaking are my wee hour delights. No distractions. Pretty sweet, all things considered. Besides, most of my problems and limitations are my own damn fault, unlike Tom's more catastrophic injuries, so I've had time to gradually adjust and find workarounds.

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#23

Re: Scraping, seeing and moving about.

TomD

If you are going to take a hit, I recommend a plane crash, and a tree even for some wood content, I never got any of the wood! My chair is the horizontal one that is under the other one.


Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#24

Re: Scraping, seeing and moving about.

Pam Niedermayer

OMG, how on earth did the airplane land like that? Fall out of the sky straight onto a tree? Bet there were a lot of bad backs coming out of that, too.

And your feet were reattached? Amazing. You did seem to walk pretty well when we met, only a tiny bit awkward, nothing worth remarking on. Does it hurt still?

And yet, there you are a year or two ago harvesting a beech tree. Blows me away.

Pam

Re: substrate for flattening a plane

#25

Re: Scraping, seeing and moving about.

Pam Niedermayer

You may have exacerbated your diabetes, but nothing is ever all an individual's fault, just as utter success is not self made. We all get where we get with the help/harm of society.

I'm sorry you have to wear casts and hobble around. At least you have a nice house, help, health care, and something interesting to do. If I can ever help, please yell.

Pam