New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Request for dovetail info. re: James Krenov

Posts

Request for dovetail info. re: James Krenov

#1

Request for dovetail info. re: James Krenov

North of the Border

I remotely remember reading The Fine Art of Cabinetmaking by James Krenov, in which he wrote about usng a file to close the gap in dovetail joint. If you have that book, would you please describe how he said he did it. Many thanks.

Re: Request for dovetail info. re: James Krenov

#2

Ellis Walentine

Couldn't find the reference

Ellis Walentine

I just read through everything he says about dovetails in that book and can't find any reference to fixing sloppy dovetails. I wonder if it could have been in another of his books?

Maybe I missed it.... sorry.

Ellis

Re: Request for dovetail info. re: James Krenov

#4

Re: Couldn't find the reference

North of the Border

Ellis and Bill,

Thank you for taking the time to help me on this. I will look at other places to see if I can pin down who wrote something about that.

Re: Request for dovetail info. re: James Krenov

#5

Flattening?

Brian Greene

I have heard of people using a file to flatten the protuding bits after putting the joint together. Maybe the reference you have is confusing two separate actions.

Re: Request for dovetail info. re: James Krenov

#6

Re: Flattening? - Yes

North of the Border

Thank you Brian. I think using a file to crush the wood fibers is what I had read.

Re: Request for dovetail info. re: James Krenov

#7

Re: Flattening? - Yes

TomD

I don't remember him saying he did it to close nasty gaps, his method is built around predictable dovetails at a studio furniture level. I don't consider all the points to be still relevant, and I don't use them all myself, but I did teach the method at one point (I like to teach stuff people can walk out and find a reference for). I do still at times use his file method, and it does close gaps even if he did not promote it as such. Basically you just put a single layer of tape around the end of the file, you leave the endgrain a little proud, and you file it away. I think that just works, I don't think you have to do anything too special, but then maybe I am doing something I don't know, there are natural ways to shift around work to reduce tear-out, etc. The only real problem with this method is that overlength endgrain filed away with a mill bastard file is a little time consuming, but it works.

According to the book he does not recommend making the endgrain long, just a hair, so maybe I have been overdoing it at times, when I did it at all. For everyday work I mark the ends to the thickness of the adjoining piece.

Re: Request for dovetail info. re: James Krenov

#8

Re: Flattening? - Yes - Do you

North of the Border

Hi Tom,

Do you have the page number where this file method is mentioned? Is it from the Fine Art of Cabinetmaking? Do you have the exact wording of that particular line? Thanks again.

Re: Request for dovetail info. re: James Krenov

#9

Re: Flattening? - Yes - Do you

TomD

Page 160 and 161 in the Sterling version, and same pages in the 1975 version.

Re: Request for dovetail info. re: James Krenov

#10

Re: Flattening? - Yes - Do you

TomD

It is the Fine Art, I think what really made the impresison is probably the picture. The file is referred to, but it is mostly the picture.

Re: Request for dovetail info. re: James Krenov

#12

Ellis Walentine

Good eye, Tom