New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Who needs a bench anyway?

Posts

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

#2

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

James Watriss

Awesome... I feel like I need to dig deeper into that site sometimes. Between that video, and the one that covers clogs, spoons, and chairs, there must be some really cool video up there that I simply haven't found yet.

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

#3

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

Bill White

Just kinda confirms my views about needing all the micromeasuring devices that are sold to woodworkers.

I'm not a total neander by any means, but reason and skill offtimes prevails.

We have one of those buckets shown. It was a gift. I've studied it many times. Danged if I could ever build one.

Now I'll go hone my spoke shave. Which story stick will I use next?

Bill

(See my tongue in my cheek?)

Bill

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

#4

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

Frank D. in Montreal

I figured people on here might know these. They passed me by, totally.

This one on forging (nails an some kind of blade that I can't identify) and resawing is pretty cool:

http://svtplay.se/v/1371061/oppet_arkiv/spik-_och_oxskosmide_samt_enbladig_ramsag__utan_ljud__1923?cb,a1364145,1,f,103007/pb,a1364142,1,f,103007/pl,v,,1371071/sb,k103004,1,f,103007

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

#5

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

TomD

That wooden compass looks quite a lot better than some of the ones I have seen for sale. I have some measurement rules, sorta:

- All tools measure or mold something. A 1/2" chisel is not only that width, but it's back is flat, it's edge is a straight, line, it meets at a V, etc... So even if we do not have the fancy devices we are coming down with highly accurate tools.

- Virtually never bought a measurement device that didn't turn out to be useful for something. Highly decorative devices are cool if the decoration seems somehow earned. But I am talking about practical measurement devices.

- Some of the most accurate, and "scientific", are also the cheapest. One can buy dial indicators for as little as 7 bucks, and there is an avalanche of the very best old school stuff doing the deindustrialization tango through ebay.

- Some measurement stuff is not that useful but fun to know. I remember a few years back doing a beam stiffness test of a cast iron jointer vs a wooden one. I got pretty much exactly the same results on deflection. That was just cool.

- Measurement is often one of the most fun parts of a job, as with stuff like frames or boats. Often the breakthrough moment is when one figures out how to get the line onto a complex 3D form, usually the cutting is simple.

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

#6

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

Pam Niedermayer

Or: How to get a hunched back and gnarly fingers and a cut up body in 20 years of work

That said, they do have benches, like the one they both sit on, like the plane that's a planing beam, and the chair they saw on.

But like James said, thanks, I'd also missed that one, and now I'm off to watch the blacksmithing.

Pam

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

#7

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks for the link. I recall seeing it a couple of years ago, but it faded into the recesses of my mind (as an increasing amount seems to do these days).

A while back I began to take an interest in coopering. I am slowly gathering speed towards building a keg or two. It was exciting to see in the video the jointer plane in use - this was the very long and wide plane he used briefly at one point. It was resting at an angle against something. I built one of these planes last year, added a handle so that it may be used as a tradition jointer as well … although that was a might optimistic as I am not built like Garth. Anyway, for this interested in Cooper's planes, the link to the article is here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/CoopersJointer.html

Do you think that the reason for the two-person planing was to overcome the absence of a bench? The planing at this stage was roughing to shape, so I expect that the plane was set for a deep shaving. Later the plane (or another like it) was used in a more traditional manner, but by then it was taking finishing cuts and this would not require the same work-holding demands.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

#8

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

santa Paul

The "some kind of blade" were actually ox shoes. Similar to horseshoes but made in 2 pieces.

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

#9

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

Frank D. in Montreal

I had noticed the hunched back...I'll keep my bench actually. I agree about the work support. The shaving horse certainly qualifies as some kind of bench, although a far cry fropm Roubo...

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

#11

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

Frank D. in Montreal

Do you think that the reason for the two-person planing was to overcome the absence of a bench? The planing at this stage was roughing to shape, so I expect that the plane was set for a deep shaving. Later the plane (or another like it) was used in a more traditional manner, but by then it was taking finishing cuts and this would not require the same work-holding demands.

Hi Derek,

They are using a stop like one would on a regular bench (to hold the piece when the plane takes a shaving). Seems like the older man is only pulling the plane back, allowing the younger guy to take another cut without interrupting the flow. Perhaps the most efficient way for a helper with limited strength or skill to help out? The planes seemed designed (2 handles) to work that way. It's not like a floor plane or a huge moulding plane (at least the few that I have seen) where the two (or more) workers would be applying force in the same direction. Interesting question. I've never seen a plane like that before, with 2 handles that cuts on the pull stroke.

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

#12

Re: Who needs a bench anyway?

TomD

"Seems like the older man is only pulling the plane back, allowing the younger guy to take another cut without interrupting the flow."he would pull it down at the end of every "

If that was the case he would be pulling it down on every stroke. I think they are sharing the work pretty evenly. If you watch them going back and forth the pusher seems to be aiming down and the puller up. i suppose one could coordinate it so the push is moving it back and stopping it from tipping, but it would be easier to just go 50%

" Perhaps the most efficient way for a helper with limited strength or skill to help out?"

Nowadays you get a 70 year old guy sitting opposite a 20 year old guy who seems competent, and just as likely the older guy doesn't know squat because the chance of randomly finding two good woodworker is not so great. But back then, who hit 70 without a clue. I remember working with my great uncle, who was through the great war, little guy, but he would outwork a guy twice his size. I can remember rebuilding his rear porch with him when he was in his 80s, he fell off a joist and his skin was so thin it came up in a huge sack of blood.