New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Japanese plane

Posts

Japanese plane

#1

Bob

Japanese plane

bob

A few posts down there is a discussion of floats for making a plane. Apparently there are a few people on this site who have made Japanese hand planes. I made a Japanese plane a year or so ago and it took a while to get it tuned but I was able to get a one or two thous. shaving.

I was never happy with the tightness of the blade. I did not use a chipbreaker and I either made the blade too loose or too tight.The construction process is fairly quick and fun but I do have some questions about the process.

It would be a great service to this site if someone could do a tutorial on Japanese plane making. I know there are photo's on the Japanese Woodworkers site Daiku Dojo but some of the photos lack explanations. Alternatively, could someone recommend a site or add more explanation to the photo's that are on the Japanese woodworking sites or you tube.For me, the throat was the most difficult part.Never knew how to get a small mouth with a throat that would pass shavings yet keep the blade fairly secure.

Thanks,

Bob

Re: Japanese plane

#2

Re: Japanese plane

Pam Niedermayer

We'll do something, probably a video, sometime in the next few months; but possibly we can help without a full tutorial.

First, and probably easiest, use shims of paper to get the blade tight in an existing dai. Also know that the goal in fitting the blade is to really whack it with a 2-lb hammer or dai blank. If it goes to sole too easily it's too loose.

It might also help if you posted some detailed photos of your plane, might pick up on something else that's easy to fix.

Pam

Re: Japanese plane

#3

Re: Japanese plane

TomD

That said, and all correct, I have several older planes where I can position the blade by hand, and they work fine. If you are after fine shavings there is very little back pressure on the blade, so it's tight fit is not all that important. It's better to be tight, and one reason is you can just drop the blade in set it about as hard as you dare, and it is right where you need it to be. Other than the Rali, there aren't too many planes like that.

I glue in shavings to tighten purchase, paper may be better. it is never as good because it isn't endgrain. As planes get really old the sole gets thinner, and this happens anyway.

Fine shaving are mostly how sharp, how flat, how tight at the mouth, and the general blueprinting. None of that is really different from one plane style to another. Though Japanese planes are different in many ways.

Re: Japanese plane

#4

Bob

Re: Japanese plane

bob

Pam,

I look forward to your presentation.

I read that the blade should not be tight except for the last 1/8 in. in the throat. I actually opened mine thinking it was too tight and apparently overdid it.

I blacksmith my own laminated blade so I may not have something right with the blade. I made the bottom of my blade flat but someone mentioned that the Japanese slightly curve their blades. I dont understand how or why that is done to the blade unless it is done to make sharpening easier.I assume a hollow is ground on the flat side.

It has been a while since I used the plane I made. It is small and I made a blade for a larger plane. I need to rustle up some wood and give it another go. I dont have a camera so I cannot send pictures until my niece returns from college. She is my photographer.

Thanks for your offer of help. In the meantime, are there any sites that explain the process?

Bob

Re: Japanese plane

#5

Re: Japanese plane *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer

This series may help, specifically about the curved blade bit.

Pam


Japanese Hand Tools forum

Re: Japanese plane

#6

Re: Japanese plane *LINK*

wilbur

I'm not sure if this is exactly what you are looking for, but I did a writeup on my blog on setting up a Japanese plane, with plenty of photos. It's not the same as making a dai from scratch, but the final tuning is the same.

Since it's in blog format, the articles are in reverse chronologic order, so go to the bottom and work back.


Japanese plane setup

Re: Japanese plane

#7

Re: Japanese plane

TomD

"I blacksmith my own laminated blade so I may not have something right with the blade. I made the bottom of my blade flat but someone mentioned that the Japanese slightly curve their blades. I dont understand how or why that is done to the blade unless it is done to make sharpening easier."

It would make sharpening very slightly easier in that the upper corners of the bevel (corners furthest from the base of the plane when in place), would be slightly deeper, and the bevel a little more stable. In theory the Japanese culture does not operate on the basis of questions and answers, part of the Buddhist tradition. So even if modern Japanese are willing to answer our every question there is no guarantee these questions are rooted in the original meaning of these things. It could make the finger position more comfortable, look better, or have originally been a convenient grinding wheel diameter, or scraper dimension. My point about the hollow, which is like the flute in a gouge, but on the back (Iron side), is that it means there is a curve to the ramp, that makes it much easier to fit with a chisel. Same principle as when working a stick with a spoke shave one looks for the high points since they are easier to remove.

Some modern Japanese planes have no real hollow on either side, and I have made planes from these that worked perfectly well, it is not fundamental to their performance. The hollow on the non-bevel (tool steel side) makes sharpening more efficient. but not over the life the plane, it 's main high end justification is that it allow higher polish, but I have yet to see that said, other than saying it myself for 30 years. The main reason given is that it makes initial set-up faster, which is ridiculous.

"I assume a hollow is ground on the flat side."

There is a hollow on both sides. The one on the tool steel side/non-bevel/sub-blade side/ upper in plane, is like a pond and would hold water, deep in the middle rises on all sides. It blends into a flat just before the edge. The one on the bevel side/iron side, is deep the length of the middle, and rises to the edges, like the flute in a gouge. It is pretty minimal in depth, it can go unnoticed, or look like casting shrinkage, though obviously forged.

Re: Japanese plane

#8

Bob

Re: Japanese plane

bob

Tom,Pam,and Wilbur,

Thank you for the comments and link to the plane blade sole discussion and tip to use paper to correct a loose blade.

My main question is how to start the mouth on the sole side and how wide(front to back) should it be?On the plane sides, there are a blade angle line and another line that is traced from the non bevel side of the blade.These run across the sole to mark the blade opening. They converge so the distance between these lines on the sole is hardly the thickness of a chisel.

I started my plane by angling the chisel perpendicular to the sole to start maybe a 1/8th or a little more and then picked up the blade angle line. Is this correct method for opening the mouth.?

Also, could you explain again how the depth of the mouth is determined? I believe a 90 deg . line is drawn from where the back of the blade line meets the sole. This line extends along the side to the top of the plane and is drawn across the top which marks the front of the opening. Is that correct?

What is the trick to tissue thin shavings?? (I know, do everything right).

Re: Japanese plane

#9

Re: Japanese plane

TomD

"My main question is how to start the mouth on the sole side and how wide(front to back) should it be?On the plane sides, there are a blade angle line and another line that is traced from the non bevel side of the blade.These run across the sole to mark the blade opening. They converge so the distance between these lines on the sole is hardly the thickness of a chisel."

How wide apart the mouth is will depend on how thick your blade is and how tapered it is. Since you made your own blade, some of that could be non-typical.

Second point, as menthioned here somewhere, the blade should be marked on the side of the plane to get the two lines, but the blade should be pulled up about 1/3rd from the mouth. This is necesarry in part due to concave back, in part to make sure you have room for a really tight fit. You might not pull it so far up since your blade is flat on the back. The front mouth line is the top beding line off the top of the blade. This is the abutment line, and the tightest possible mouth line, it is also the rest point for your saw, and the line that establishes cutting angle by wood type, so you do not open the mouth until you are tuning.

"I started my plane by angling the chisel perpendicular to the sole to start maybe a 1/8th or a little more and then picked up the blade angle line. Is this correct method for opening the mouth.?"

Depends whether you are using a subblade. either way the initial angle is parallel to the either the blade surface, or the SB bevel surface. The idea being you want at least a parallel escapement, but not past vertical since that would lead to the mouth opening with wear.

"Also, could you explain again how the depth of the mouth is determined? I believe a 90 deg . line is drawn from where the back of the blade line meets the sole. This line extends along the side to the top of the plane and is drawn across the top which marks the front of the opening. Is that correct?"

Nope, see above. You do draw the line you describe, another is drawn ahead of it about the width of a Japanese square, but it is fairly variable, across the top, so say 5/8" ahead of the blade edge/mouth. On the sides, you project the forward line down to the lower angled line that is the rear of the mouth. The mouth itself is sloped as mentioned until it intersects the diagonal line just drawn, which it does, fairly close to the sole. To put that differently, draw a line from the rear of the mouth to a point on top that is ahead of the front of the mouth, about 5/8-3-4".

"What is the trick to tissue thin shavings?? (I know, do everything right)."

Yes, but mainly you need an extremly sharp blade to be able to catch the shaving. And you need a very flat sole (with or without the waves, but waves make it easier) so that a blade with minimal projection isn't in the shadow of some lump on the sole. The simplest way to get the flat sole is to sand it on a flat surface. The traditional way is with a scraper plane, and winding sticks, but if you can't get a plane to work... Where does the scraper plane come from.

Re: Japanese plane

#10

Bob

Re: Japanese plane

bob

Tom,

Thanks for your comments.

In order to clear one last point, I pulled the "Japanese Woodworking Tool" book. I suspect you have a copy.Referring to the diagram on page 97 there is a blade angle line B and blade thickness line C across the sole.On a small plane or a plane with a blade that has a relatively thin body, these two lines may be less than 1/4 in. apart. How is this opening cut when a standard chisel is nearly 1/4 in thick? Also, wont the edge of the cut on the blade thickness line be very thin and weak at the mouth? Please describe how you make the blade opening when working from the sole side? What type of chisel and do you really keep this opening as narrow as I describe above?