New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

recommendations for a saw vise

Posts

recommendations for a saw vise

#1

recommendations for a saw vise

Jeff Heath

I'm looking to purchase a used saw vise, and was looking for input from those who have used one of the older Disston vises. They seem to very readily available, and I'm not looking for anything fancy.

Pro's and con's, if you please? Also, a recommendation on another is welcomed, as well.

I'll be mostly sharpening 12" and 14" tenon saws, but on occasion, I'm sure a panel saw or two will need it, as well.

Thanks.

Re: recommendations for a saw vise

#2

Re: recommendations for a saw vise

Guillaume Dery

Used saw vises are hit or miss and unfortunately often more miss than hit.

This is not something that I would buy online but in person where you can inspect it. I bought about 5 before finding one that I am moderately happy with (a Disston #1. Although I am actually still planning on springing for the Gramercy one as it looks awesome and I only hear nice things about it).

Things to look for:

-parallel jaws (should go without saying)

-clamping action (smooth, sufficient pressure)

-Length (longer is better)

-wear and tear on the jaws (I have a saw vise that is bowed and only clams in the middle)

- If you are looking at cast iron (and you probably are), inspect it for faults, cracks, etc. Many of these have been dropped in their life and cast iron does not react well to impacts.

Nice to have:

-some people line their jaws with leather to dampen vibration

-permanent mount vs. bench clamp (if you do get a clamp-on model, resist the temptation of clamping it on your actual workbench! That debris is nasty on your later woodworking and you never get it all)

-Adjustability (angle)

All of the above being said, if you happen to find a nice Disston D-3, jump on it.

Re: recommendations for a saw vise

#3

Re: recommendations for a saw vise

TomD

Did Diston make a real heavy duty fixed one for a shop. The clamp on ones yell "Jobsite".

Wooden ones work well also, Any time one wants stiff and low vibe, wood is a natural. That said, anyone see a real masterpiece wood saw vise? I have used the ones that on just clamps in the main vise. Sew some magnets into a cloth around it and go, but I imagine someone has outdone themselves?

Re: recommendations for a saw vise

#4

Re: recommendations for a saw vise

Guillaume Dery

I don't think Disston made any fixed saw vises (at least that I know of). This is why I am hankering for the Gramercy. Looks like an excellent piece of kit.The D3 is heavy duty for a clamp-on model however.

As far as wood vises go, I did come across a shop-built one from Dominic Greco lurking in the articles section here which looks entirely functional http://woodcentral.com/articles/handtools/articles_925.shtml

(sorry, I haven't figured out how to do clickable URLs here yet)

AS an aside, I noticed that you are in Toronto. Are you planning on attending the Tools of the Trade in Pickering on April 1? If so, maybe we could grab a coffee and talk wood. Always nice to meet fellow members. I am driving down from Ottawa for Tools of The trade, looking for a few handsaws (speaking of Disston, would be nice if I could get a companion ripsaw to my D12 crosscut) and other toys (still on the lookout for a depth gauge for my handbraces)

Cheers,

Guillaume in Ottawa

Re: recommendations for a saw vise

#5

Re: recommendations for a saw vise

Jeff Heath

I did check out the Grammercy. Looks nice, but at $159, I'd probably make my own first. If I was filing as a side business, I'd consider the $160 to be cheap, but since I need to sharpen my saws a couple times a year......

Anything else out there?

Thanks for the replies.

Jeff

Re: recommendations for a saw vise

#6

Re: recommendations for a saw vise

Ron in Sterling, CT

I have seen good reports on other forums about Dom's saw vise, but have not had the opporturnity to try one out, or build my own yet.

Ron