New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Dunlap plane query

Posts

Dunlap plane query

#1

Dunlap plane query

Bill Tindall

I sold someone some surplus oak and during the negotiations the customer mentioned that he had a plane, that didn't. He had taken a class at Woodcraft where it was "sharpened". (microbevel on wrong side, was not sharpened to the very edge and it was not straight across the edge). little wonder it didn't pick up a shaving as it was dull and had no clearance)

I said I would take a look at it. It was a Dunlap #4. It seemed a cheap looking plane, but it was a good opportunity to teach the owner how to set it up. I checked the chip breaker and while it looked to be of poor quality it was in fact the straightest I have ever encountered. Only needed polishing. The owner was a machinist and I set him about straightening the edge and establishing a hollow using the grinding wheel. He did well, but then he has probably spent 10X more time at a grinder than I. He did allow that he would have jigged up the blade and done this job on a surface grinder. I started him with a honing jig on abrasive sheets. When I showed him the technique I became immediately impressed with the steel in this plane blade. This blade sharpened like a high quality replacement blade. It was exceptionally abrasion resistant as judged by how it performed on the abrasive sheets. It took a keen edge and made shavings that left the owner smiling.

What is the deal on Dunlap planes? I never heard of them. It looked cheap but it performed well. The steel in the blade was outstanding; better than any Stanley steel I have encountered.

PS He also brought along some WoodRiver chisels. I didn't get to check out the steel but the fabrication quality was exceptionally poor. They did look attractive if one didn't look too closely. Amazing how polishing a crummy grinding job can apply the appearance of quality to a chisel.

Re: Dunlap plane query

#2

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Dunlap plane query

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Dunlap tools were Sears "lesser" brand to Craftsman back in the 50's and 60's. Some of the planes might've been made by Sargent, and others by Millers Falls. They were considerably lower priced than the Craftsman versions, but as you've discovered, could be made to work pretty well.

I have a couple of their block planes. Nothing fancy, but usable. Not even close to my old Stanley 65, though.

Re: Dunlap plane query

#3

Re: Dunlap plane query

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"Lesser" meant cheaper wood on the knob/tote, a less robust lateral adjuster, no screw at back base of the frog to move it forward and back, and so on. However, the Dunlap planes I've seen seem well-machined; I'm not surprised you were able to set it up well.

My "Wards Master" No. 4, a first-line plane but from a catalog company, was like that too: I thought for a while that I'd never need to hone the blade again, as it held onto the edge for dear life.

Re: Dunlap plane query

#4

Re: Dunlap plane query

Patrick Gibbons

Many Dunlaps were made by Millers Falls. I'm particularly fond of MF planes and don't doubt that the blade was probably of the same quality. I have one of the last MF planes when they were on par with their lesser brands. It still is a good user in its own right.