New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

American Beech Mystery

Posts

American Beech Mystery

#1

American Beech Mystery

TomD

I have this block of beech that I cut as part of my plane and bench wood. It is about 13 x 3.6 x 3.6 with a corner missing. I cut it in spring 2010, and by April 2011 it weighed 4 pounds even. I just checked it and it still weighs 4 pounds, no change. It is a split for a plane, and such blocks often dry faster than say a 3.6" thick board would, but that is super fast. And I measured it in April it could have hit 4 pounds earlier.

I was just wondering whether it is typical for beech to dry that fast. Old Street Tools has an article about beech and mentions that the rays accelerate drying, so I can expect it to dry faster than some heavy woods, but this is very fast.

Anyone have experience with beech.

Re: American Beech Mystery

#2

Re: American Beech Mystery

Philip Duffy

Tom, I think there is another factor that needs to be considered before you use that beech; stability. Beech has a reputation for being unstable, even after several years of drying. So, depending on your intent, be aware the wood may wander in several axis. Phil

Re: American Beech Mystery

#3

Re: American Beech Mystery

Stuart Johnson

Was it green when cut and what did it weigh in 2010? I think the environment it where was drying would also affect the actual drying time.

Re: American Beech Mystery

#4

Re: American Beech Mystery

david weaver

I can't comment on it drying, but if you are curious about it, cut the blank as you'll cut it to use it for planes (if in fact you are going to cut it). Otherwise, just use it as is. I wouldn't be surprised if it was pretty close to totally dry in a year. Now it's been 2 years, and it's less than 4 inches thick in two directions with all four sides and ends exposed.

I would be more worried about where it will go in three weeks after you've split it down the middle. I've gotten quartersawn kiln dried boards before that still twist when they get in my shop, presumably because the tree was growing with a twist in it (as Bickford's blog shows when he splits one of his logs, the grain gradually spirals up the tree).

But I don't think you have much to worry about, you're almost two years on with the wood, and it's probably about as dry as it'll get without going into a kiln.

Re: American Beech Mystery

#5

Re: American Beech Mystery

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I looked up the density of dry beech and got figures of 39, 40 and 41 pounds per cubic foot when dried. With beech the density is higher for dried wood because the shrinkage is substantial. Your piece has roughly .0975 cu. ft. so you would expect roughly 4 pounds when dry.

I think your blank is dry. The water exits quickly from the end grain and nothing in your blank is far from either end. I think ideally you would dry pieces that were somewhat longer because the end grain is subject to checking from rapid drying and you could lose a few inches at each end. A longer piece would take a bit longer to dry. The traditional drying period for plane blanks is three years.

Re: American Beech Mystery

#6

Stability

Larry Williams

"Stability," in the forest products industry refers to the ratio of shrinkage between the tangential and radial directions. This means when drying the wood shrinks more in the flat sawn direction than in the quarter sawn direction. That's it, nothing more. It has little to do with the ability of the wood to stay in place or keep its shape once dry. For its density, beech has a relatively small amount of seasonal movement in the radial direction. This is used to advantage in plane making because the grain is oriented so that the wedge is housed in the radial grain. Large seasonal movement is a problem for maintaining the angles necessary for a secure wedge in a plane and beech's relatively small changes in the quarter sawn orientation make it ideal for planes.

Re: American Beech Mystery

#7

Re: American Beech Mystery

Larry Williams

Tom,

The problem we have in drying thick beech is slowing the drying down to avoid huge differences between the moisture content of the core and surfaces. We have to slow it down enough to avoid checking but not so much as to encourage fungal growth. It's not an easy process and sometimes we end up with very expensive fire wood. Beech reaches equilibrium relatively quickly and the big problem drying thick beech is that it dries too fast.

Re: American Beech Mystery

#8

I'm not surprised

Bill Tindall

The drying rate for wood is about 10X from the ends compared to the face and quartered is faster than flat.

Drying rate depends on the above factors as well as species, temperature, relative humidity, air circulation and where in the drying stage the wood is at. All these factors make the adage of 1" per year a useless guide.

If I cut firewood in TN in the spring by fall a 20" diameter section is, or is nearly, equilibrated to outside conditions, providing the wood is covered to exclude rain but allow wind. It is certainly well below 30% MC for it will have checked and the checks stabilized, evidence that the piece is has lost most all of the intercellular water that it is going to. (volumetric shrinkage does not begin until about 30% MC. ) I have some 20-24" beech in the wood pile that I cut last May and it is thoroughly dry. It was dry in August. Beech dries more rapidly than oak.

Given good drying conditions I would have expected that block of wood to be air dry in 3 months. Even with retarded air circulation I have air dried 10/4 walnut lumber in less than a year.