New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

Posts

Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#1

Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

Bill Tindall

Knives-Hand tool skills honed in the shop prove beneficial around the house. I used to sharpen(slowly) knives on an India stone. The inexpensive water stone retired from the shop is faster. I put it on a cookie sheet under the kitchen faucet at a moderate drip and have at it. However, I have come to realize that even my moderately expensive kitchen knives don't have steel as good as common woodworking tools. This observation has left me to thinking that I may make some kitchen knives some day.

Slicing- The precision for slicing anything has improved, from paper thin slices of smoked pork shoulder to uniform (well acceptably uniform) slices of raisin bread. You know they sell a thing for slicing bagels. It's only one cut! Even my power tool skills enables acceptable bagel slicing.

Zesting- I was using Microplanes to remove zest long before these tools appeared in cooking stores. They are good for nutmeg shaving too.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#2

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

Patrick Gibbons

Bill, I have found that cutting bread is very similar to using a hand saw. The knife does the work and the hand is there merely to guide.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#3

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When I was 16 I begged my mother to get a high carbon, low chrome kitchen knife so I could put a fine edge on it. She bought a nice imported knife. Last year when we closed up her kitchen one of my sons took that knife and the spoon I made for Pam's spoon contest in 2005. When I reported this to my mother, she said "He has good taste".

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#4

Know what'cha mean

Neal in San Jose

One comment I get frequently from guests helping out in the kitchen is "Boy, your knives are sharp!" The micro plane is also good for removing the very end of your fingers while doing the nutmeg, but I haven't come up with a practical use for that.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#5

If I'm not mistaken (frequently the case)

Bruce, a MN Galoot

making kitchen knives is what Ron Hock did before he started making plane irons.

Careful, Bill, that is another very slippery slope :D

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#6

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

TomD

Yeah, that is just for starters.

Bread. Only problem is the 3 kids who wreak the loaf you come to find.

I have a bunch of Japanese knives, and a few French, etc... Before stuff from china was everywhere, 30 years ago, I got one of their 3 dollar veg knives that is everyone's perennial favourite. Wish I had bought 5.

However, the miracles knives get the most use. The steel is crap, and the waffle edge an insult, but the reality is they are really great knives. The thin spatula knife, cuts up sushi rolls better than my 100 dollar sushi knife. The slicers are great for bread. The steak knives are great for spreading and routine stuff like making sandwiches. Sorta a Rally plane situation where the design is very clever, the execution is not so fab.

I am a big believer in the Spyderco system for knives and scissors. Sharpens everything, might not be the very best but I have been using it 30 years, and I don't really see the need to change.

A good chef's knife is a worthwhile purchase, another excellent design. Mine was only 25 bucks but has excellent steel.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#7

Oh, yes......

Bill Tindall

removing the very end of your fingers while doing the nutmeg, but I haven't come up with a practical use for that........It gets one out of doing dishes for a bit.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#8

Your sweety must be more understanding

Neal in San Jose

than mine. Mine would just tell me not to get blood on the good dishtowels!

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#9

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

John in NM

My wife was recently visiting her sister, who admonished her for putting knives in the dishwasher (it seems dish detergent dulls knives in whatever universe Martha Stewart lives in - she was the source of the advice). Jean politely pointed out that this was twaddle, although bumping into other utensiles during the wash probably doesn't do any good. Sharpening is so easy, Martha would do better to have monthly demonstrations than to dispense such silly advice.

I agree that kitchen knives are made of horrible steel. Soft buttery stuff that never rusts but takes forever to knock the wire edge off and then dulls in the blink of an eye. My favorite kitchen knife is an old carbon steel butchers knife that I used to keep in a camping kit. Not pretty enough for home use (I don't decide these things :D ), but I use it in the kitchen at work where the knives are the cheapest of the cheap. The thing is so sharp it slices bread cleanly, and has kept that edge for months with only minor dressing.

Opinel makes carbon paring knives if you can find them. I think I paid $6 for mine :D Good steel is well worth developing the habit of hand drying the knife or brushing off a little rust before use. Stainless has been in use so long that I notice many people now think that carbon steel is "dirty" and somehow poisonous :D Maybe in Martha's world it is indeed both.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#10

Shhhh!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I let the cat out of the bag years ago and now I am the knife sharpener for my family...and friends. I had to open my pie hole :-(

Seriously, no big deal and a nice service for others.

T.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#11

Re: Shhhh!

TomD

Those folks get a hit on the belt sander, because non-sharpeners always wait far too late. And anyway, that is how pros sharpen blades.

I agree about carbon steel, but good stainless is nearly as good, and nowadays they won't let you use the knives we like in a restaurant, which probably says something about what we should be buying also. Probably more pros cut with large chef's knives made out of stainless plate with poly handles sold in blister pack, than anything else.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#12

there are good stainless cutlery steels

Bill Tindall

The best edged pocket hunting knife I own is 440C stainless and CPM makes a stainless steel very similar to 3V. My main fault with most knives is the heat treating. Knives are made softer than I would prefer. I have some that can be filed!

The best value in store knives are the "professional" white plastic handled affairs available for almost nothing in restaurant supply stores. The ones I got have as good as or better steel and heat treat than either the Henckles or Victorinox.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#13

I don't doubt that....

John in NM

As you say though, they draw them down pretty soft, probably on the advice of some lawyer or another who lies awake at night fearing a liability suit from a brittle knife injuring the happy homemaker :D I would imagine some of the professional, expensive blades are harder, but I don't have any of those.

Along similar lines, the yellow handled Stanley chisels are quite useful if rehardened, drawn to maybe 400 F, and rehandled. I had one I did that with and it was then a decent chisel for the hackenter box that went to jobsites.

We also have a stainless knife that is very thin. Blade is hard and thin enough to ring when you tap it, so it's one I like ok. Good for slicing ham thin.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#14

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

Dale Stansbery

Don't forget using a chisel to open a paint can! As for sharpening knives, I much prefer carbon steel knives and a sharpening steel. I learned from dad as a kid during butchering season. I've never been able to get anything stainless as sharp. I once took a microscopic photo of a knife freshly sharpened with a steel, and the sharpening steel leaves a microscopically serrated edge. The only drawback is the frequency you have to touch up the edge. However, using a steel is decidedly faster than a stone.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#15

American-made Old Hickory knives

Patrick Gibbons

Seem to have good steel and can be had for small coin. I believe they're made by the same people that make Queen knives.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#16

I'll bet that explains it

Bill Tindall

Any knife that can be sharpened by a sharpening steel will need to be heat treated softer than what I would consider optimum for a knife to be sharpened with an abrasive. Maybe this is why I find typical knives too soft to suit me. I'll bet they are heat treated to be compatible with sharpening steels. My grandparents could use a sharpening steel but I never got the hang of it.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#17

Good to know...

John in NM

A bit of digging turns up that they use 1095 for the blades, and that Ontario Knife is the fixed blade sister company of Queen knives (both made in NY state).

Thanks Patrick, next time I'm looking for a kitchen knife, that's where I'll start.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#18

Re: I don't doubt that....

TomD

Actually I think the reason is use. There are activities were constant sharpening is more efficient than: sharpen, edge hold, edge hold, big resharpening. First there are environments where stones and oil are not a good fix, but a knife "steel" basically a rod file is more appropriate, or the soft wood jobsite where a file sharpened chisel is best; there are products like scythes that need the edge drawn out continually to extrude thin steel, sharp is not enough; and there are products like razors where the edge needs to be the same for every customer. Leather working, certain survival uses, etc... all have their own needs.

It is a woodworking, hunter/skinner, etc... bias that edge holding is god. I want to be able to get through all the edge planing for at least one project before I have to resharpen my knife, but that isn't what happens working in a meat plant. You cut every working moment. There is no end or resting point.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#19

Re: I'll bet that explains it

TomD

It explains part of it. As with my other post, there are different uses for all kinds of tools. You have certain kinds of elite tools like Japanese woodworking tools; You have serious tools, the butcher knives, as far as I know they are all stainless these days; And you get crap that is sold to punters but works well, serrated edge miracle knives; and you get stuff that doesn't work.

Scythes are an interesting example, They need to not only to be very sharp, but the edge angle profile needs to be very thin. To keep that with repeated sharpenings requires constant peening of the edge to draw out a new feather. Therefore the steel needs to be soft, which does to a certain extent lead one in a vicious circle. There are Japanese hard edge scythes, but I don't really see them being used in entirely the same way, on hundreds of acres of grain.

I would caution about saying stuff about stainless, there are very good SS. They are so good there is little practical reason for anything else, in most knives. But then as with anything else people root out uses that require different materials. Like cutting dovetail pins super thin allows one to keep flying the flag for hand tools. I like that this happens because I can make simple carbon knives with domestic heat treating and a sense of superiority.

The other reason not to dis SS is that it is always on a continuum from unsharpenable salt water dive knives, through to some of the toughest most edge holding steels there are like D2, which ranks as partially stainless in many people's minds.

There was an interesting event in knives. They had pushed 440c so hard that it was very popular, but for whatever reason was scarce one year. A couple of big makers changed their production to 420, the previous holder of the "pure crap" label. But the 420 knives turned out to be just as good. The explanation was that it was all about intentions and picking the right heat treating protocol. The world is almost always more complicated than a sales brochure.

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

#20

Re: Ancillarly benefits of hand tool usage

John McPhail

Improved physical fitness.