New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

To camber or not to camber

Posts

To camber or not to camber

#1

To camber or not to camber

David Riseberg

I have a Stanley #6 foreplane, that I am never really sure how I should be sharpening the iron. I don't have a #5 Jack plane. My next hand tool purchase would be a L-N #8 jointer. I also have 2 - Stanley #4 Smoothers. Up to now, I have never been sure if I should camber the blade of the #6, to use as a large Jack, or should I sharpen straight across (cambering only the ends to eliminate tracks) and use it like a small jointer. Up to now, I have actually used it both ways, but with only one blade for it, its wreaking havok on the blade.

Thanks

Dave

Re: To camber or not to camber

#2

Re: To camber or not to camber

wilbur

Given that you don't have a jack plane, or more specifically, another way of quickly removing wood with a plane, I'd go for the camber.

But what you are experiencing is exactly the reason for having more than one plane setup, or at least, having a couple of blades, one cambered, one straight.

Re: To camber or not to camber

#3

Re: To camber or not to camber

TomD

I would look at getting a proper jack, you could even use one of the 4s you already have. The Jack's length is no biggie. But obviously not if they are tuned. Making a wooden Jack, which is far and away the best kind, takes about 45 minutes. You would need a blade also.

Anyway, fore planes normally have camber. Maybe around 12" radius. Might as well have it that way. If you use it to do the work of a jack it will be heavy going, but whether you should choose to take more cuts with the finer blade, or less cuts doing more work with an already heavy plane is a mater of preference. If you make the fore into a jack you end up without the fore, or having to do a lot of finishing. Nice thing about metal planes is you can set them up and the settings aren't permanent. You will need more mouth if you choose a jack plane degree of blade camber.

Re: To camber or not to camber

#4

Re: To camber or not to camber

David Riseberg

I have a feeling, I'll need to pick up another blade. At least until I'm able to get the jointer I want. I'm hoping for that to be during the summer.

Re: To camber or not to camber

#5

Re: To camber or not to camber

roninkokomo

Another blade is a lot cheaper than another plane