New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Lee Valley Diamond Lapping Film

Posts

Lee Valley Diamond Lapping Film

#1

Lee Valley Diamond Lapping Film

Phil

In my last Lee Valley order, I decided to give the diamond lapping film pack a try. I've always used 3m micro-finishing film for sharpening, and I thought it would be interesting to compare this new medium. So far, so good. Tried it out on my block plane, and proceeded to get effortless 1 thou cherry end grain shavings. Time will tell how this holds up to repeated use. I suspect they brought this out as a precursor to their new high tech alloy blades: longevity should be good with my old fashioned A2 blades.


img

Re: Lee Valley Diamond Lapping Film

#2

question

Bill Tindall

This may appear to be a dumb question but coming from the perspective of someone that didn't find 8" stones long enough what technique do you use on these short pieces of abrasive- back and forth, round in circles, I really can't picture how I would use such a short length.

If you like how these work graduate to a cast iron plate and $15 worth of diamond paste.

Re: Lee Valley Diamond Lapping Film

#3

Re: question

Phil

Bill: good question. I never really considered the length a limitation, probably because I use what might be an unorthodox style of sharpening. I use a Mark II honing guide. When I first started using it, I would use the full width of the 8 /12 by 11 finishing sheets (cut into multiple strips 8 1/2" long). Max. travel on that would be about 4 1/2 inches, when you allow for the length of guide/blade combination. As I switched from one grit to another, I cleaned the guide roller to prevent cross contamination of the various grits. Then I got what I thought was the bright idea of placing a slip ordinary paper on the finishing film for the roller to ride on: no need to clean the roller between grits. However, this limits the length of travel to the length between the roller and the projection of the tip of the blade, about 2 3/4". So on those 6" diamond films, I use a little less than one half the film each time I sharpen (practical travel length is really about 2 1/4"). It seems to work (I can't imagine the blades being any sharper than I now achieve).

As far as diamond paste, I have not tried it, but I may venture in that direction when I exhaust my current supply of micro-finishing film. Right now, I am trying to gauge if I am getting the blade sharper with the diamond film vs. the regular micro-finishing film. Its a little early in the trial to make any definitive judgements.

Re: Lee Valley Diamond Lapping Film

#4

diamond vs "other"

Bill Tindall

Unless you are sharpening one of the highly abrasion resistant steels, particularly one with very hard vanadium or tungsten, there is no reason that diamonds will achieve a higher degree of sharpness than any other abrasive. In these cases the choice is determined by cost, convenience, etc.

Again, how exactly are you using the short films? Is the blade pushed, pulled or back and forth on the films?

Re: Lee Valley Diamond Lapping Film

#5

Re: diamond vs "other"

Phil

Back and forth on the coarser grits, back on the finer grits (to avoid tearing the film).

Re: Lee Valley Diamond Lapping Film

#6

Re: diamond vs "other"

TomD

I have always bought the longest stones I could, though that has usually involved stones around 8 inches. When I went to scary sharp sandpaper sharpening I often sharpened on pieces the size of playing cards, usually with a side to side motion. It is theoretically better to sharpen in the line that one will cut in, though I really haven't noticed a significant difference. And in any case one can always make a few strokes at the end in that direction. I don't think the size of these diamond papers is of any significance, except in that it may dictate a technique, but it shouldn't dictate a result. Personally I would go back and forth side to side before I would drag on way only, as it will be faster. One only needs an inch or so for the lateral movement. I mostly sharpen without a jig, though I do use them for truing narrow bevel tools at times.