New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Gifted?

Posts

Gifted?

#1

Moses Yoder

Gifted?

Moses Yoder

I am reading the Bible through this year; it is an interesting book, and we won't discuss whether we believe there is any truth in it. I came upon this quote, which I have copied from biblegateway.com

Exodus 31

New King James Version (NKJV)

Artisans for Building the Tabernacle

31 Then the Lord spoke to Moses, saying: 2 “See, I have called by name Bezalel the son of Uri, the son of Hur, of the tribe of Judah. 3 And I have filled him with the Spirit of God, in wisdom, in understanding, in knowledge, and in all manner of workmanship, 4 to design artistic works, to work in gold, in silver, in bronze, 5 in cutting jewels for setting, in carving wood, and to work in all manner of workmanship.


I thought the premise was somewhat interesting, that a man was given the gift of craftsmanship. I wonder if ancient cultures considered this to be a regular occurence. I love working with wood, and do a lot of maintenance on my house. My two neighbors, on the other hand, couldn't hit a nail with a hammer if they tried. My father was a rough carpenter, a pretty good carpenter but I did not inherit my love of fine woodworking from him, nor do I have any brothers or sisters that are really interested in woodworking out of my seven siblings. A lot of people agree, regardless of religion, that man is made up of mind, body, and spirit. It seems to me a gifted woodworker would have 3 areas that the love and ability of woodworking would come from; genetics, environment, or the spirit world. Which do you think it is, or does it come from somewhere else?

Re: Gifted?

#2

Re: Gifted?

steve mackay

I've al;ways belived in "naturals". A "gift" for smething. Personaly for me its engineering. I've no formal training or education but I can "see" how things work, and think "three demensionaly". While this served me well in an ARMY career, it now enables me to follow my passion for woodworking. The wood part is my parent's fault. So I guess I have a "gift" that was channeled by "enviornment". Now we can argue about the "crazy" part.

Re: Gifted?

#3

Re: Gifted?

Archie

I teach my students that there's a difference between natural talents and spiritual gifts. Talents are those genetically transferred (and environmentally encouraged/enabled) from the first parents all the way down to us today. Gen 4:20-23 refers to the domestication of animals by Jabal, the invention of the harp and flute (lyre) to Jubal, and the blacksmithing of "all kinds of tools forged out of bronze and iron" to Tubal-Cain. These represent three of the earliest natural talents. Their ancestor Cain possessed talents necessary for city building--engineering, architecture, carpentry, etc.

My natural talents evidently do not include woodworking and mechanic skills; but that doesn't stop me from tinkering and doing abit. I love that feeling of actually accomplishing something. My grandparents farmed; there's quite a lot of fulfillment to see what you plant come to harvest. A lot of work, too.

I definitely believe that early life environment and education predispose us toward conceptual or hands-on trades. I've spent my life thus far in the classroom and now like to head out to the shop to relax. I really believe that we've become too much consumer oriented and no longer producer capable. IMO. YMMV.

Re: Gifted?

#4

Re: Gifted?

Bob Hackett

Genetics,environment or the Spirit world? The answer for me would be yes to all three. Our ancestors supply the genetic make up, our environment supplies opportunities for training and the Spirit World can provide guidance.

This question might better be thought of in terms of; "How can I best become a vessel for creativity/Divine Will" ?

I recently wrote an article about the historic and mythological connections between blacksmiths/craftsmen and shamans. The title of the article is "The role of the Craftsperson in the Craft" and it traces the symbiotic relationship between the temples,the priests/shamans and the spiritually connected people who make the things the priests/shamans use to minister and serve the spiritual needs of the community.

Funny that someone like yourself, who I would consider a Christian fundamentalist, and a shamanic witch, my spiritual path, would be headed down the same road and viewing things in much the same way.

The Universe works in mysterious ways.

Re: Gifted?

#5

Re: Gifted?

Hank Knight

What a wonderful question! I believe all three contribute, probably in different measure, depending on the individual. Many folks grow up with the genetics and in an environment that would seem to promote/encourage craftsmanship, but they take an alltogether different path. The spirit is missing for them - their muse sings a different song to them. My father was a woodworker, of sorts, and I grew up around his tools and projects. He was a power tool guy and his projects were primarily rough, construction type things. He had little interest in details or hand tools, where my interests lie. Our muse is similar, but not the same. On the other hand, my grandmother was a gifted musician. I love music, grew up in a musical household and I have been playing at the guitar for most of my life. Unfortunately, I came to the realization long ago that I have zero musical talent. My musical muse is strong, but, alas, she has nothing to work with.

Re: Gifted?

#6

Re: Gifted?

Hank Knight

Bob, I never thought of you as a witch. I'm going to have to ponder that one! :\

Re: Gifted?

#7

Re: Gifted?

TomD

Certainly seems true to an extent. But in the case of an amateur, the defining characteristic is what draws on to something. "Was it for this the clay grew tall" Which incorporates the idea of the affinity with fate.

My Grandfather was a Joiner, my father retained some lower level aspects of that interest, mostly the belief he could do it, though he never got that far. But he is a world class scholar. Then in my case I was drawn to fine woodworking, and many other things to boot. Calling, convenience, avocation. In order in our family. So while there is probably a gift that separates the "people who can program a VCR" from those who can not, I think the main factors are elsewhere.

Without a doubt, my life has been influenced enormously by the availability of leisure time, as a kid, and young person by the abundance of time our lifestyle allows, and accidentally by the need to retire at 37 and find something to do. My Dad on the other hand worked full time at his profession for 70 years, is still going at it, in his late 80s. So he would do some woodwork if he could save some money, or to fill a need not out there in the marketplace, but he didn't need to fill in time, which seems to be a major motivation today.

Re: Gifted?

#8

Re: Gifted?

Tom Colligan

Thanks for the post, Moses, and the good natured replies from each. I have no natural talent for working wood but I'm continually touched that the Messiah, Himself, was a woodworker. Best to all,

Re: Gifted?

#9

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Gifted?

Jack Guzman from Maine

Though I'm not particularly talented in woodworking,I have always had a knack for doing things with my hands. I find that every skill I try to master seems to come easy to me.I know that nothing in my experiences has prepared me to be good at handwork. It is something I was born with,a "gift".I know I didn't earn this gift so I'm thankful for it and make the most of it. Good post Moses.---Jack

Re: Gifted?

#10

Re: Gifted? Long Response

Clementine

This is from my course in Art and Biblical Archeology:

Artwork was allowed by God in Israel’s worship practices, not as representations of God but in craftsmanship and ornamentation. Exodus 25-28 details the materials and construction plans for the tabernacle. The tabernacle was richly and colorfully adorned, including bright cloth, beautiful wood, gold, and other precious metals and stones. The wood used in the frame and in the items within the ark was acacia (KJV shittim), an orange-brown wood that was abundant in several places along the wilderness route of Israel. It was a hard wood and excellent for cabinetmaking. The Ark of the Covenant was made of acacia covered in gold. The Table of Showbread was made of this wood also. The altar was acacia covered in bronze. These items thus held a specific functional purpose that included a presentation in a beautiful work of art. The lampstand and its utensils were made of pure gold. The curtains were made of “fine twisted linen and blue and purple and scarlet material.” Angelic figures called “cherubim” were added that were to be “the work of a skillful workman” (Exo. 26:1). Even the doorway to the tabernacle was a work of artful craftsmanship composed of these same materials.

The same pattern of artful craftsmanship was exhibited in the temple in Jerusalem. First Kings 6 and 7 detail the construction of the temple and other buildings. The temple was not as large as other buildings in Jerusalem, and certainly not as large as other temples in the ancient world, but it was richly crafted and adorned. The windows were narrow and designed to allow light to enter the temple (6:4). The NAU calls them “artistic frames;” the NIV uses an architectural term called a “clerestory.” This is a narrow window that extends slightly above the roof line to admit light. Access to the upper stories was by a winding stair case (6:8). The stone walls were then covered with beams and planks of cedar (6:9). Cedar is a soft wood and splinters easily, so it is not a good choice for most constructions. It is, however, a beautiful wood when sawn and planed, with pronounced figures and grain that makes a wonderfully artistic impression. Since the cedar for the temple would be “old growth,” it would have straight grain and few knots, thus, an excellent choice to enhance the beauty of God’s house. If it were finished with an oil such as olive oil or oil from certain beans the effect would be truly inspiring. The cedar used by Israel came from Lebanon, a nation that still notes the cedar tree’s significant place in history by having a symbol of a cedar tree on its national flag, as well as maintaining numerous protected groves of the Cedars of Lebanon.

Wood carvings adorned the walls of the temple. These consisted of cherubim, palm trees, and open flowers (6:29). Considering the crude instruments the artist had to work with, it is amazing to read of the intricacy of the work that went into these carvings. One is reminded of the Reformation artist Albrecht Dṻrer who concentrated his artwork on carvings and woodcuts to portray the message of the Bible in art form. One other feature is interesting in its detail. Five-sided doorposts were made for the entrance of the temple. It is simple enough to make a four-sided post with right angles and straight lines. But to make five-sided posts is quite another level of skill, especially when one considers that the craftsman used only fairly crude hand tools to cut a precise bevel so that the five sides would be equal. This indicates an astounding level of critical attention to detail went into the temple construction. As for the craftsmanship of the temple, it was to be matched by careful obedience to the Lord by the people (6:12-14).

Re: Gifted?

#11

Moses Yoder

Thank you for the responses

Moses Yoder

Interesting and thought provoking reading, thank you.

Re: Gifted?

#12

Religion on Wood Central

Moses raised an interesting question, a variation of the "nature versus nurture" question.

It's also true, though, that (as on most online fora) the Wood Central rules ask that we refrain from discussing religion. There's obviously a fine line here.

I've been busy - that's not quite the word (I'm up to six hardware store visits, a sure sign of a project gone to the dogs) - replacing our water heater for the last couple of days, and have been doing flybys of the forum. I want to look at this thread more closely when the heater is busy making hot water; but I can certainly ask that folks be thoughtful about their posts, and aware of the WC standards of conduct.

Re: Gifted?

#13

We`re bein` good Boss! :^)

Re: Gifted?

#14

Genetics are a big part *LINK*

Paul M.

I learned first-hand that genetics can have a real strong influence on your abilities and desires, as well as your path in life. Here's my story...

I've drifted into many different hobbies over the years. I got into woodworking, but dust allergies made it difficult to use power tools. I then got into hand tools for the quiet and the dust-free shavings, but I cannot say I have a great passionate love for furniture. To me furniture is rather utilitarian, and I just cannot get excited about building yet another chest. A guitar making class in the local junior college hooked me completely. My love of music and love of handtools combined to draw me to making guitars. Now I'm preparing to make a business out of that passion.

So of course, one of the first things I do is look for the availability of the website my_last_name_guitars dot com. Hmmm... I have a very uncommon last name and yet it's already taken in this rather small field. So I click on that link and I see someone who looks vaguely like me who lives in the area where my grandparents are from. I email him, and tell him about my area of interest and describe my father and grandparents. It turns out that we're first cousins! I found a first cousin that I never knew I had via a path of shared passions.

There may also be spiritual links, but those ones are a bit difficult to prove or disprove. I can not really talk about that side of the question with much feeling. But finding a direct relative you didn't know you had via a shared passion is quite a strong push for genetics.

And no, I do not yet know what name I will call my own business. The obvious one is already taken. :)


My cousin's site

Re: Gifted?

#15

Really well put

wilbur

I think Hank put it really well. I have a similar relationship with my father as far as woodworking goes. My father could certainly put together things that lasted. He built a set of floor to ceiling bookcases that have held up over two moves, and show no signs of coming apart, so clearly he has the brains and the talent to make things out of wood.

He also made these bookcases with plywood, glued and screwed together, prebuilt doors, and a stain dark enough to hide all the flaws in the plywood. He doesn't understand why I go through all the bother that I do whenever I make something. Why dovetail a corner when some nails would do?

Re: Gifted?

#16

There's always...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"Cousin Paul's Guitars."

Neat connection.

Re: Gifted?

#17

Re: Really well put

TomD

My experience is that nails often hold better than half-measures of joinery. There is usually a perfect way to do a job, but it often isn't obvious until one has made some mistakes and can correct them. With furniture the cycle can be so long that one will not live to see the mess one made of things. Dowels and finger joints sometimes fall apart in a decade or two. Boats are cool that way, they usually show mistakes inside 10 years though there is always a higher sea somewhere.

Re: Gifted?

#18

Re: Gifted?

John in NM

How can one really define the desire to make beautiful things and make them well? For some I can see it being spiritual, for others maybe the satisfaction of meeting a challenge (today I installed a lock with those stupid round cornered plates, using chisels rather than a router :D )

Aside from that desire, for me it comes down to aptitude and practice. Both are second to the desire to produce though.

Re: Gifted?

#19

I agree

Bill Tindall

Everyone I know well enough to know "their story" that makes fine stuff has the same story. It began with a passionate desire to own furniture they couldn't afford to buy. Driven by this motivation they learned what they needed to learn to make what the wanted to make. Some started with simple Shaker and developed to making the best of the 18th century styles. None of them are "gifted" at design and most make period stuff, which means learning techniques and then copying design. I think most people have the skills to do this kind of work. It is the motivation that determines the course.

However, on the main board there are some gifted designers. No matter my motivation I could not achieve this level of design creativity.

Re: Gifted?

#20

Re: I agree ish

TomD

My motivation was slightly different than the one you mention. I wanted to make things I couldn't buy. My first large project was a canoe, I designed it from scratch. At the time there were plans for strip canoes, but they were not for the same kind of boats that were sold to serious paddlers. They were either bad designs or copies from earlier users whose needs were not the same as contemporary needs. By the time I started woodwork, I was already well established in a few other fields, notably fly tying. There, one was encourages to do original work and amateur work was assumed in most cases to be better than pro work, a divide I was on both sides of. I was brought up in a professional background where it was assumed that if one made things it would be in the design of them not in the hands on labour. So for me, design and making stuff I could net find was the motivation. Cost has to be in there, or one could not afford it, or might just decide to make do. Overall, though woodworking and craft is probably the single most expensive decision I ever made.

Once one thinks in these terms one can always find many products one wants that don't yet exist. Some of these are quite silly, like my wooden jack plane with a Japanese style blade and retention. But once one thinks it up, one wants to have it. And occasionally one needs a laugh.