New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

Posts

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Okay, so I missed the Ides by a week. That only means you need to respond sooner if you want your comment to appear in the next edition of Woodworker West magazine.

In talking with Ron Goldman, editor of Woodworker West, recently, we mused about the role of mistakes in woodworking. Sometimes they are nothing but a nuisance, but other times, they can not only be instructive, but they can lead to entire new ways of doing things. This month, I'd like to hear about your relationship to your mistakes. Do you fix them? Do you make "details" out of them? Have you ever learned something you hadn't expected, and even applied that new awareness to other projects?

It's all about mistakes, folks. We all make them. The question is, what do we make of them?

As usual, your answers will be run through our editorial blender and sent off to appear in the March/April issue of Woodworker West. I appreciate your input as usual.

Cheers,

Ellis Walentine, Host


Woodworker West Magazine

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY ***

Jack Guzman from Maine

One of the first lessons I learned in woodworking is the way to handle mistakes. Understand that everyone makes them, accept that the error has been made and if redoing the piece is not reasonable, find a clever way to disguise the error and finish the piece. Learning to recover from errors is a skill in itself. Sometimes turning the mistake into a new design feature if it can't be disguised.We are not machines,we make mistakes occasionally. It's not a sign of failure. It's just proof that we're human.---Jack

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

interesting silence

Jack Guzman from Maine

I think the lack of responses to this question is an interesting response in itself.---Jack

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

#4

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY ***

Bob Hackett

If you are all about exploration (which I am) then you want to see what the material is capable of which will lead you to finding it`s limits. Pushing those limits leaves a much larger margin for error and I`m sorry to say I have messed up a lot of wood. My propensity to make mistakes has led me to harvesting, processing, and seasoning my own wood, which led to a far deeper appreciation for how unique and vibrant custom cut air dried wood can be. It also led me to green woodworking and the use and restoration of hand tools.

My disappointment at having some early projects self destruct due to the cycling of wet summers and bone dry winters here in Maine led me to a the understanding that wood is a dynamic material and I need to allow it to move.

The realization that every thing I make doesn`t have to be a shrine or offering to the gods of the trees and craftsmanship got me building simple things with found or dump wood with my grandchildren and non-woodworking friends. These "rustic" objects require only hardware and time as investments and even though many of them aren`t built to last they somehow endure even though they break many of the accepted rules and sometimes incorporate what many would consider glaring mistakes.

There`s a freedom that comes from allowing room to make mistakes and believing you have enough knowledge and skill to recover from them or overcome them. That freedom makes all the difference between your craft becoming another part time job with lists, specifications and deadlines to meet or a chance to explore possibilities,learn from the material and fully enjoy your end of a partnership.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

#5

Ellis Walentine

It can be tough to admit mistakes

Ellis Walentine

There are a lot of differing attitudes about mistakes. James Krenov once told me that fixing mistakes is like a cat covering her droppings in kitty litter. Needless to say, he didn't care for "making a detail" out of something that shouldn't have happened in the first place. But, he was all about perfection. I will admit to fixing a lot of mistakes in my career, simply because they were a natural consequence of pushing the envelope, as you say, and of rushing to get things out the door without losing my shirt. Trouble was, many of the fixes took longer to do than making the thing over again from scratch.

I had a small arsenal of favorite fixes, ranging from epoxy and sawdust to "Dutchmen" of every shape and size. At some point you have to make a value judgment as to whether a fix is acceptable. To me, it's just another design problem.

Ellis

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

#6

Re: It can be tough to admit mistakes

TomD

I make few mistakes and normally can easily repair them. Don't normally make a feature out of them. One time I can remember was when I built a trestle table. It had a stretcher that was mortised through the legs slightly higher than center. When I went to assemble it, I realized to my horror I had made the two ends with the center legs in opposite orientations. The result being the mortises were at different heights. Simple fix was to enlarge mortises and remake the stretcher. But it is hard to feel good about such bonehead moves.

Bigger problem for me is to get hung up over perfection and to put a project on hold. Earlier in my career, with nobody to ask, etc... That was probably necessary to come up with a plan. But it can be just a mindset thing.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

#7

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

James Watriss

Funny... I just wrote about this on Sunday.

Depends on the nature and scope of the mistake. Typically, I fix it, and move on, products must be delivered. Once in a while I may ask the client or recipient if they're ok with a modification, and more often than not, it turns out to be a detail they really don't care about, and it's just me being fussy. When it's work for my benefit, I can get away with being a perfectionist.

But when it's time to get a job wrapped up, diminishing returns and Zeno's paradox get into an ugly race to the bottom. I learned early on that good enough and DONE, and better next time, feels a lot better than fighting myself and not finishing even the smallest jobs in anything resembling a reasonable time. And it's really helped me improve more, while getting more accomplished.


Learning, growing, making mistakes

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

#8

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY ***

ron in kokomo

I guess the only thing that I can really say is that I very much try to learn from them and not make the same mistake twice. Alas, my record there is not perfect.

Ron

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

#9

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY ***

SteveA

I think I make at least two different kinds of errors and they prompt different kinds of "responses."

I very much believe - like everybody else here, probably - in planning, that full size drawings and sections, mockups, detailed cut lists and plans of action are paramount. So if an error is the result of my not initially thinking through the job entirely - a sort of laziness - then I get very angry at myself. How to fix it, of course, depends on the error and/or the situation. Fooling an unsuspecting eye isn't really that hard, just requires some thought and the right tools and materials. Just check the Mohawk catalog,

If, on the other hand, the error is due to a momentary lack of concentration - mis-cutting a piece, something like that - I almost always find that it's the result of me not liking some detail of the design or construction, something I was unwilling or unable to admit to myself. It was there, just below the surface, and the error is a signal, an involuntary burst of personal dissatisfaction. It's a kind of epiphany and it always leads into rewarding territory. Invariably, the "fix" is better than the original idea.

Steve

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

#10

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY ***

wilbur

As long as I can learn something from a mistake, it's not a total loss.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

#11

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY ***

Howard Pollack

I consider mistakes inevitable and think that one mark of a good craftsman is to be able to correct them. That said, I make enough and have to throw away enough to fill a scrap box. Work with them when you can, toss them when you can't...

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF JANUARY *** *LINK*

#12

I never makes mistakes.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Once I thought I did, but it turned out to be a design change my subconscious decided upon.

And if I did make a mistake, I would never admit it here ...

.. or post it on a website, like this: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/SomedaysIshouldstayinbed.html

Regards from Perth

Derek :)