Guess the age
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Guess the age of this chisel. There could be a few who recognise this exact tool. If so, hold off until tomorrow so others can guess.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Guess the age
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Guess the age of this chisel. There could be a few who recognise this exact tool. If so, hold off until tomorrow so others can guess.
Re: Guess the age
Archie
Butcher? Early to mid-1800s...guessing....
Civil War ? 1860s ?
how can one tell?
Bill Tindall
I have no idea but I would like to know what features would lead someone knowledgeable to be able to date it and determine where it was made. There doesn't seem to be anything about it that could not have been done at a very early date so I will guess 18th century if it American. But it it could be Roman I suppose. It would be a pain to grind the pits out so I would have avoided it had it turned up in a flea market. But I do like the pattern.
If that's what I think it is...
Larry Williams
If that's what I think it is it's Dutch and the best photo I've seen of it. I don't want to spoil the age guess but think earlier.
Re: Guess the age
David Weaver
i'll go 1675. I'm going to guess it's from a time that carving tools and chisels were not separate.
Ships Carpenter, Novaya Zemlya
Re: Guess the age
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Warren
Well Larry probably knows something about the chisel ... 
So, if it is Dutch in origin, then it possibly originates with the Dutch East India Company. They did a little exploring around the world. In Southern Africa they, under Jan van Riebeeck landed at the Cape of Good Hope (Cape town) in 1652, and even earlier, in 1642 under Abel Tasman, landed in what is today Tasmania (the southern most part of Australia).
Regards from Perth
Derek
1596
Warren in Lancaster, PA
In 1596, Dutch explorers attempted a North East passage around Russia to avoid South Africa. They were forced to winter over in Nova Zembla (now called Novaya Zemlya). They built a hut from parts of their ship. In June of 1597 they started rowing back to Holland in a small boat. Twelve of the original seventeen made it home in November. This chisel was one of the artifacts left behind. It was frozen and untouched for 290 years. Perhaps if the expedition were successful, Derek would have been born in Siberia.
Bill asked about features that might help to date it. Here are some notes; feel free to correct my suggestions.
1. Tapered octagonal handle. This seems to be the most common pattern late 17th to early 19th century. Later chisels are more likely to have turned handles. The amount of taper shown in Moxon (1683) is more extreme and I have wondered if it was exaggerated by the artist; this chisel is more moderate. It tapers to just a little larger than the bolster.
2. No ferrule. The ferrule also seems to be a 19th century innovation. I am having trouble thinking of 18th century examples.
3. Tapered blade. The blade tapers in width in most 18th century chisels. My feeling is that the amount of taper is reduced as the century wears on, maybe nearly straight by 1800. The taper on this chisel is pretty strong and perhaps the best clue to its early age.
4. Bevelled edge. I think this is a little bit of a surprise. We usually think of this feature as 19th, 20th century. These bevels are strong, maybe forged rather than just ground. Interesting.
5. Bolster. At first glance this looks like the filed octagonal bolsters we see on 19th century tools, but it is not quite so careful, so perhaps just forged, not filed.
It would be nice to see a lot more examples. However, I think it is interesting how little the design changed for the next 300 years.
Warren, where did you get that picture...
Stephen Shepherd
and do you have one of the little horned smoother from the same collection? Best photograph of that chisel that I have seen.
Stephen
Re: Warren, where did you get that picture... *LINK*
Warren in Lancaster, PA
This is a Dutch site for the Rijksmuseum. Here is another picture, click on extra groot right below picture to get large file. I got pictures of other objects by manipulating the number in the address. There are about 200 objects, but not every number gives a picture, so it is a lot of work.
Other tools
that was interesting
Re: 1596
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
In 1596, Dutch explorers attempted a North East passage around Russia to avoid South Africa. They were forced to winter over in Nova Zembla (now called Novaya Zemlya). They built a hut from parts of their ship. In June of 1597 they started rowing back to Holland in a small boat. Twelve of the original seventeen made it home in November. This chisel was one of the artifacts left behind. It was frozen and untouched for 290 years. Perhaps if the expedition were successful, Derek would have been born in Siberia.
Hi Warren
Thanks for the piece of history. Interesting stuff.
For reference, South Africa was not on the map in 1596. The Dutch, along with the English and French, were seeking a passage to the East for the spices. What they were trying to avoid was rounding what came to be called the Cape of Good Hope. It was also called the Cape of Storms, and for good measure. The lower most point of Africa - where the Indian Ocean meets the Atlantic, was known for its violent sea storms, which caused many ship wrecks as sailors attempted to round the Cape. Eventually, in 1652, the Dutch landed at the Cape and colonised it.
No doubt I have family in Siberia as well - they are everywhere! 
I look back on my childhood in South Africa and recognise how much my interest in furniture and wood is influenced by my early memories there. Certainly, the military chests I recently completed were a result of recalling those belonging to a brother-in-law. The furniture of Southern Africa has a strong French influence. Not only did the Dutch colonise the Cape (where I lived), but the French Hugonots did so too in an attempt to avoid persecution for their religious beliefs. Their furniture style has a delicateness ... much less ornate and less heavy than the British, who came to colonise the country in the late 1800s (some of my ancestors among them). There is a Shaker feel to some pieces.

This is a Yellowwood (the light wood) and Stinkwood (the dark wood) jongmanskas (young man's chest).

Above, a typical table (although a modern one) of the Cape Dutch style. These were typically made with Yellowood tops and Stinkwood legs, for use in the kitchen. We have one we use as a dining table that is 200 years old.

Tolletjie (spindle) chair, in Stinkwood, with a riempie seat (leather thong), from the early 18C.
![]()
Settee from the early 1800s.
The farming areas, particularly, retain the influence of the Dutch settlers in the architecture ..

Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: 1596
bugbear
4. Bevelled edge. I think this is a little bit of a surprise. We usually think of this feature as 19th, 20th century. These bevels are strong, maybe forged rather than just ground. Interesting.
Surprised the hell out of me, at that date.
BugBear