New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Dough bowl progress

Posts

Dough bowl progress

#1

Dough bowl progress

Patrick Gibbons

This is a project I determined to do about 10 years ago and so I bought most necessities back then. My major source for info is Sculpting Traditional Bowls by Rip and Tammi Mann. Because I could not find the right items 10 years ago this project stayed on the back burner. The traditional method is to use green wood. Only three tools are needed; a bowl adze, a bowl shave and scorp. I was able to find a hand adze, but it's not a bowl adze. The bowl adze has a handle that curves back towards the blade. I also found a scorp but the bowl shave was no where to be found. Rather than green wood I bought some 4" thick basswood.

Because the wood was dry, I used saws to shape the outside and accomplished this with great success. The corners were rounded with a scrub plane, rasp and sandpaper.

I have been using my adze to shape the inside and like the old joke; I just flew in from the coast and boy are my arms tired.

Perhaps there are carvers out there who can steer me towards a better way of hollowing out the bowl. Sir Roy used a bowl gouge in one of his books. I know the best solution is to locate some green wood and start over, but I want to at least finish this one first. Any ideas?

Re: Dough bowl progress

#2

Re: Dough bowl progress

Patrick Gibbons

I'm going to try drilling today to see if that will waste some wood faster. Then I'll gouge out the remainder. I'll let you know if it works- all three of you who've read this.

Re: Dough bowl progress

#3

David Barnett

I've used scorps, hooked knives and gouges

David Barnett

"I'll let you know if it works- all three of you who've read this."

I must be one of the three, Patrick, but I didn't jump in because my hand tool of choice these days for such work is not hand powered: a Kuzall doughnut wheel on a 4 1/2" angle grinder. Sad thing, I truly enjoyed doing it the quiet way, but it's hard to go back once you've been seduced by Kutzalls for trenchers, bowls and spoons.

Re: Dough bowl progress

#4

Gutter adze and crooked knife

Bob Hackett

The alternative is I`d clamp it in the milling machine. :)

Re: Dough bowl progress

#5

Re: Dough bowl progress

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I read this yesterday, Patrick, and have been thinking about it. I have talked with Rip Mann a few times, watched him work, held his tools, and a friend bought his book. Without seeing your adze, how it is sharpened, how you use it, it is tough solve a problem. I am a carver. My suggestion is to work with a gouge and mallet on smaller pieces 1x6x6 or 2x8x8 or so. Lots of us burn this size of scrap. Get comfortable with both efficient hogging out and getting a fine surface straight from the gouge. Dry wood or green wood will work.

Even if you are determined to work on the basswood, I would go with the gouge and mallet. The reason is that with the gouge it is easier to cut just where you want and easier to learn efficiency. Even though your wood is dried, I think your problem has more to do with your technique than the dried wood. And I think a person who is good with the gouge can visualise what to do with the adze.

Re: Dough bowl progress

#6

post scriptum

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would carve the inside first. It is hard to hold the blank when the outside is already shaped.

Re: Dough bowl progress

#7

Re: post scriptum

Patrick Gibbons

Warren, going by Rip's book, the outside is done first because one uses the adze to hollow out. I think my technique and the sharpness of the blades does have a lot to do with the success, and lack of, I'm having. That's why I'm considering this a learning project. Ideally I want to make four of these so it's worth the experimentation and taking my time. Thanks for the heads up about the gouge and technique.

Re: Dough bowl progress

#8

Re: post scriptum

Pam Niedermayer

How does using an adze to hollow out the piece make a difference in whether you start the shaping on the outside or inside?

Pam, who'd probably have started with the inside, too

Re: Dough bowl progress

#9

Re: post scriptum

Bruce, a MN Galoot

A spoon is not a bowl, but I just finished a set of 8 serving spoons, carved in walnut. I tried doing the outside first on one and found it nigh unto impossible to do the inside. The rest got the insides carved first.

Re: Dough bowl progress

#10

Re: post scriptum

david weaver

If I had to use a gouge, I'd start with the inside. If i had to use an adze, I'd do at least some outside work on the bowl before doing the final cuts on the inside.

This illustrates why pretty clearly. Can you imagine handing a squared blank to move the bowl around with an adze?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cR8z4ehrbQA

Re: Dough bowl progress

#11

A couple of reasons why not

Bob Hackett

That guy in the video is obviously doing a demo and knows what he`s doing. He`s hewing the inside one handed with body parts still in the path of a very sharp edge. I cringe when I think of a beginner doing it this way. It`s an invitation to the ER. Not a good example for others and not the way I`ve seen serious bowl makers do things.

I was given the book by Rip and Tammy Mann but also own the book by Willie Sundqvist which goes into much more depth about all the phases of carving a wide variety of treen (tools used in the kitchen). He advocates and has great success using readily available tools that are still being made such as adzes, hatchets and bent gouges. He also demonstrates techniques and ways to hold the work that allow the work to be held simply, securely and independently. This allows you to use both hands to control the cutting tool of choice. Even more importantly, his techniques allow you to get your whole body behind the cutting operation. This gives you better control,more applied power and maybe most importantly, it keeps all your body parts out from it front of any sharp edges that can quickly cause serious injury.

While I like some of Mann`s work I can`t say I agree with his techniques or his methods of instruction. If you want to make more than one bowl and stay out of the doctor`s office go buy a copy of Sundqvist`s book and follow it. Leave Mann`s on the coffee table where it belongs.

Re: Dough bowl progress

#12

David Barnett

Using one's body to stop a blade the smart way.

David Barnett

That is, without slicing or stabbing oneself. Sundqvist uses body positions as stops to limit where the edge ends up. This considerably lowers risk and makes all non-jigged edge tool use entirely enjoyable. These are also techniques found in Sloyd.

Getting harder to find old copies of Swedish Carving Techniques, but worth the effort and cost.

Re: Dough bowl progress

#13

Yeah, all the way around.


Re: Dough bowl progress

#14

Re: post scriptum

Pam Niedermayer

Thanks, David.

First, I didn't realize you guys meant hand adzes necessarily. Maybe an adze is defined as hand held?

Second, I wouldn't expect the outside to be square necessarily, given a fondness for tree sections, but more stable, more easily held/braced/clamped independently. But I agree that this would be too heavy and potentially awkward to hand hold.

Third, who works like that guy in the video? I don't think I would. In fact, he kind of illustrates why you might want to do the inside first.

Pam

Re: Dough bowl progress

#15

Whew, made me cringe, too.


Re: Dough bowl progress

#16

Re: Using one's body to stop a blade the smart way

Pam Niedermayer

There are some Swedish bowl carving books and dvds on the Country Workshop site.

Pam

Re: Dough bowl progress

#17

Re: post scriptum

david weaver

The thought of a chouna didn't occur to me until just now. Sometimes I don't remember all aspects.

I guess I really wouldn't have too much of an issue with working the way that guy is working, but I would probably do it sitting and holding the bowl with my hand under the bowl. But I don't know, I've not made a bowl, and I've only done spoons with gouges and and a carving knife.

I'd guess pretty much anyone who reduced stock with a hatchet would figure out a way to use an adze like that pretty safely. Personally, I'd start slow and make sure what happened was what I expected to happen, but at the same time I'd expect to be comfortable with it before the end of the bowl.

Thinking about it now that you've brought out chouna (indirectly maybe, but that's what I'm inferring), I would probably leave it flat and remove most of the material standing before I went to rounding the back. But I think I'd like to finish it in a way that guy was doing it. I've seen other people do most of the initial removal on large bowls (if doing it by hand) with an axe, and with the blank on the floor. Not a lot different than a chouna, I guess.

Re: Dough bowl progress

#18

Pam

Patrick Gibbons

The outside slope defines the walls which are finished on the inside. Because the bowl can be held against a surface when using an adze, it doesn't need to be clamped. The whole point to the traditional method is the ease in which it can be executed, that is, no clamping necessary. The shape of the bowl, the outside, is determined than the inside is executed to finish up.

Re: Dough bowl progress

#19

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Dough bowl progress

Stephen Shepherd

Drill a row of holes next to each other across the grain on each end of the dough bowl blanks. Then split out the waste in between, after carefully checking the grain, scoring along the grain on both sides if necessary. Saves a lot of work.

Stephen

Re: Dough bowl progress

#20

Re: post scriptum *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer

Thinking about it now that you've brought out chouna (indirectly maybe, but that's what I'm inferring), I would probably leave it flat and remove most of the material standing before I went to rounding the back. But I think I'd like to finish it in a way that guy was doing it. I've seen other people do most of the initial removal on large bowls (if doing it by hand) with an axe, and with the blank on the floor. Not a lot different than a chouna, I guess.

I didn't specify a chona, even though that's what I use, a Hamaguri style; but there are several other tools that can be used the same way. I'd also get out all I could before shaping the back, want to keep those swinging sharp edges away from body parts as long as possible. This is easier if the log is kept clamped and stationary.

Pam, who paid a LOT less than Iida-san is charging these days


Chona from Iida

Re: Dough bowl progress

#21

Re: Pam

Pam Niedermayer

I just think this type process is made much easier, to say nothing of safer, by keeping the log clamped. I can't afford artificial limbs, although this changes next month when Medicare kicks in.

Pam

Re: Dough bowl progress

#22

Re: Using one's body to stop a blade the smart way

James Watriss

Any recommendations of titles to seek out?

I have an upcoming project that involves researching sloyd, I'm trying to dig through as much material as possible.

Re: Dough bowl progress

#23

Re: Pam

Patrick Gibbons

I revisited St. Roy on the subject and he hews the inside first, then the outside. I'm still experimenting but either way it's hard doing the inside.

Re: Dough bowl progress

#24

Re: Pam *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer

Sure, it's hard doing the inside; but I picked up a trick on another of Roy's episodes, from season 30 I think, with Eli Bas... making a windsor chair. Eli drills holes all around the seat top to mark the depth needed, then scorps and shaves until he reaches the bottoms of the holes. Pretty cool, and much faster than some sort of C measure that has to be constantly taken.

He studied with Curtis Buchanan, who has a wonderful windsor chair building series on YouTube, step by step, so far about 39 episodes.

Pam


Curtis Buchanan on YouTube