New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

A comment for perspective chisel makers

Posts

A comment for perspective chisel makers

#1

A comment for perspective chisel makers

Bill Tindall

A bolster is not necessary for a tanged chisel but if it is desired for what ever reason the chisel does not have to be forged to have a bolster. Once again the knife makers have pioneered the way. The modern high performance tool steels are heat treated at such a high temperature that silver soldering does not soften these hardened steels. The knife makers have shown that a bolster can be silver soldered onto the heat treated blade with no loss of hardness to the blade. edge.

Hence, an amateur tool maker can employ modern steel and heat treating along with simple sawing, grinding and silver soldering, if you must, to yield a chisel of equivalent form, and more or less equivalent function, as a forged tool.

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#2

For the O1-W1 crowd

Bob Hackett

For smaller chisels clamp the blade between 2 copper bars and for larger chisels stick the blade into a small bucket of wet sand and you can still silver solder the bolster without drawing the temper in the blade enough to matter during your lifetime.

Better yet get your buddy the welder to zap it with the MIG or TIG and Bob`s your uncle. ;)

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#3

question for you bolster boys

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Okay. Let's assume I bite the time bullet and decide to mfg my own chisels. Why is is necessary to solder - or weld - the bolster in place? Can't I just fit it carefully to the shoulders of the tang, drive it home and let mother friction hold it in place?

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#4

craigd

Re: For the O1-W1 crowd

craigd

I've had success with brass brazing bolsters, then tempering O-1. Brass melts close to O-1's critical temp so with a little care, it doesn't run all over the place. If you heat treat with a torch, the is no reason to get the bolster area all that hot.

I have switch to fitted bolsters - the tang is stepped (ie the blade has shoulders) and I make a cap with a slot for the tang. The other end of the cap fits the handle like a socket. I use a steel hammer for driving these chisels.

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#5

Re: question for you bolster boys

TomD

The bolsters on most modern knives were not being hit with anything, which allows them to even be epoxied. Chisels are a different mater.

Many makers of knives that are designed to be used in combat, do not want their tangs welded. Welds can weaken the metal too much. What welding does and doesn't do is a pretty complex subject. For instance many of these same knives would have forge welded blades because they are argued to be more durable. But tangs are a different mater.

One way to go with modern steels is to make parts integral. Grinding removes material so quickly you can simply grind some of these features in. The easiest way to mount a really strong handle is to epoxy bond it. This is not just adding a dab of glue. You want to float the tang in a socket of epoxy. This is how one adds maximum strength load take-offs to wooden structures, when there isn't much space. It is also the easiest method.

At the other extreme, a lot of home made tools do not need to be ultimate in durability. Home made tools can be easily replaced or rebuilt. They are presumably to be used by non-thugs. Probably the user has some respect for them. Home made tools also are fast to make, and one can all of a sudden have a specialty tool for every use, so individual tools see less wear. One can lavish the really heavy construction on the odd tool that really needs it, without overbuilding every other tool. One doesn't have to give each tool the same construction so that it will match a set for marketing reasons.

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#6

yes

Bill Tindall

Yes unless you intend to bash it with something bigger than a 3 pound hammer.

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#8

Re: yes

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Works for me. I only whack with a 1 pounder.

It seems to me that Dean Jansa and Mike Siemsen made their chisels pretty much as you did and the bolster was attached in that way. But I seem to be wrong about such things with frightening regularity. :D

Thanks, Bill!

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#9

Re: question for you bolster boys

Pam Niedermayer

The easiest way to mount a really strong handle is to epoxy bond it. This is not just adding a dab of glue. You want to float the tang in a socket of epoxy. This is how one adds maximum strength load take-offs to wooden structures, when there isn't much space. It is also the easiest method.

And if you have to change the handle?

Pam

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#10

Re: yes

Dean J in MN

Yep. The bolsters are sitting on a little shoulder in the main chisel, so all the hammering force is transfered into the chisel. There is no way the bolster can come off, they were undersized a little and then "convinced" to become part of the chisel with a large hammer. :)

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#11

Re: question for you bolster boys

Bob Hackett

Heat will release epoxy Pam. A heat gun will supply enough heat to release the tang and yet not have any effect on the temper.

Here`s my take on bolsters,if you`re going to be beating the sense out of it use a socket chisel,that`s why they were invented.

For paring chisels you don`t need much bolster if any at all. If you can split your handle while pushing a chisel by hand then I don`t want to shake hands with you any time soon.

For a chisel that may see some occasional mallet work then I have friend who grinds shoulders just ahead of the tang,drills whatever smaller coin he pulls out of his pocket,slides it over the tang and calls it good, no welding, brazing or epoxy needed. He burns the tangs into the handle after he presses on a ferrule and when the coin bottoms out he`s ready to go to work. He has replaced more than a few split handles (mostly because he uses kiln dried scraps instead of riven stock for handles) but has yet to have to replace any coin bolsters and quite a few of them are pennies because he`s wicked cheap.

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#12

Re: question for you bolster boys

Pam Niedermayer

Most of my Japanese chisels have both tang and socket, after a fashion; and I can remove a handle by holding onto the blade and knocking the handle on a bench/table. This often destroys the handle; but it does come off.

I don't see how the epoxy inside a handle is heated. Two ways: 1) heat the blade and 2) heat the handle. The latter would definitely set fire to the handle, the prior could damage the blade's temper. I know, you guys say it doesn't, so I'll believe you, but how is this so?

Pam

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#13

craigd

Re: picture please

craigd

Here are three stubby firmer chisels (1/4, 3/8, 1/2), O-1 laminated to mild steel (on the cheap, just welded; 1/4 is all O-1). The blank at the bottom shows the shoulders that the bolster butts against (which the 1/4 lacks since the bolster was brass brazed on pre heat treat).


In case you are wondering, the lamination is pretty much just to add meat, the O-1 layer is too thick to get any benefit.

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#14

There`s heat and then there`s HEAT

Bob Hackett

Remember Pam that heat is a relative thing. You can heat the steel of the chisel hot enough to get the epoxy to release yet still be nowhere near the temp it takes to have an effect on the temper or cause permanent damage to the handle.

Suspending the blade of your chisel in a pot of boiling water is another good way to get the job done.

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#15

Re: picture please

Bob Hackett

That last pic is an excellent example of the kind of tool that can be salvaged from the center of an old heavily pitted chisel that most folks would consider junk.

I pick them up for next to nothing (like 4 for a dollar) at flea markets and yard sales.

The trick is to visualize what remains after you grind all the rusted crap away. You have to be able to see that "tool within the tool".

That clapped out, beat down and pitted laminated timber framing chisel could very well end up looking like that last pic. If the softer portion is too heavily pitted to retain the needed thickness then it may make a very nice thin paring chisel that retains that "buttery smooth" feel on the stones that others here have raved about.

Some folks are amazed to see many of the bark spuds I use and sometimes give away are actually re-purposed laminated chisels. They`d be even more amazed if they saw the "before" pictures. :)

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#16

Re: picture please

Bill Tindall

How are the ferrules made , or made from?

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#17

tangs and splitting handles

Bill Tindall

I put shoulders on the top of my tanged chisels to offer some support. I have beat handles in the handle seating process (when it has gone awry) with a 2 # hammer with the chisel clamped in a vice until the chisel slid in the clamped jaws yet never split a handle made from a dogwood limb section. Such a handle will never split in any woodworking circumstance. Bolsters undeniably look nice but they are not necessary if the handle wood is robust.

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#18

Re: There`s heat and then there`s HEAT

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, yeah, I know. I just don't get any joy from pondering epoxy. :)

Pam

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#19

craigd

Re: picture please

craigd

>How are the ferrules made , or made from?

Mild steel rod on a lathe. Put the rod in a collet, drill and then square the inside. The tang hole was drilled and filed to fit, rather than cut on the mill because the hole in the handle wasn't centered.

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#20

Re: question for you bolster boys

TomD

Pam, it isn't hard to replace an epoxy bonded handle, there are lots of ways. Most are probably going to require breaking something, but if something wasn't broken it probably wouldn't need replacing. Hate to be roundabout, but there are just so many different starting points, it would be impractical to try to describe it. That said, epoxy cuts about as easily as wood so it isn't difficult to work with.

I did once try to replace a Japanese handle, which is about when I figured out that they were finish ground, which is more trouble than anything else I am imagining here.

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#21

Re: epoxy and heat

TomD

I sorta gave up on heat after running into glues that were hugely resistant to it. Also if it smokes one is into some nasty stuff.

I am recommending epoxy bonding, which is used on some name brand chisels, and is pretty similar to plastic handled chisels, in some respects. So if one had a 3/8" chisel shank, one might drill a 3/8-1/2" hole, and then pot the shank in there. it would probably be hooped. There are several advantages to this. Epoxy bonds well to metal, particularly when it comes to a male female type interface. Epoxy glues well to wood. But metal does not bond to wood. As important is that the act of potting the metal in a socket of glue increases the surface area and spreads the load.

Anyway. simplest method to get the handle off would be to simply split the handle, then pare back the wood, or grind it. Prepare another handle with the appropriate hole, and bond it in.

Re: A comment for perspective chisel makers

#22

Re: The joys of epoxy

TomD

Ask this little girl what she thinks of wood epoxy:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BnLmKXY-FCg

The Ron Hock chisel that LMII makes/sells seems to be epoxy bonded.