New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Question for Bill Tindall and others

Posts

Question for Bill Tindall and others

#1

Stephen Shepherd

Question for Bill Tindall and others

Stephen Shepherd

How abrasive is graphite?

Stephen

Re: Question for Bill Tindall and others

#2

Pretty slick stuff, IMO, so not very abrasive.


Re: Question for Bill Tindall and others

#3

In relation to what?


Re: Question for Bill Tindall and others

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: And while we're on the subject

Moses Yoder

How slick is snot?

Re: Question for Bill Tindall and others

#5

Is this a trick question

Bill Tindall

Graphite is a lubricant. Its crystal structure is such that the crystal planes have little cohesive force between them. As a result they slide past one another with ease. Hence, if graphite is between two pieces of metal, for example, this slippage provides lubrication, not abrasion.

It has a mineral hardness of 1 on the Moh's scale(1 to 10), the same as talc, while aluminum oxide is 9 and diamond 10. (this is not a linear scale).

Re: Question for Bill Tindall and others

#6

Stephen Shepherd

Talc is an abrasive


Re: Question for Bill Tindall and others

#7

In what application?


Re: Question for Bill Tindall and others

#8

In short, not very abrasive.

John in NM

Though it could be used for polishing something much softer than itself.

Demand for graphite as an abrasive would be limited by the futility of maintaining a polish on something soft enough to be polished by it.

Is there any point to asking why you ask?

Re: Question for Bill Tindall and others

#9

Re: Talc is an abrasive

Alex Grigoriev

I think Moh scale doesn't correspond to abrasive qualities, especially for materials easily friable.