New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

adjusting set on japanese saw

Posts

adjusting set on japanese saw

#1

adjusting set on japanese saw

Mike

I bought a 300mm japanese rip saw (tatebiki) and was a little bit disappointed. The blade is decently made taper ground, and pretty thin 0.03-0.026". However, the set is too much. The kerf is bigger than a western handsaw. It was most likely configured for softwood. Is there any way to reduce the set on these saw (e.g. stoning the teeth just like western saw)?

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#2

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

Mike

Forgot to mention. The saw is supposed to be hand-made not impulse hardened teeth.

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#3

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

wilbur

Stoning the teeth can be done with Japanese saws, just like they are done with western saws. I'd give it a try.

Out of curiosity, where did you get your saw from?

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#4

Japanese saw setting *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer

Check out the link below for Mark Grable's (metate US) approach. And if this is a very valuable saw, might be worth a trip for it to Mark's.

And an addendum from Dave Burnard from a couple of years ago.

dburnard

PostPosted: Wed Mar 25, 2009 1:34 pm Post subject: Reply with quote

The setting hammer has a series of small teeth filed/cut into the striking end, the finer the better but scaled to the size of saw teeth you are setting. Yataiki's saw setting hammers are very fine compared to the marks I've seen on other saws. The teeth shouldn't actually be sharp, since their purpose is to deform rather than to cut. Many of the setting hammers marks I've seen do look like sharp cuts, which could cause problems. Yataiki leaves his saw bodies and teeth pretty hard, so sharp teeth may not be an option, whereas of softer saw teeth it may not matter so much.

Anyway, the little beveled shoulder on the setting anvil doesn't actually do the bending, it's the little teeth on the setting hammer hitting and stretching out the struck side of the tooth. The little beveled shoulder gives the tooth tip somewhere to go as the tooth bends. So you rest the tooth near that transition, so there's something behind the hammer blow, on the body of the tooth, and so that the tip is free to deflect downward as the tooth acquires set.

As the process level, it's the same manipulation used to tap out a plane blade...

Jim

PostPosted: Thu Mar 26, 2009 10:35 pm Post subject: Reply with quote

I remember speaking with yataiki while showing him a saw I set.

My anvil had a champher and my hammer hits localized causing the set bend to be an angle. He had suggested the anvil be a small radius and the tooth set shape to be an arc. Made a huge difference. Positive support, meaning anvil support directly under the hammer blows is critical. Practicing the hammer swing to have the same power every time is also helpful.

I just recently acquired a few saw hammers, but I need something more in the way of an anvil, so for the moment I continue to use a flat saw set which bends the teeth. This seems to give me more control, but it's an old tool, not something you can buy at LN/LV.


Pam


Grable on pointing teeth

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#5

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

Pam Niedermayer

How drastically have you stoned a saw? This is a real question, because I question stoning for more complicated teeth and/or a large amount of set to remedy. And if you've done it successfully, I'll have the courage to try this. :)

Pam, who hopes she hasn't inadvertently offended, not my intent

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#6

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

wilbur

I've successfully stoned the rip and crosscut teeth on a 270mm and a 300mm ryoba. I guess to be more accurate, I should say that I stoned the teeth and didn't completely screw it up, as the saw still cut. ;)

Seriously, the teeth seemed to cut more smoothly after the stoning. I wasn't paying too much attention to how much the kerf changed after the stoning, although it seemed to narrow enough that I said to myself, "Oh, look. The kerf got thinner."

Buying rusty old ryobas off of eBay for very little money and going to town on them with files goes a long way towards building up confidence in altering the teeth, if for no other reason than to see what happens. But I do think that the majority of western saw sharpening/filing/tuning techniques do translate to Japanese saws.

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#7

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

Pam Niedermayer

Buying rusty old ryobas off of eBay for very little money and going to town on them with files goes a long way towards building up confidence in altering the teeth, if for no other reason than to see what happens. But I do think that the majority of western saw sharpening/filing/tuning techniques do translate to Japanese saws.

In the past couple of months I've bought a couple of old Japanese saws - one really good one from Alex that he says is kinked slightly, but danged if I can see it, probably won't until I saw with it, and I'm counting on George Wilson's boiling water trick to work. From him I also bought a bunch of appropriate files, just getting ready. So your experience is very encouraging, and I'll dig into them when I can. I agree that western saw tuning techniques should work more often than not.

I did buy an old Japanese saw some years ago and was also encouraged that none of the cleaning (sandpapering and minimal sharpening) I did killed it; but it is a Maebiki with huge teeth, just loves those tree trunks. I'd have to work a long time to muck it up.

Pam

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#8

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw *LINK*

wilbur

I did a series of posts on my blog about sharpening Japanese saws. Definitely not Mark Grable quality, and most likely not completely in line with historic practices, but it seems to work, and makes sense to me in terms of getting a better understanding of the tooth geometry.

http://giantcypress.net/tagged/Japanese_saw_sharpening


My approach to Japanese saw sharpening

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#9

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

Pam Niedermayer

I read your blog on saw sharpening, very good job, thanks. Ron Herman? Never heard of him; but would you say his video is more comprehensive than Tom Law's (not to mention that all I have is a video tape version of Law's)?

Pam

PS, some unwanted feedback on your blog page: What the ---- is that 1" high bar doing inserting itself between my bookmarks bar and the blog entry? It actually overlays the stuff I'm trying to read and there doesn't seem to be a way to turn it off in Chrome.


Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#10

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

wilbur

That floating header came with the theme that I'm using. On my laptop, it's a little less than 1/2" high. I kind of like it, myself, as it keeps the header links handy as you scroll down the page.

I haven't seen Tom Law's video, but Ron Herman's video is just great. After seeing Ron Herman's video, it was the first time that I really was able to wrap my brain around the saw sharpening process, and I was able to quickly get a better handle on what I'm doing with Japanese saws. He also covers stoning the teeth of a saw.

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#11

I have both the Law and Herman DVDs.

Chuck Nickerson

I find the Herman DVD much more complete.

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#12

Re: I have both the Law and Herman DVDs.

Gordon Thomas

Mike:

Can you share with us the maker of the saw. My reason for asking is that the steel varies considrably from one to another. For example, Heiji has switched to tempering his steel to a harder finish than in previous years. The result is that the saw is more difficult to adjust/ sharpen and definitely more susceptible to breaking - this has not been my experience but, comes straight from Heiji himself.

best

Gordon

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#13

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

Mike

I got the saw from Hida tool. It is called Nakaya, however, I think there are quite a few different saw makers with Nakaya surname. This saw feel harder than the Disston saws I have but I am not sure how it compare with other non-impulse hardened Japanese saw. It's not super expensive, ~$100. However, rip kataba seems hard to come by, so to me it could be a gem if I can get it to work.

I have no setting hammer, anvil, nor the skill to adjust the set. I will most likely send it to a professional to have it adjusted. However, will this weaken the teeth? For stoning, I think I can do it myself as I have done that with western saws. But I prefer not to as that will remove materials from the teeth, or is it a common practice for Japanese saw, too?

My frustration could have been my lack of understanding of Japanese saw. I had a 240mm machine made ryoba and a couple dozukis before this saw. Therefore, my expectation has always been very thin kerf. For a 300mm saw, should the kerf be similar to a regular western handsaw?

btw, I bought the remaining stocks of Nakaya from Hida tool. This 300mm and a 210mm. The 210mm perform extremely well with the test cuts I made. So, I really want this 300mm to work well.

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#14

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

Pam Niedermayer

Since I'm no longer developing software, my laptop is a small 13" screen MacBook, suitable for writing. There's nothing, repeat nothing, amusing about that bar stealing 1/2" of my available 7", particularly since it overlays part of what I'm trying to read. I understand that it might be useful for updating your blog. I'd bet the template was designed on a really big screen.

Thanks to you and Gordon for the Herman video referral, I ordered it a few minutes ago.

Pam

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

#15

Re: adjusting set on japanese saw

Marv W

Hi Mike,

I side joint every western style saw I file, but not for the purpose of adjusting how the saw tracks or follows a line. The side jointing is only done to account for any minor variances in the setting of the teeth. I do not file Japanese style saws, at least yet. But the same rule applies. If a saw is such that it wants to wander off the line, this means there is something quite wrong with how the teeth are filed and or set. If there is too much set that produces an unnecessary width of kerf, the saw should be refiled and reset. Attempting to reduce the amount of set by bending the teeth in the opposite direction only invites broken teeth, especially on a saw plate that seems to be harder than normal. The safest way to reduce set is to file the excess set away.

Marv