New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

Posts

How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#1

How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hello.

I am making a couple Shaker round tables. Trying to use hand tools as much as I can and/or have hand tools to do the task at hand.

The round table top has a rounded over edge. Because I don't have a proper hand tool to do it, I used a large router bit that put a very slight round over on the table top. I really liked the look, although the top wasn't supported very well and the round over isn't consistent. I cleaned it up with some sand paper and tried using, with some success, a Stanley 51.

I had the same issue with the legs, I wanted just a slight round over. Not a round over like a half radius router bit would do.

The 51 worked ok except for when I hit the end grain sections and it leaves a faceted surface (hope that's the correct term).

I was thinking for the next one, I could make a scratch block kind of tool to round over the edge. I've seen those kind of tools in FWW I think. Would that work? I'm guessing I would have problems with the end grain sections using a scratch block.

I guess my question(s) is, how, before power tools came along, did woodworkers do these types of profiles with alternating grain- going from long to end grain? A concave spokeshave?

The crude image below is kinda like the profile I was going after. This is 3/4" Cherry btw.

Thanks.

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#2

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

david weaver

Plane it like you have and then scrape the facets with a curved card scraper.

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#3

Ellis Walentine

... and if you can bear a modern approach...

Ellis Walentine

... take a block of urethane foam insulation and cut/bandsaw/file a channel in it that matches your profile, then use it as a sanding block with some fine sandpaper.

Ellis

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#4

Concur *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...although there are concave spokeshaves, such as the Stanley 55, as in the linky.

The downside of such a shave is similar to the downside of any "jigged" tool: you can get limited by the shape the manufacturer decided upon. If the curve is consistent with what you want, you're golden; if not, you have to guard against the tendency for the tool to impose its curve anyway.


http://peterrobinson.galootcentral.com/spokeshaves/#Stanley-55-shave

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#5

Re: Concur

TomD

For that exact curve I would use a spokeshave. The edge of the table will have to be worked from 4 directions, to keep going downhill, plus whatever the grain pulls. While the spokeshave has a primary curvature, with several you can get a lot of different curves going. Doing the handles on planes seems to use every tool in the shop. Planes would work just as well if you have hollows.

Be very careful working these edges, there is a huge impact on the design. Often there can be a slight compromise towards safety. But design wise the curves on the edge will affect how the eye flows over the piece. So look at some pictures, consider you base, and how it moves the eye, be sure when you select the treatment that it takes the whole piece into consideration.

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#6

Router bit suggestion

Bill Tindall

Eagle America sells a "Furniture/Box Making" bit (102-2025) that makes a nice bull nose profile with two passes. Just slight blending required. I have used this bit for many bull nosed edge situations, most recently on the cherry chest of drawers front edges.

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#7

Re: Router bit suggestion

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

For that matter, there are full (makes a half circle) and half radius (makes a flatter profile) bullnose bits that will require no blending at all; but Joe mentioned his desire to do the work with hand tools.

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#8

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

Pam Niedermayer

There's probably a nosing plane somewhere that would do this job quite nicely, so if you have a vibrant old tool market in Cleveland or thereabouts, you may want to start looking. Also other molding planes, maybe a round held at the proper angle. The previous ideas are good, too.

Pam

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#9

Re: Router bit suggestion

Bill Tindall

The bit described is not an arc section of a circle. I don't know what geometric form it is derived from. Because it is such an attractive profile it has become my go to profile for "bull nosing" an edge.

If an arc of a circle is ground into a pane iron bedded at other than 90 degrees it is going to make a profile similar to what this bit makes. I think it will be an ellipse.

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#10

Quick custom scraper shave ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Joe

It would take but a few minutes to create the profile you want by filing a bandsaw blade and using this as a scraper.

Here is a very (!) basic scraper shave I made for a custom shape. Just the bandsaw blade attached to a piece of wood. The wood reinforcement is optional. You can scrape successfully without it.


I simply used a coarse file to form the basic shape, then progressively smoother ones, and ended with a slip. I am sure that you could later find other uses for a standard size, so it is worth making.

Rough out the curve with a block plane then scrape to smooth.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#11

Re: Router bit suggestion

TomD

For the kinds of arcs we get with planes, say 60 degree segments, and the kind of reductions we get going from profile to bedding angle, say by 36% for 45 degrees, it is really tough to see any ellipsis. But on a semi circle smushed by 80% it stands out as you can see in the drawings,

An easy way to get all these curves is in cad. One can draw the profile, then stretch the appropriate axis for the drawing by the angle factor, 1.44 for 45 degree beds, for example.

[/url]

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#12

Re: Quick custom scraper shave ...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I agree with this completely. It's essentially an oversize scratch stock. The really nice thing about this approach is that it'll give you a perfectly uniform, consistent curve. Just a little block plane work to hog off the majority of the wood and scrape away!

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#13

Re: Router bit suggestion

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks Bill.

I drive by that store on occasion. I'll check out this bit. Looks like it would produce the profile I like.

I have another top to make. If I can't do a good job with one of the other suggestions here (using a hand tool of some sort), this bit will probably do it.

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#14

Re: Quick custom scraper shave ...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Derek,

I think what you show is pretty much what I had in mind or figured what I would need.

When you file a profile like this into something like a piece of bandsaw blade, do you also put a bevel on it and hone it like you would a plane blade? Or is the profile filed out with a 90 degree edge like a card scraper?

Also, is the resulting surface ready for finish or do you sand after using it?

Thank you.

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#15

Re: Quick custom scraper shave ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Joe

The scraper was given a 90 degree edge. No burr or bevel.

The finish off this was pretty good. If you refer back to the original picture you will get an idea of what it was like. Here is a blow up of a section (not a great deal of detail but if you squint your eyes and look closely ...) ..


I did sand the scraped edge to 800 grit, but then I wanted a very fine surface. This is much more than I would expect for furniture that ends up oiled. As with this example, the finish of the following example was Shellawax ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#16

finish ready?

Bill Tindall

That depends on the finish. It certainly won't be if you intend to pigment stain. It can be if you are oiling. The surface will be characterized by an abundance of what I call micro-tears, at least in my hands. These micro-tears absorb stain and finish more than the long grain surfaces and go darker, again in my hands. I have had such poor success with end grain and cross grain scraping that I just avoid it.

I have enough mountains to climb in making something that I don't need to tolerate some difficult way of making a profile when a router bit does it quick and reliable. I have scraped moldings with the grain and it is actually quite easy to get a profile unobtainable with a router bit. But I must say that I waste out as much as possible with a table saw and router before scraping.

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#17

I get it.  Thanks.


Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#18

Re: finish ready?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I understand what you are saying Bill, thanks.

The finish will be a quick coat of BLO, then oil based varnish. Although, to be honest, I am up against the wall time-wise, and my skip the BLO. It's a Christmas gift and I am quickly running out of time.

Re: How do you smooth a rounded over edge?

#19

Minor disagreement

roninkokomo

I think the wood makes it so very much easier to use with finesse that I would not call it optional.