New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Grinding plane irons and chisels on sandpaper?

Posts

Grinding plane irons and chisels on sandpaper?

#1

Grinding plane irons and chisels on sandpaper?

Charles Jackson III

When I first started to learn how to sharpen I grinded my blades on 80 grit sandpaper before I went to waterstones and I got a sharp edge that way. Now I cant seem to get a sharp edge. I had bench grinder but sold it then the post office lost so I had to since the guy money back.

Re: Grinding plane irons and chisels on sandpaper?

#2

Re: Grinding plane irons and chisels on sandpaper?

TomD

It's all about finding a process that actually links up and works. There are thousands of potential component part, and there are millions of ways they go together, but they don't all work. Initial shaping on sandpaper can run into problems with rounding. Sandpaper has it's problems, and rounding is probably the worst of them. As the blade rounds one soon finds one can't chase it enough without just making the problem worse. In particular, getting finer grits to deal with the coarser ones is harder the more uncertain the geometry gets. The grinder you sold would make it possible to reset the hollow grind now and then. I also use jigs every now and again if I need to flatten the bevel. I try to avoid jigs otherwise. At one point my million dollar idea was a lee Valley sharpening jig with wheels mounted to slide side to side, or better still to work in both Axises.

Also, minor point, I find quality 220 paper is more than enough for roughing. In fact they can cut faster, because there are more points. I find that the most aggressive paper in my stock is the 220, though it could vary by brand. I think it cuts flatter also. On a grinder I will go as low as 80 grit paper for a regrind.

Re: Grinding plane irons and chisels on sandpaper?

#3

Re: Grinding plane irons and chisels on sandpaper?

Neal in San Jose

As Tom says, it can be done with sand paper. However, there are so many potential problems with sandpaper (so-called "Scary Sharp") that many of us that try it eventually give it up as being more trouble than its' worth. The most common problem is using the wrong sand paper. Most "wet or dry" paper is silicon carbide grit, which has a problem that makes it problematic for working tool steel. It is friable, meaning it fractures easily into smaller and smaller grits. Thus, you may start at 220 grit, but in seconds, you are at 2000 or finer. A big clue is that you find it in the paint department. Works well on paint, which is what it is designed for.

You need aluminum oxide, which is not nearly so friable. It is a little harder to find, but Lee Valley is a good source.

Another problem is that it can roll up in front of your blade as you push it, causing the iron to dub over. You end up with a rounded bevel, and no hope of refining the edge on subsequent finer grits.

People have been making edges sharp since the Egyptians made the pyramids, so a sharpening STONE is a proven method. I know it can take longer, but it conveniently avoids both of the above problems with paper. Too bad you sold your grinder - that's the first step for many blades and chisels in my shop. It's also a huge time-saver when changing sharpening angles, or removing big nicks.

Re: Grinding plane irons and chisels on sandpaper?

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: Grinding plane irons and chisels on sandpaper? *LINK*

Moses Yoder

If you do a search on ebay for "hand cranked grinder" or "hand crank grinder" or "hand grinder" you come up with a variety, like the one below. If you do buy one, it is very beneficial to also buy the Veritas tool rest and you will need a new wheel so you might as well buy this kit from LV. http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=32972&cat=1,43072,45938

Even though it says the grinder is 5", if you remove the tool rest a 6" wheel will probably work, but you will probably need to get a bushing made at a machine shop so the wheel fits on the shaft.


Hand Cranked Grinder

Re: Grinding plane irons and chisels on sandpaper?

#5

Re: Grinding plane irons and chisels on sandpaper?

Charles Jackson III

I currenly have a hand crank grinder but it has no wheel! I took it apart and I dont know if it will work or not.