New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Frame saw

Posts

Frame saw

#1

Bob

Frame  saw

Bob

Over the years I have tried to use a frame saw but I just cannot stay on a line like I can with a hand saw or backsaw. The other day, I had to make some tenons on 3 pieces of 2x4 and grabbed my bow saw because it was handy. I cut dead straight to the line on the first 2 pieces(rip and crosscuts) with almost no effort.I was stoked that I finally was getting the hang of the saw. On the third piece, the saw pulled way to one side, almost ridiculously so.I dont get it. How could I go from dead on perfect to ridiculous in a matter of minutes??

The saw and blade came from woodcraft(if I recall ) and cost maybe 50-60 dollars. The blades are German made and relatively cheap .I hate to blame the equipment but what could have changed? I tried again and did better. I obsessed about the verticality of the blade at the start of the cut.Is this the simple answer or? How do I know if the blade is stiff enough? The handle easily rotates while the blade is in the kerf.That is why I had to obsess over balde verticality. Is that bad or to be expected with a frame saw? The blade is wide, maybe 1.5 or 2.0 inches so it is not like I am using a narrow bow saw blade.

Thanks for any suggestions. The saw would be a delight because it cuts effortlessly but not with consistency.

Re: Frame saw

#2

Re: Frame  saw

John Pappas

Bob, I certainly don't have the answer for you, but I am intrigued by your comment, "The handle easily rotates while the blade is in the kerf." If you had sufficient tension on the blade it doesn't seem to me that the handles would easily rotate. I'm eager to hear other comments, but I will say that I put enough tension on my saw that I can "pluck" the blade and get a nice "ping" sound.....and the handle does not turn easily.

Re: Frame saw

#3

Bob

Re: Frame  saw

Bob

John,

I did check and the saw was a little loose. It has wire across the top which is tightened with a long bolt. I tightened it up and was able to do better with some test cuts but one or two test cuts still got away fom me. I dont know if I have it solved.

Apparently, pot pies are a more interesting topic than the techniques to master the frame saw.

Thanks for your comments and help.

Re: Frame saw

#4

Re: Frame  saw

Bob Hackett

The way you get to where you can consistently follow a line with a saw is the same way you get to Carnegie Hall, PRACTICE!

What I do with any tool that is giving me less than optimal results is to first try to understand how and why that tool does it`s job. There is always the chance that I am trying to use a less than appropriate tool for the job at hand.

If The bow saw you are trying to use to cut dovetails is the same one you were using yesterday to prune the Apple tree then the answer to your problem should be obvious.

There must be a reason you bought this frame saw and keep picking it up. I would start my investigation by going back to the source and re-read the article that made me think I needed a frame saw or pay a visit to the person I saw using a saw just like it and made me think I could duplicate their results. Once you return to the source you have a better chance of seeing two important things;the first is seeing where you may be doing things or looking at things in a different way that may be causing your unacceptable results and more importantly you can now begin to see some of the ways that the source`s tools and techniques differ from your own and why those(sometime subtle) differences make all the difference in the final result.

Re: Frame saw

#5

Bob

Re: Frame  saw

Bob

Bob,

I agree that practice is important. I was able to split the line on several cuts on the piece I was cutting and then I suddely got wildly off course. (I can do far better with a western saw with my eyes closed time and again so I am coordinated enough to have decent repeatability.)

I originally bought the frame saw based on comments made by numerous people including Tage Frid and F. Klausz. I believe it is the standard tool in Europe.They have done well with them over the centuries.

I like frame saws because the cut is almost effortless. I live in remote Wi. and do not have people close by that are skillful with a frame saw to observe their technique.

From comments in another post, I believe my saw is a little out of tension and will try a tighter blade.

Re: Frame saw

#6

Re: Frame  saw

Sean FitzGerald

hello

if you look at pics of frank klauz's saw you will notice a shim between the end grain of the stretcher and the arm(s). when you tighten the wire or string the saw arms pivot around the stretcher. When the distance between the arms at the stretcher is a little greater than the distance between the arms at the blade it is easier to properly tension the blade. try it, it works for me maybe it will work for you as well.