New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Stanly 45

Posts

Stanly 45

#1

Stanly 45

eliot d

Years ago I purchased one of these with a bunch of blades of all kinds of shapes. This plane has several outriggers and all kinds of little adjustable feet and other knobs, etc. My problem is that I don't know how to use it. I wanted to clean up a rabbit the other day and just couldn't figure the thing out. Anyone willing to help me out, please?

Re: Stanly 45

#2

Re: Stanly 45 *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I don't recommend using a Stanley 45 on rabbits - too hard to clean the fur off.

On the other hand, they're great on rabbets (or, if you're British or Aussie, rebates) and other uses.

You want to spend time reading at Alf's Cornish Workshop page, linked below. The book "Planecraft," available from Woodcraft or from the used book purveyors, is good, too (get the original by Hampton, not the later Sainsbury re-do).

The most important lesson I got, relevant for about any fenced plane: start at the far end and do a 6" or so stroke, then work your way back the board until you're doing full-length strokes. Helps dramatically to keep things aligned.


http://www.cornishworkshop.co.uk/combinationplanes.html

Re: Stanly 45

#3

Re: Stanly 45

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

"too hard to clean the fur off"

You almost made me spit my wine! LMAO!!!

DC

Re: Stanly 45

#4

Re: Stanly 45

eliot d

Bill, I can't thank you enough! The link is perfect! Just what I was hoping for. (And I do feel foolish about not knowing even how to spell it!) What do you expect from us machine types?

Re: Stanly 45

#5

my dismal experience

Bill Tindall

I inherited a Stanley 55 from a joiner relative of generations past. If anyone has ever successfully put a molding on a piece of hardwood with one of these things please let me know and maybe I will dust off the instruction book I bought for it and give it another try.

However, if anyone is tempted to buy one of these because they need to make moldings I would recommend instead the set of Lee Valley router bits patterned after the Stanley 55 profiles. They work just fine in cases where a piece of molding is required to get on with a project. I just finished making 200' of oak shoe molding with one of these bits. I would have slit my wrists had I been required to use the Stanley 55.

Re: Stanly 45

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: my dismal experience

Moses Yoder

Is that router as in electric router?

Re: Stanly 45

#7

Re: my dismal experience

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

Patrick Leach seems to harbor the same feelings towards the plane...

http://supertool.com/StanleyBG/stan8.htm

DC

Re: Stanly 45

#8

Re: Stanly 45

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I hope you know I was just teasing; and that typo is pretty common.

Re: Stanly 45

#9

Re: my dismal experience

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The 45 and the 55 are very different tools. The fence mechanism on the 45 is simpler, for one thing; and there are fewer adjustments to make.

Confession: I own but have yet to use a 55.

But I use my 45 with some regularity when I'm in the shop (as opposed to doing remodeling/refurbishing on the house, which is where a lot of my time/energy has gone for quite a while now). There's a learning curve - there is with every tool, regardless of what powers it - but it's a useful tool, once the basics are mastered.

Re: Stanly 45

#10

Re: my dismal experience

David Weaver

I had a cream puff 55 a while ago. I kept the box as patrick advises, but I was convinced to get the most out of it. I used it for a little trim work in the house, softwood only, and I put together some router table fixtures (back when I did that sort of thing) doing tongue and groove with it.

I wouldn't do anything with it in hardwood other than tongue and groove. Anything else is softwood only, and picky about the grain direction.

In the end, it's not worth the trouble, and I sold it. There's no great reason to fight it or cater to it with stock selection.

I tried for a while to sell it on WN, but I guess I had badmouthed them not too long before, and nobody would even give me $350 for it (keep in mind, cream puff, complete, original box even unused slitter).

I put it on ebay on a straight up auction and someone bought it for just short of $600 when the bidding was done. (I think it cost me $400, so when all was said and done, it was a good purchase, just not for the reason I thought it would be).

Re: Stanly 45

#11

Re: Stanly 45

Brian Greene

You need this book which is specifically about the Stanley 45 & 55 combination planes: http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=44906&cat=1,46096,46100

I have one and I don't use it as much as I should. This book will make it easier.

Re: Stanly 45

#12

One has to wonder...

John in NM

Why there would be a set of router bits to match profiles from the notoriously impossible to use plane? Surely not so that people can match existing moldings, because like you, I doubt that either has ever been successfully used to make more than a foot or two of test stock using perfectly clear and straight white pine (yes, I know someone will come along and disprove that, but I prefer to live in willful ignorance :D ).

When I was a kid in a state where people actually fish, I used to tie and sell fishing flies. Didn't make as much as a paper route, but I didn't have to get up at 4 am either. I noticed the flies that sold the best looked very realistic, but didn't necessarily catch as many fish as something that looked like a dust bunny on a hook. These flies were effective for catching fishermen more than fish :D, and I've always suspected that these two Stanley planes have a similar knack.

Re: Stanly 45

#13

eggs before chickens....

Bill Tindall

First came the commonly used profiles-beads, ogees, asymmetric coves, and the like- created with molding planes. Then came the useless Stanley gizmo that was to create these profiles with one plane and a box of cutters. Then came the Lee Valley "Stanley 55" collection of router bits to make these profiles for those that didn't have a collection of molding planes for the task.

Re: Stanly 45

#14

LV's router bits

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The sharper details on the LV bits are certainly nice - and that sharpness of detail is why (some) people continue to track down wooden molding planes and/or learn or attempt to learn how to use the Stanley 45/55 (I will allow that some folks learn/attempt the 45/55 for reasons of gizmotic obstinance). In comparison, so many router bit profiles look like they were done with a sander.

Re: Stanly 45

#15

I certainly like wooden molding planes

John in NM

And I'll even admit to having owned a 45, which I sold at a loss several years later :D

The chicken and egg irony of 55 profile router bits really struck me funny :D

Re: Stanly 45

#16

Re: Stanley 45

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is a tip for you, Eliot. When you are setting up the 45, secure the handle in your vise so that the plane is upside down and tilted up at an angle toward your eye. In this position it is easy to sight along the runners to check clearance. Also with the plane secure like this you have both hands free to measure the fence setting, set the iron etc.

I bought a 45 plane about 30 years ago, after using one at a friend's shop and one at a historic site where I worked. I have used it for grooves, dados, rabbets, beads and sash. I would not argue that it is the finest tool for any of these operations. However, I never thought it particularly difficult to do careful work. I have not seen beads or sash made by machine that were as clean as what this plane produces.

I have never owned a 55 plane, but I have used one when I was helping to make molding for a historic building. My impression is that the plane was designed for carpenters and that the moldings are mostly appropriate for architectural work.