New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

Posts

Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

#1

Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Friends,

Normally I hang out on the "Messages" page, but now need some input from the hand tool experts.

I inhereted an 8 7/8" X 2 1/2" wooden plane from my dear buddy Kurt, who died several years ago. Occasionally I rehab his old tools and put them back into use in the Colonel's Workshop.

This plane is probably European, as Kurt brought most of his hand tools from Germany after the war. It is of beech. The iron is wedge shaped, very high angle bedding, and has serrated very small teeth machined into the blades back (or front?) There is a beech blade support piece on the back of the plane, dovetailed into the beech body. The body has a very small split at the base of the dovetail socket. It is not continuous, but can be widened with slight pressure. Super glue would repair it effectively. The glue failed in the dovetail and the support is free. Inspection showed a very small amount of glue had been used to secure the support to the plane. Probably hide glue. Kurt was a cabinet/coffin maker before the war. Any reason not to use Titebond to permanently and continaully register the support to the plane body?

The body has a metal bar through the planes throat which captures a beech wedge, applying pressure to the iron, all backed up by the plane's throat angle. It is a steep angle, whether or not the blade is installed bevel up or down. In one position it seems the angle exceeds verticality. What is the proper position of the iron?

I noticed the throat opening at the sole isn't square with the plane, and there seems a lot of room between the blade and the surrounding sole slot. Does this make a real difference? With wedge installed, the iron seems rock solid. I could "square" the opening but risk misaligning the sole opening and wedge/iron support. The tool looks like it was "born" that way, and it must have worked okay for decades. I could fashion an auxiliary sole and glue it to the plane bottom. Any comments?

Lastly, what finish should I use on the cleaned up and sanded body? Poly okay, or BLO?

Sorry about some of the terminology used to describe the tool. I hope I've been clear enough for your understanding. Please tell me what you'd do if this was your plane.

George

Re: Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

#2

Re: Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

Bill Tindall

I'll give an opinion on the last question. Some BLO on 4/0 steel wool is a good grunge cleaner. BLO is actually an excellent solvent for oily grunge like body oils from sweaty hands and the like and it leaves a sufficiently protective finish.

Re: Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

#3

Re: Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

Bob Hackett

Sounds like what you have is a scraper plane with a toothed iron for working highly figured wood. the grooves in the iron mave it work like a series of small gouges so it will take the high spots off without tearing out the figured wood.

any chance of some pics of this plane?

If it were mine and the previous owner was a friend I`d sharpen it up and keep it just as it is and use it exactly as is. The only reason I would do anything to it is if it didn`t work at all for me or if it really needed to be tuned up in order to be useful to me.

I have some tools from friends and family that are no longer with us. Some are the next best thing to trashed but the folks I knew who owned them used them that way. Every time I use one these old tools I can feel that connection to the previous owner and imagine that wherever they are now they are smiling when they see me doing the same things in the same way with the same tools that they used.

Why would I want to erase all that just to shine something up?

Re: Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

#4

Re: Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Does it look like the planes in the linky below? I'm way not an expert, not even a beginner, on wooden planes; but it sounds like a toothing plane.

The pictures seem to show the bevel being at the back - this would be consistent with the practice for cabinet scrapers, of which this is a variant tool, if it's what I think it is, and understanding that my knowledge is reading-based, rather than experience-based.

Welcome to the quiet side, Colonel. You should come visit more often.


Does it look like these?

Re: Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

#5

Re: Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

TomD

http://www.ecemmerich.com/metallhobel.html

See the toothing plane

Re: Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

#6

Re: Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

TomD

"Inspection showed a very small amount of glue had been used to secure the support to the plane. Probably hide glue. Kurt was a cabinet/coffin maker before the war. Any reason not to use Titebond to permanently and continaully register the support to the plane body?"

If it is a totally clean wood to wood surface with full contact Titebond original is good. If it is crudded up with other stuff I would get it out, and if the gap is large, use a credible epoxy

" What is the proper position of the iron?"

Bevel down with an angle of about 80 degrees.

"I noticed the throat opening at the sole isn't square with the plane, and there seems a lot of room between the blade and the surrounding sole slot. Does this make a real difference? With wedge installed, the iron seems rock solid. I could "square" the opening but risk misaligning the sole opening and wedge/iron support. The tool looks like it was "born" that way, and it must have worked okay for decades. I could fashion an auxiliary sole and glue it to the plane bottom. Any comments?"

If the bed isn't also angled, and if the sole is square to the body, if it was commercially or otherwise expertly made, then the opening is as it should be. Sounds unusual though. Best idea is to sharpen the blade, and get it in the right way and see how it works. If a plane works that is way more important than how it should be. When trying to get stuff to work, fix the stuff that has to be right first, rather than worry about stuff that may or not look right. (I know you are trying to determine which is which). A large mouth up to 1/4" can be fine on this kind of plane. And the way you tell whether it is fine is by doing the basics and then seeing if it will do what you want.

"Lastly, what finish should I use on the cleaned up and sanded body? Poly okay, or BLO?"

If it looks like the ECE type planes, then they are varnished. BLO is a definite classic for at least our planes. I prefer to use a drying oil with better properties like a watco. But it will all work if it is what you want.

I would not add a sole unless forced to. Soles are largely unnecessary unless the plane is actually worn away. Adding soles to new planes is largely a waste of time since most users will not wear out a pine sole. Soles set up a dissimilar woods thing which is rarely positive. One can use a sole as part of a strategy to encapsulate a plane, but while that is a good enough idea, the simplest one piece planes from boards work really well also.

Re: Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

#7

Yes, Similar

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Morning Bill,

Kurt's has a tote sticking up out of it, shaped like a horn from a rhino. Also, the plane's body is more oblong, and the teeth serrations are much more shallow.

George

Re: Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

#8

Re: Yes, Similar

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That tote shape, on the front, is fairly common on continental European, particularly German, planes. On at least some of them, it's got a distinct handedness, shaped to fit the left hand (for right-handed users). Holding such a plane left-handed is not very comfortable. It must have been nice for left-handed mechanics who ordered proper left-handed planes (ECE, at least, sold/may still sell them in either hand) - none of their colleagues would want to borrow their planes.

Re: Need Advice-Woodie Scraping Plane

#9

Roy Underhill video

CJ in MPLS

The toothing plane is shown in use in this video:

http://www.pbs.org/woodwrightsshop/video/2800/2810.html