New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

So... what's everyone working on these days?

Posts

Re: So... what's everyone working on these days?

#26

Re: Building my new guitar shop

TomD

I have a small guitar shop on my second floor. However, I recently moved into it so it is half guitar and half leather. Guitars are kinda my money thing, not a business but a pay for itself part of the woodworking thing. But the new rules on natural species have sent me back to the drawing board looking for something less risky. Making guitars was starting to be like owning guns, up here, except the problems are at the border, which is worse.

Re: So... what's everyone working on these days?

#27

Re: Building my new guitar shop

TomD

Classical guitars do not normally have the edges bound. Though maybe I am missing the latest trend. I also have the nippers, if you are not binding the edge, you can also use black epoxy, and just hide the nipped back ends. I like having as much retention in the wire as possible.

Classicals sometimes have cutaways. If you play "classically" I think the elevated fingerboard is a better choice, since the arm position will not really allow one to use a cutout, but it does profit from the elevated access. Think violin, the hand reaches high even though there isn't a cutout for it. Just a thought. Most of the people who buy classical guitars aren't really that rigid in how they use them, and cutouts are what the big manufacturers sell.

Re: So... what's everyone working on these days?

#28

Re: Building my new guitar shop

Paul M.

I hear you Tom on both the money and multiple species act fronts. There's no way that I will make much money making guitars. And who knows if there will be any viable wood sources to make guitars that customers might want to own. Nobody is lining up to buy an oak guitar. This is a compulsion that I simply must do and I am indeed going into this with my eyes open as to the hazards of entering into this business. Some of my favorite jokes on the subject:

Q: What is the difference between a Luthier and a 16" pizza?

A: The 16" pizza can feed a family of four.

Q: What do you call a Luthier without a wife/husband?

A: Homeless.

Re: So... what's everyone working on these days?

#29

Re: Building my new guitar shop

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Has anyone ever made an oak guitar?

Re: So... what's everyone working on these days?

#30

Re: Building my new guitar shop

TomD

Not intending to be discouraging. Most of the horror I have is related to the US border, which does not affect the activities of US based luthiers unless they directly import odd materials. And anyway, I just allow myself to be easily deflected. I really don't like dealing with rules. I simply prefer at a personal level to be involved in free realms. But there are lots of successful luthiers, including at least two I know who started more recently than me, in my area here. Both of these guys are selling into the US, but there is a sufficient local market if one was really smart about it. Rules me out :)

Part of the reason I can't stop bringing up the endangered species thing is that while it has bitten into the guitar business, it actually has application for tools in the hand tool area also. Infills, Asian tools, there is even some decoration in tools or furniture of species like "pearl". If something like the Lac bug got listed, can you imagine... :) But some of the duty to declare these products probably still exists. The gaze just isn't on tools yet, as far as I know.

Re: So... what's everyone working on these days?

#31

Re: Building my new guitar shop

TomD

http://elderly.com/images/new_instruments/10N/ARTS2_body-back.jpg

White oak is cool, and I have seen red oak guitars also. Then there are other interesting woods, burls, swamps, lives, and euros. Lots of oak to play with.

Economically speaking the great guitar pricing item works like this, speaking of acoustics, but not of the violin or archtop guitar type. Lets say your basic maple guitar was 1000 from a big name volume company. Then their basic rosewood guitar might be 1500. Price of a maple backs and sides 60-200, price of indian rosewood backs and sides, 40, in volume. I am not taking custom woods here, just nice stuff. These are also when I bought my stock 15 years ago. So while every wood known to man has been tried, particularly when the green guitar fad started a while back, if you want to make money...

Of course if you are not selling it is also pretty much the great guitar OOH AHH thing also. That said in customs, manic grain is also very attractive, and the numbers level out where that is concerned.

Re: So... what's everyone working on these days?

#32

Re: Fretboard binding

GolfSteve in Calgary

Thanks Paul. Makes sense.

Add in another $50 for fret nippers.....Building a guitar is going to be much more expensive that just buying a really nice one....

:(

Re: So... what's everyone working on these days?

#33

Re: Building my new guitar shop

Paul M.

Hi Tom,

The really sad part is that the laws as currently written only apply to wood in it's raw form. You can have some nice old Brazillian Rosewood from 20 years ago, but if you *turn it into an instrument* it is now declared as a new *product* and hence restrictions of sale apply.

I'm new to this trade, so the grandfather clauses do not apply to me. But I'm making sure to keep every reciept regarding instrument materials, and I do not already own any wood that is banned at this time. I will stay away from Brazillian Rosewood, anything from Madagascar, and MOP inlays. I want to avoid products that will put my instruments automatically under suspicion. The problem is that the net is widening over time, and I will eventually get bit as they classify everything other than Oak as an endangered species. :(

I just saw that Cocobolo from Panama was added to the banned list. I wonder how I can prove that Cocobolo is or is not from Panama? Most of it is from Mexico. But suspicion is cast ever wider.

About 10 years ago, I bought a share of 100 trees in a Costa Rica tree farm. I thought this would be a form of Karma to help plant more wood that I will consume in my lifetime. At this rate, when the trees are ready for harvesting in another 15 years, there will be no market for them because they probably will be added to the banned woods list. Truly sad.

Re: So... what's everyone working on these days?

#34

Re: Building my new guitar shop

TomD

It is the arbitrary nature of it that worries me. One's responsibility to prove origin is very tight. Having receipts doesn't mean they apply to the wood you are tagging them to. But on the reverse, an agent can lay a charge just because he thinks a wood might be the banned stuff, and the need to prove otherwise may end up with a plea deal, just to get out from under it. I emphasize that the guitar biz has not come to a crashing halt as a result of this, and guys are carrying on, so my extreme views while true if one wants to guarantee a quiet life, are not the norm.

What is also irritating is that someone wrapping BIC-like lighters, in China, in veneer is going to be essentially impossible to track, while regular locals like us are easy to tag. That is the whole point, to make the pain for consumers, and manufacturers over here so painful that we won't want to risk it. Or that seems to be the point. So at one level there is probably a view that there is a way to work within the rules, but another way to look at it is that the point is to make it impossible to work within the rules. Not sure which is right. Anyway, at least it probably helps a little at the forest level.