New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

Posts

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Yes, folks, it's time again to register your opinions on yet another topic of importance to woodworkers. Six times a year, we post these "Ides" surveys and publish the results in our "News & Views" column in Woodworker West magazine.

I know this doesn't have much to do with hand tools, but I'm sure that most of you own or use tablesaws as well. This month's topic is a timely one. As most of you know, there is a major deliberation taking place at the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) regarding mandating the use of flesh-sensing technology on tablesaws sold in the US. The issue is now coming to a head, as the deadline for public comment is December 12, 2011. The full story can be found in the Federal Register.

We've had numerous discussions on this matter over the years, the most recent being this one back in October. Whether or not you participated in that discussion, I look forward to hearing your thoughts. Do you think that the government should mandate flesh-sensing technology on tablesaws? Would such a ruling be an unwelcome intrusion on woodworkers' freedom of choice, or would it be a justifiable regulation in the public interest, similar in scope and effect to mandatory seat belts and air bags in new vehicles in this country? Does the fact that Saw Stop owns the only patents on this technology as applied to tablesaws enter into the equation? What other pros and cons enter the equation?

If you'd like to register a formal comment to the CPSC, go to http://www.regulations.gov/#!submitComment;D=CPSC-2011-0074-0001 .

Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host


Comment to the CPSC about Tablesaw Regulations

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#2

Stephen Shepherd

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Stephen Shepherd

Ellis,

I can't believe you posted this on the Hand Tool Forum.

I stop sawing when the hand saw comes in contact with flesh. Works every time and very fast.

Stephen

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#3

Thanks for the Heads Up

Steve Elliott

As a hand tool user who also uses power tools I'm glad to have been made aware of a chance to comment on the proposed regulation.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#4

Logical

roninkokomo

If you accept the premise that the government has any business in monitoring the safety features of commonly sold products. It is a no-brainer. It is particularly compelling from a workplace safety perspective when those working for others need to use table saws.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#5

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

Jerry Gibbs

Manufacturer's product liability insurance may require the technology anyway. Insurance regs are often more powerful than statutes. It is useful to remember that in the original lawsuit, the health insurance provider of the injured user, not the user, brought the suit. I think this is an increasing trend, given the questionaires I have to fill out for my insurance company when I visit the Dr.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER *** *LINK*

#6

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF NOVEMBER ***

TomD

I'm against making the SS feature mandatory. Government is not made up of woodworkers, and they are unlikely to consult with an unbiased segment in developing regulations. At most they should mandate disclosure, and leave the determination of safety features up to individuals.

Sticking your fingers in the saw blade is about as sensible as being run over by your own car. The real risk factors for US table saw use are the poor guards, poor splinters, and the fact that while the domestic market has moved away from making everything out of panel products, the standard saw continues to be designed for that purpose, and too deep to safely access. This latter problem is worsened by the addition of bulky fence systems to saws not designed to carry them. Kludgy US saws are the bigger problem.

Another US/amateur thing, is to use tablesaws far more broadly that safe practices allow. The saw for everything crowd pushes the saw into things it may not be designed to do. Since I have an uncounted number of saws in my shop, I never have to use a saw for something it is not safely able to handle. I feel the saw represents zero risk to me. Perhaps people who want to push their saws should consider something like SS, but that should be a choice, not some generalization.

The US is all about the quick technology fix. This product area is developing like bike helmets back in the 70s, where one manufacturer lobbied for mandatory adoption of bike helmets, even though the helmets adopted were woefully inadequate. I noticed that there are now some TS users who think that TSs are completely unsafe unless used with an SS, as though there was ever any reason to get one's hands in the blade in the first place. This also parallels the bike example, where generations of users now grow up thinking that riding a bike at jogging speeds is suicidal without a helmet.

The woodworking industry not bought and paid for by SS should consider the helmet example. While you will never get any agreement on this subject, I think it is true that helmets: A) led to more accidents in many jurisdictions, and; B) led to many people shying away from cycling, in large percentages. The explanation behind these paradoxical effects is that people wearing helmets and drivers near them, both feel more confident in their safety, leading to other accidents. Also, while helmets are certainly capable of reducing the effects of accidents, and making cycling safer, many participants took the need to wear them as evidence that cycling was an unreasonably dangerous activity. There are parallels in woodworking.

I personal follow a more euro approach to my TS use, and feel that is a better model than the US mousetrap one. Hand injuries can be devastating at a number of levels, and I do not take that risk lightly. But I just think the table saw budget should be divided up among solutions for better saws, and safety gear, other than SS. I know I don't need one, and I wonder whether those who use a power feed in a factory setting need them. etc...