New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Speak to me of mechanical pencils

Posts

Speak to me of mechanical pencils

#1

Speak to me of mechanical pencils

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

At an estate sale this last weekend, I bought a box of what appear to be mechanical pencil leads, in a range of hardnesses (3H to 9H in the top layer, who knows what underneath).

In some past discussions - I remember them mainly on Badger Pond - some members argued pretty strongly for mechanical pencils, which is what motivated me to risk $1 on the box of probably more than 100 leads.

They measure 2mm. Are there particular brands of mechanical pencil that I should be looking at? Lee Valley says the Fixpencil (apparently the original mechanical pencil) is the best. A quick online survey shows them at four or more times the price of Staedtler (sp?); are they four times better?

And, what range of hardnesses is likely to work best on wood marking?

Re: Speak to me of mechanical pencils

#2

Re: Speak to me of lead holders

James Watriss

I think of .5mm (or .3, or .7) as a mechanical pencil... Click, click, click... 2mm is a lead holder. (My own semantics)

3H to 9H is really hard lead, for leaving really light lines. I think for wood purposes that's a bit too hard. I like no 2/ HB lead, as it's soft enough to leave a dark line, but isn't really smudgy. You can always experiment, but I think the harder leads won't leave a dark enough line to be clearly seen. Maybe I'm wrong, and the hardness will hold a point well enough to run it through a knife line.

I like Staedtler fine. There are other brands, too, but for just making a line, I really have a hard time understanding how 'better' is really quantified for a humble lead holder. Even if it was an old, brass barreled Rotring 600 series that was unearthed in some abandoned engineering lab in Russia, it's still nothing more than a fancy handle.

Me, I've been using $3 Pentel .5mm mechanical click pencils... Though I do have a couple of Rotring .7mm pencils, too.

The Rotrings are nice, and they feel solid, etc. But it's just a pencil.

Re: Speak to me of mechanical pencils

#3

Those are drafting leads...

John in NM

I probably have a dozen lead holders around if you need one. I used to do a lot of drafting, but not much any more. They get sharpened with a little pointer thingy, basically a cylinder that holds three or four blades to scrape the sides of the lead at a sharp angle. Has to be in the lead holder to work sharpen really. You can just use sandpaper too.

All the H's are really too hard for woodworking use, they'll dent the wood and not leave much of a mark. HB or B would be my hardest choice, much softer than that and it won't hold a point any time at all.

Re: Speak to me of mechanical pencils

#4

oops...

John in NM

Meant to reply to Bill's post :D Man, I hate working nights!

Re: Speak to me of mechanical pencils

#5

I used them exclusively

Bill Tindall

I use a 0,5 mm Pental P205 drafting pencil with a soft lead for all my pencil marking, but I use gel pen for dark woods. The gel ink reflects light and stands out in bright contrast on walnut. The Pentel costs $6 and last an indefinite life until someone takes it or it migrates to some other part of the house . Nothing larger would be useful for precision marking. Larger lead diameters would be useful for carpentry I suppose. I can't see the harder leads being useful except for making light marks on paper. I never used a 6H even with drafting the old fashion way.

Re: Speak to me of mechanical pencils

#7

Re: Speak to me of mechanical pencils

Bob Lang

You should be able to find a suitable leadholder and sharpener at another garage sale. Although they were once the standard, and twirling the point in the sharpener is kind of fun, they were cheerfully and gratefully abandoned when the .5mm mechanical pencils came along. Asking "what's the best leadholder?" is a lot like asking "what's the best buggy whip?"

The mechanical pencils sold for drafting are nice, and if you want to make a really fine layout line, 2H, 3H, or 4H work well. Trouble is, if you're over fifty you probably won't be able to see the 3H or 4H lines. For most uses, a good old #2 lead is fine enough.

I like the .5mm Bic throwaways for in the shop. I'm too much of a pencil loser to keep track of the nicer ones.

Bob Lang

Re: Speak to me of mechanical pencils

#8

agree w John


Re: Speak to me of mechanical pencils

#9

Re: Believe it or not, I wrote about this ...

TomD

So Derek, where is the review of the new Lee Valley pencil sharpener. I always thought they should make one, with a substantial blade that a wood worker could get excited about sharpening, though I was thinking rotary.

I use .9 pencils a fair bit. I don't agree they need to be thinner in order to work accurately. It is like a sight one a gun or the face of a target, large ones are often more accurate. The line is just a marking, you still have to take dead aim, or pick a spot. Sometimes I will quickly lay a line in, notice it landed to the side of where I wanted it, and just make the cut. Marking a line is never as accurate as marking a line and picking a spot.

That said, I sometimes like to use a regular pencil, sharpened and slightly rounded, then make a flat on it on sand paper so the it marks a very fine line, does not wear too quickly, and does not dent too badly.

Re: Speak to me of mechanical pencils

#10

Re: Believe it or not, I wrote about this ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

So Derek, where is the review of the new Lee Valley pencil sharpener.

Hi Tom

Well LV sent me one (it attaches to a brace, which was then turned furiously by my wife) ....


However it did not work well. All my pencils did not point.

Bad LV.

End of review.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Speak to me of mechanical pencils

#12

Re: Speak to me of mechanical pencils *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

I have a bunch of drafting pencil laying around the shop but grab the one from Rockler for any real use. It is large enough to hold and comes with a handy little sharpener to slip in you pocket.


Rockler Woodworking Pencil

Re: Speak to me of mechanical pencils

#13

Re: Believe it or not, I wrote about this ...

TomD

Anything for family fun !

What about this one:

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=68746&cat=51&ap=1