New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

flat bench for hand planning

Posts

flat bench for hand planning

#1

flat bench for hand planning

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA---

My first project ever as a woodworker was my work bench. I knew very little about woodworking then ,so it was amazing that it really turned out to be a wonderful bench. (I recall that I followed the steps from a Woodcraft(?) set of plans.) It is made up from end grain hard maple. I can't claim, however, that it's perfectly flat. I mean it looks and feels flat, but it just isn't perfectly flat. I would imagine that a nice piece of MDF is flatter.

My question is this: I took a weekend class on wooden plane making once, and I remember that the instructor ( his name may have been Fink) emphasized having a really flat bench for proper hand planning. How important is it? And if it is critical, do I have to flatten my bench ( a big job for me, I would think) , or could I simply clamp a really flat object of some kind under whatever I'm planning? (I realize that , if I did, I would also have to devise a way to hold the work piece.)

Re: flat bench for hand planning

#2

Re: flat bench for hand planning

TomD

It is a good thing but not in all cases is it required. Some wood is so stiff it is like it's own bench. Some processes, like thicknessing can in certain case be irrelevant. There are a lot of planed parts that are held in a vise or fixture.

Mostly it has to do with taking small cuts . If you wanted to take a 4 tens finish shaving, then it is possible to flex a lot of boards one might encounter into hollows that would allow the board to curve enough away from the plane that it would not take a shaving or take one more at the ends or other contact points. THe theory would indicate that a mere few thou would be possibly ruinous, but the fact is that it does not seem to be. But that is the calculation. The same thing when using the geometry of the projected blade to lock in dimensions of the piece being cut. A classic case there would be edge jointing where the deeper sections are all but totally rigid. Then there are non-critical processes. Etc... So it is only a hindrance in a few important cases.

I think it is important when laying out a bench to allow for it's straightening, and to place it on a level surface, even if pads need to be poured. This is the routine practice with machine tools, and woodworking is actually taken to similar tolerances. I got into a bind with a bench I built a decade ago. When it came to finishing it, the 5 gallon tin of finish had rusted, and gave the bench a very appealing, unintended stain. But it has hindered me from planing the top, since I know it will be hard to match. :)

Re: flat bench for hand planning

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: flat bench for hand planning

Moses Yoder

When possible, a nice flat bench is a real advantage in hand tool work, because you can lay a board on it and tell right away whether the board is flat or not. Also as Tom says, if you are planing like a 1/2" board and your bench is not flat the board can bend to the bench. You can use shims to prevent this. I think in your case, end grain maple, if the top comes off easy I would take it to a shop with a wide belt sander and get it flattened and call it good enough. In Christopher Schwarz's "Workbench Book" all the tops are made of southern yellow pine, a wood that would be easily handplaned flat occasionally as it moves.

Re: flat bench for hand planning

#4

Re: flat bench for hand planning

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA---

Thanks for your replies; but what about putting something truly flat under the work piece in those cases where it could make a difference?

Re: flat bench for hand planning

#5

Planing Board

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Yes, sometimes a planing board is used to provide a flat surface for planing thin stuff. A planing board should be maybe a full inch thick and have a shallow stop across one end. In the 1970's I used a planing board to plane 1/4 inch stuff because I was working on a bench that did not belong to me.

Re: flat bench for hand planning

#6

Re: flat bench for hand planning

Paul M.

I was planing some 5 foot long pieces of Mahogany for a face frame around a set of bookshelves this last week. I don't have any reliable 5' long straight edges, so I was using the bench I made 10 years ago as the surface reference.

This is some really nasty Mahogany with lots of internal stresses. Remove 1/16 inch along one side, and the other bows by up to 1/4 inch. But the color matched what I was building and I really wanted to use this.

I was fighting this bendy wood trying to get it straight and then realized that one of the gaps between the workpiece and the bench seem consistent with the bench more than with the workpiece. I could flip top to bottom and have the same gap, or I could swap it endwise and also see this gap. I took a straight edge to my bench and saw about 1/32 gap for about 6 inches in it's length. A few minutes workout with my jointer plane and I now have a good reference point to measure the straightness of my workpieces.

For someone who hates performing lots of measurements like me, it's great to have a known and reliable reference point like a flat bench. I don't think that effort put into leveling the worksurface will ever be regretted.

Re: flat bench for hand planning

#7

Re: flat bench for hand planning

roninkokomo

Agree. I believe a flat bench to be very important to a hand tool woodworker

Re: flat bench for hand planning

#8

Don't believe the hype. Planing trays are fine.

James Watriss

Benches are not sacred altars, no matter what anyone tells you.

End grain maple? Really?

Anyway, benches get used. I've been known to screw things down to mine, spill things on it, and use it like any other tool.

There's nothing wrong with using a slab of MDF on top if you need a really flat surface. Guys I know do it regularly, they glue on strips on the bottom front edge, and top rear of a 2' x 4' piece from the Despot, and use it like a bench hook. One guy wrote his name in big block letters on the top strip... FLANAGAN.

So, folks started referring to them as flanagans(tm).

Do what you need to, to get the results you want. Don't waste more time than necessary on your tools; focus on the work.

Re: flat bench for hand planning

#9

Amen to that philosophy

Bill Tindall

"Do what you need to, to get the results you want. Don't waste more time than necessary on your tools; focus on the work."

But for many it's about the tools and not the result.

Re: flat bench for hand planning

#10

Re: Don't believe the hype. Planing trays are fine

eliot d

You're right in questioning the end grain thing; but I'm having trouble describing it correctly. The top of the bench was made by gluing up hard maple boards with the flat sides perpendicular to the top surface. So it's not end grain. But it's not the flat sides facing upwards the way you would make a dinning room table.Do you see what I mean?

Re: flat bench for hand planning

#11

that would be edge grain.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

same way that my much less than noble nondescript pine bench is made - the face of the 2 X 4's are glued together, making a bench that's 3.5" thick. It's a tool, nothing more. Being of a lesser wood, I have absolutely no prohibition about what gets done on it: I've rebuilt motorcycle engines, dropped spinning tailed routers on it, screwed stuff to it. It's also helped build a lot of furniture and cabinets.

Re: flat bench for hand planning

#12

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: that would be edge grain.

Jack Guzman from Maine

My bench is also made from edge grain maple. I built it from LV plans before I ever did any hand tool work. I never got the grain oriented correctly so when I try to plane it I get tearout. I only tried this once. One day about 5 years ago I was showing my stepson and his two young children around my shop. My seven year old grandson picked up a chisel and took a chunk out of the neatly chamfered edge of my benchtop. I was looking elsewhere at the time. I was more concerned about his tender flesh than my poor bench at the time. I should have been more watchful of kids around sharp tools.His father apologized but I told him that I would treasure it as a signature. A few years later,his sister,my granddaughter built a class project on that bench with my supervision of course.

Anyhow,since that day I stopped worrying about the prettinesss of my bench. I agree,if it was perfectly flat it would be an asset,but it isn't. So I don't worry about it. I use my bench for everything but painting and power tool use. Occasionally I have to scrape off glue spots but otherwise it's a bench and it looks like it's well used.

If you can get your bench flat go for it,but if not, it's not that important. At least,that's my opinion.----Jack

Re: flat bench for hand planning

#13

All in perspective

Bob Hackett

It`s been my experience that if you live in an area like I do (coast of Maine) you`ll have to get used to the idea of wood movement and methods to compensate for it. Your dead flat bench in winter will most likely not be dead flat come summer. After you work with your bench for a decade or so you come to an understanding,just like you do with any other tool.

That being said,I know a few folks who spend an incredible amount of time finding ways to work around a recurring problem and that could have been minimized if they would just invest a little more time initially and address the root cause of the recurring problem.

There is a lot to be said for having a dead flat surface as a reference plane. That`s why machinists use surface plates,they guarantee accuracy and eliminate the chance of multiplying an error till it becomes a problem.

I`ve never seen a wood reference plate,cast iron and granite work well though they make for an awful heavy bench. ;)