smoother- newbie question
Jerry Gibbs
Why are smoothers relatively small? I would thing a smoother should be as large as practical to even the surface and prevent hollows. Thanks. Jerry
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
smoother- newbie question
Jerry Gibbs
Why are smoothers relatively small? I would thing a smoother should be as large as practical to even the surface and prevent hollows. Thanks. Jerry
Re: smoother- newbie question
Pam Niedermayer
Because the smoother needs to ride the waves to smooth. They're not supposed to flatten.
Pam
Re: smoother- newbie question
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Why are smoothers relatively small? I would thing a smoother should be as large as practical to even the surface and prevent hollows.
Hi Jerry
A smoother is not a dimensioning plane, that is, it must not affect the final dimensions of the piece. It is only to prepare for a finish, to smooth the dimensioned piece at the end. This is why smoothers are typically set up for very fine shavings.
A long plane, such as a jointer, stretches across the piece and levels it equally. To do this it must find a common denomenator, which translates to all areas being lowered to the level where all hollows are removed. This changes the dimensions of that piece.
A smoother is short to bridge as little as possible, to ride the hills and valleys and thereby remove minimal surface area. Traditional wooden coffin smoothers were in the 6 1/2" - 7 1/2" range for length. One can go even shorter than this. Cabinet/card scrapers are the shortest planes of all!
Of course, if you are largely working with machinery, and all your finishing is on "flat" pieces, then a longer plane may be used - and preferred by some, such as David Charlesworth's "Super Smoother", a Stanley #5 1/2. Others prefer a one-size-fits-all approach. Alan Peters was often said to use his #7 jointer for all work (which I think is an urban myth). To do this, anyway, you would need to plan your work accordingly.
Regards from Perth
Derek
see "stack of drawers" post below
Bill Tindall
There is no practical need for a table top, or drawer front for that matter, to be level to 0.002"(more of less) the thickness of a typical shaving. And that is how level the surface must be across the length and width of the plane to be able to pick up a shaving.
Re: smoother- newbie question
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I don't subscribe to the "hills and valleys" theory. Smoothing planes are used to clean surfaces from dirt and scuffs prior finishing or gluing up. For this we could well use a jointer plane, but the jointer is heavy and tiring. Unless you are after workout, the less it is used the better. Smoothing planes are also used for trimming and fitting. For these tasks the jointer would work, but would be awkward. Here we want some thing that we can use with quick deft movement. We also use short planes for very small stuff (like little desk drawers) where a large jointer would also be awkward.
A skilled worker can try or joint the stuff with a smoothing plane. However as this takes somewhat more testing with the straight edge, a longer plane is worth the extra weight to save time.
For rough work, a wooden jack, 15 to 18 inches long is ideal. A wooden plane is lighter and less tiring. Because the plane is taking a thick shaving, some length is helpful here. The two hands are farther apart giving a greater moment (more leverage) to help control a plane which is used more forcefully. A smoother can get away with a short length because it takes a light cut which is not hard to control. A short plane works for roughing, but is tiring.
Re: smoother- newbie question
TomD
"I don't subscribe to the "hills and valleys" theory."
+1
That does happen, but it isn't the main reason soles are long and short. It is to control cutting geometry, which is pretty much constant, while the hills and valleys may vary in phase to the plane, and are largely irrelevant.
For instance on the jointer: New school, the wood has been through the machines already, and just has ripple to be cleaned. Old school, there are other planes that get rid of the hills and valleys before the jointer takes it's turn. But the longer sole locks in the flatness potential, and it's relationship to shaving thickness, and that is pretty much a constant.
With smoothers, getting and keeping a shaving is easier with a short sole. There is a hills valleys issue here, and it may even be warp in the wood, crumbs, or an untrue bench. Rather minute irregularities can take the blade out of the cut, and the problem steepens as the blade dulls. A "dull" but still sufficient blade is like having a lesser blade projection. Less friction of a short plane also helps. And the plane just doesn't need to be longer. A joiner might have dozens, or even a hundred or more planes, of those only a handfull need to be over a foot long. There are lots of reason, as already listed.