New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

top and bottom of a chisel

Posts

top and bottom of a chisel

#1

top and bottom of a chisel

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA---

My first post here: I used a Tormac the other day to sharpen the bevel of an old chisel, but it wouldn't make a nice symmetric bevel. When I looked closer, I could see that the top and bottom faces of the chisel were not parallel; so that was the problem. What's a good way to get them parallel without using fancy equipment?

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

#2

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I take it you mean that, when you hold the chisel so that the sharp edge is pointing at you, the back (opposite the bevel) and the "front" (on the same face as the bevel) aren't parallel

Without fancy equipment, I think the only method is VERY careful grinding, or gluing sandpaper to a flat surface (MDF, piece of marble/granite floor tile or kitchen counter offcut) and equally carefully abrading it. You'd want to have a way to compare each edge so you know when you're approaching parallel. Machinist's outside calipers (see image below) are probably the simplest/most available.

The accurate use of calipers is something of an art. You have to learn how to feel when the calipers are rubbing consistently on the two measurements being compared. Nothing suffices but practice in this area.


img

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

#3

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

Pam Niedermayer

I don't know that there's anything sacrosanct about the tops and bottoms of chisels being parallel, so far as I know, they often taper toward the handle. However, at any given point, say the edge, they should be parallel. Can you photograph the chisel so we can see what you mean?

Pam

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

#4

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I can't see where it matters. The bottom and top 'flats' could be at extreme angles, but it wouldn't matter to the cutting edge.

So long as the cutting edge is straight and sharp, and the bottom flat is indeed flat - at least for an inch or so adjacent the cutting edge - then the rest of the geometry shouldn't matter.

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

#5

It could, when grinding the bevel *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Many, probably most, chisels taper in thickness from the edge to the handle; some, such as Lie-Nielsen's homage to the Stanley 750, take it to an extreme, but many chisels taper more mildly. This should not have any impact on sharpening (the Tormek uses an angle-setting jig that registers off the back of the chisel, so if you've got a chisel with a dramatic taper, a little adjustment of the toolrest/sharpening jig will take care of it).

IF, however, the body of the chisel is thinner from one edge of the length of the chisel to the other, any sharpening or grinding device that registers from the beveled side of the chisel will have trouble. I think that may be what Eliot's describing (a drawing or picture would help).

Eliot, one alternative you've got is to forgo the speed of power grinding, and use coarse honing devices (diamond stones, coarse sandpaper on a flat surface, etc.). If you're not comfortable with hand-held sharpening, select a jig, like the Eclipse jig (or knockoffs of it - Lee Valley sells one, linky below), that registers from the chisel edge, not the faces.

Another alternative, of course, is to throw the chisel in the back of the most convenient drawer and try another chisel; saying bad words while you do the throwing is optional.


The "Eclipse" jig at Lee Valley

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

#6

I think what the problem is...

Bob Hackett

That when grinding the chisel he`s referencing off the top and since the top is not parallel to the back the grind doesn`t come out square to the back.

If this is so then I`d either grind the top to fix the problem or make a tapered shim to tape to the top of the chisel to make the face and back true to each other.

I think I`d go with a shim of some sort first to see if the steel in the chisel was of decent quality and will hold up to hard use. The chances are good that if the quality control was bad enough to let this sort of thing slip by then the chisel may not be worth investing all the time it would take to fix it.

You could always bring it back to the place you bought it from,explain the problem and either get a replacement with better geometry or your money back to put toward a good quality chisel that will grind square without all the rework.

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

#7

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Elliot

The Tormek blade holder essentially caters for blades with parallel becks/fronts. However it is possible to tweek the settings quite easily.

The blade holder uses a screw at each end. If a parallel blade is tightened more on one side that the other, the bevel end is forced out-of-parallel by the now skewed forces on the blade. This can be used in reverse, that is, with a blade that is out-of-parallel, use more-or-less downforce via these screws to balance out the blade until it is grinding evenly. Grind a second or two, check, adjust, continue ..

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

#8

Re: It could, when grinding the bevel

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA---

Thanks for the thoughtful replies. I should have explained better just what's out of parallel: if you take a cross section perpendicular to the long centerline. this section should have top and bottom lines that are parallel. I understand that the chisel may taper along its length, which, as has correctly been mentioned, would not affect sharpening. But, as several of the replies pointed out, if it's not parallel it the way I have(looking at it with the sharp edge pointed at you), then when held in the Tormac, the chisel will be twisted a little in the jig; and the grind near one edge of the chisel will be more than at the other edge; so the grind profile won't be symmetric.

I think the suggestion I will try first is to play with the two Tormac jig tightening screws to see if I can't get the grind to look right. Then, perhaps, the shim idea. (But both these methods, even if they worked, would still leave the non-parallel problem to plague me later.) I'm intrigued by seeing if I can grind it parallel using the machine caliber; learning to use it well would be an advance in my shop skills.

Thanks for taking my question seriously.

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

#9

You can use an Eclipse jig with Tormek.

Chuck Nickerson

Tom Lie-Nielsen glosses through it in his book on sharpening.

I was working on my prototype this weekend. I'll finish it Tuesday.

This uses the Eclipse's side clamping to hold the chisel face parallel to the stone surface,

giving a straight cutting edge.

As a bonus, I've discovered it also will work with the Wolverine's jig for grinder wheel truing.

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

#10

Re: You can use an Eclipse jig with Tormek.

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryAo1Kz+awUUYH8ShA---

Chuck, I happen to own one, but I don't know how to use it with a Tormek. Would you be good enough to clue me in?

Re: top and bottom of a chisel

#11

Re: You can use an Eclipse jig with Tormek.

Chuck Nickerson

You drill a coulpe holes in the frame to hold pins. The pins then rest on the Tormek bar.

As soon as mine is done (Tuesday eve?) I'll post a photo.

If you have access to Tom Lie-Nielsen's book "Complete Illustrated Guide to Sharpening", there

are photos in the chisel section.