Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Donkey's ear construction question

Posts

Donkey's ear construction question

#1

Donkey's ear construction question

Bill Tindall

I have a stressful miter to execute and I can't afford to screw it up. Normally I nibble away with the table saw but too much risk this time of accidently over nibbling. Besides it is time to bite the bullet and own a jig.

I intend to make the jig according to the sketch in the picture because it seemed to be the easiest to make and use. However, given that I have neither ever made or used the donkey ear I need to ask if this is a good choice. I am looking for the easiest to make and use variant of the jig.

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#2

Stephen Shepherd

This one has fewer parts. 


img

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#3

Looks like you're trying...

John in NM

To make a silk purse out of a donkey's ear :D :D :D

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#4

Question

Bill Tindall

Is it difficult keeping the piece to be shot from slipping? Gravity is not helping in this arrangement.

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#5

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Answer

Stephen Shepherd

I just grip the work to the appliance with one hand and use the other to operate the plane. Gravity keeps the plane in place and a hand grip keeps the stuff being shot in place, advancing it as the work is done. Seems to work fine, if you can do two things at one time.

I suppose you could clamp the stuff down and just work off all that is projecting, never tried it as the regular way seems to work just fine and the stop prevents split out on the back side.

Stephen

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#6

thanks

Bill Tindall

nothing beats an answer backed by experience

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#7

Darrell in Oakville

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

Darrell in Oakville

Are you working with room-sized pieces or cabinet sized pieces?

For very long pieces you want the work horizontal and the plane tilted. Or at least that's my experience...

Darrelll

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#8

Donkey's ear alternatives

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Michael Connor (in Australia) offers a simpler version of that one ..


Link: http://www.michealconnorwoodwork.com.au/workbenches/workbenches/workbenches.html

My version is ..



Details here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/BuildingaMitredPencilBoxwithaShootingBoard.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#9

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

Old Baleine

Bill,

I build very large picture frames for a university art museum. Many of my frames are 6 to 8, even 10 feet or more on a side. When I plane the miter on a 6-foot length of moulding, you can be sure it needs to be horizontal, not sticking up in the air. I use a jig very similar to your illustration; I copped the basic design from one of Robert Wearing's books. My plane runs in a v-groove cut in an UHMW plate where your groove is.

To hold the moulding in place, I use a pair of tapered wedges to "clamp" the moulding down against the base of jig. The wedges fit between your top guide and the base. My top guide is 8/4 maple, lag-screwed or through-bolted to the base (I forget which). The top guide needs to be thick in order to withstand the clamping stress the wedges exert.

The jig works perfectly. I have tuned miters for loooong mouldings on this jig, trimming hundredths, if not thousandths from the miter to get that perfect fit.

My best advice is: built it beefy.

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#10

thanks for ideas, tell us more.....

Bill Tindall

I would find it interesting to learn more about your framing. Where does the molded/carved framing material come from? You must have some good tricks for clamping such a frame. A picture of one of these huge frames would be interesting to see. Pictures of any part of the process and jigs would be interesting.

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#11

Re: thanks for ideas, tell us more.....

Old Baleine

Bill,

I'm in Bahston right now, thousands of miles from home. When I get back, I'll see if I can pull some photos together for you. In a nutshell, let me just say that the clamps I most often use for assembling large frames are mods built around the little Veritas 4-way speed clamp. For large frames and small, it is far and away the easiest and most straightforward of any of the clamping jigs I have used, including band or strap clamps or corner clamps pulled together from the center. Depending on the depth of the moulding profile, I'll stack up to three sets of Veritas clamps. I have threaded rods in various lengths up to six feet, and join them together with hex coupling nuts to get the length I need. When necessary, I'll shape a spacer from a thick piece of Ethafoam to conform to and cushion the outside edge of the moulding where the corner of the clamp fits. It doesn't take fiber-crushing pressure to pull even a big frame together; you can get plenty of tension on the rods with those quick-release nuts once they engage the threads. I have a very large (8x12) assembly table to work on. After checking for fit, the miters are glued up and dry overnight. The next day I spline the corners together, using a pretty crude corner jig attached to a regular old biscuit joiner to cut the mortises for the splines. Once again, keep the frame in the clamps for stability while the glued splines cure. Handle carefully.

The important construction detail with most large frames is this: the frame is decorative, not structural. An "inner frame" or stretcher (strainer, actually) is what holds the frame and framed painting or panel together and to the wall. Some of our assembled frame/plex/mounting panel packages weigh 300-350 pounds avoirdupois. The inner frame supports almost all of the load and holds it to the wall. I usually hang these larger frame assemblies off of french cleats, which greatly simplifies getting the thing level and plumb on the wall, and gives a little "back and forth" to get it centered to the curator's satisfaction.

The donkey's ear is just not practical for trimming long mouldings. The Wearing-designed jig performs brilliantly with a razor-sharp iron and a LN 62, and the tapered wedges lock the moulding to the base of the appliance tighter, yet with more flexibility than anything else I have found. But that top bar needs to be beefy.

"Someday", I hope to rebuild my miter block with the top bar locked into the sides with a sliding dovetail rather than metal fasteners...

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#12

facinating

Bill Tindall

Next time I am in a museum I'll be looking closely at the frames.

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#13

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Which Robert Wearing book are you referring to?

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#14

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

Old Baleine

It's either this one:

http://www.amazon.com/Making-Woodwork-Devices-Robert-Wearing/dp/1861081294/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1319938064&sr=1-1

or this one:

http://www.amazon.com/Woodworkers-Essential-Shop-Original-Devices/dp/0806985844/ref=sr_1_9?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1319938161&sr=1-9

I think that he describes it in both, and both are worth having, especially if you can get them without paying an arm and a leg. As I recall, the construction details seemed to me as though they were a little sketchy for speakers of American English, but once I got into to it, it made sense and came together. I'll post a photo in a few days, once I get home, and it will explain itself.

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#15

no silk purse here... my donkey's ear jig

Bill Tindall

Most important in constructing the jig was to not make my shooting board look bad by comparison, Picture 1.

Someone was fretting earlier about what to make one out of. This one works adequately and it was made from stuff in the kindling bin.


I decided this design was easiest to make and use. I couldn't figure out how to make the other kind and get everything properly oriented. The base is a scrap of MDF. All that was involved was cutting a 45 on two pieces of 8/4 scrap from the kindling bin, and a 45 on a stick to bridge across the top. A 1/4 x 1/4 groove was cut across the MDF. The edge of the plane rides in this groove. A square fixed in this groove was used to locate the 8/4 pieces orthogonal to the groove. I tacked these pieces down with a dab of glue (yellow) and when it was dry I ran two screws in from the back side to secure these pieces. With a square I located the top piece orthogonal to the 8/4 pieces and parallel to the groove. A scarp of something thin is used to elevate the pieces to be shot to get them high enough on the plane blade to be above the plane frame.

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#16

Looks great to me

John in NM

This is the single thing that I like to use MDF for :D

Aren't those thin scraps of stuff handy? I have a bunch of 1/16 poplar veneer and 1/8 plywood laying around from a laminating job years ago, and it seems like I'm always grabbing one for something like this.

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#17

What plane do you use for this?


Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#18

#5 works fine

Bill Tindall

I just built it and have used it on 3 miters so I don't have lots of experience. I was anxious to get on with skirt installation on the chest of drawers so I grabbed what was at hand and it worked ok. I don't see why any plane would not work. The height of the "8/4" pieces need to be right for the plane width. The plane edge needs to ride the piece bridging across these pieces. 1 5/8 high is fine for a 2 3/8" iron, less for a 2".

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#19

Re: #5 works fine

Pam Niedermayer

I wondered what type plane would ride steady in the groove. I've thought recently about making a plane with a 45° sole instead of a jig, even obtained a fairly narrow blade with a 45° edge for it. That way it could sit flat on its side and be used on an unmodified shooting board.

My purpose is to plane the mitered part of hidden dovetails.

Pam

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#20

Re: #5 works fine

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Let us know how that works, if you get around to it, Pam. I've made a lot of half-blind dovetails, but no full-blind yet, because those miters stop me dead in my tracks.

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#21

mitered dovetails

Bill Tindall

These were popular with a famous cabinet maker from Knoxville, Emmet something or another. His work was featured in one of the first Fine Wood working issues and I think this joint was described there. His students like them. Anyway, he developed some easy way to make them. I have seen it demonstrated but don't recall the details other than it looked like something I could do which means it looked easy. One of his students gave a class on it recently but I didn't attend. I'll ask around at club meeting and see if anyone attended the class and took notes or pictures.

Re: Donkey's ear construction question

#23

Re: mitered dovetails

Pam Niedermayer

Would love to hear anything and everything about this, Bill, thanks. It was really difficult to find a suitable blade for a suitable price, so I suspect that it will have to be custom made to accommodate larger pieces.

Pam