New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

antique hand planes

Posts

antique hand planes

#1

antique hand planes

darrin hill

borrowed my neighbors plane the other day to play with, and i loved it..

This weekend i was going to a very large antique mart (its about 20 miles long... covers two towns)... im into antiques and have seen tons of planes and molding planes and other tools... some of the people have a fleamarket / garage sale type booth where u can find anything, like a harley made entirely of wicker, or i saw a hot air balloon gondola last time i went.. some sell just antique tools..

i was going to keep an eye out for planes, and was wondering what to look for in a antique plane that i can use in the shop.. I've seen stanley metal ones to very long wood boxy looking planes...

whats the difference, and what kind of planes are usefull in a generic wood shop?

some are around $20 up to several hundred for the really old ones.. but then antique shops are always expensive...

Re: antique hand planes

#2

A contrary view

Bill Tindall

Step 1. Decide why you want to own a plane. If the reason is to make stuff then proceed to step 2.

Step 2 If you want to learn to use a plane then buy one that is known to be in usable conditions. In your case that would be to either buy a new quality plane or a plane bought from a woodworker that can guarantee the plane works. The likelihood of you buying a wood plane from an antique dealer that you will be able to effectively learn to use is near zero.

Step 3 Learn to sharpen. Success with a plane is predicated on being able to sharpen it properly. It will take a long time to learn to sharpen on your own. Seek out someone experienced for help.

Re: antique hand planes

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: antique hand planes *LINK*

Moses Yoder

Books have been written to answer your question. You can look at the Patrick Meister's Blood & Gore page, linked below, to learn more about stanley bench planes. The best way to start out is to buy a Stanley #4 plane and replace the iron with a Hock iron, buy something to sharpen it with, ask specific questions about it here, and start learning. The large wooden planes you see are also good to buy if you heat your house with wood, they are normally very dry and oily and burn quite well. If you really learn makers marks, sometimes you can find a rare one worth keeping but chances are about the same as winning the lottery. If you stick with a regular Stanely bench plane to start with, you'll do good. Later on you will find yourself lusting after the better built mousetrap, the Stanley Bedrock bench planes, but they are kind of expensive to mess around with if you don't know what you're doing.

P.S. I was typing this while Bill posted his answer, so it's not that I disagree with what he said, he makes good points to, I just have a different viewpoint.


Meister's Blood & Gore

Re: antique hand planes

#4

Re: antique hand planes

Patrick Gibbons

Most people's answers are going to break down into two camps. Either learn to tune up old planes or learn to use a plane first with good-quality brand new ones. Both sides have their merits. A smooth plane and a jack are universal in use and both can be justified by any woodworker as a necessity.

Re: antique hand planes

#5

One other thing

Patrick Gibbons

Most woodworkers today tend to prefer metal planes but good quality wooden planes are available if you know how to pick them. Historically wooden planes were actually preferred by craftsmen in the past. I include transitionals in that category.

Re: antique hand planes

#6

Wooden Planes- build one

Bill Tindall

All the wooden planes I have ever seen in my area were apparently used by carpenters. They have huge mouths and most are in rough shape.

If one wanted to go the wooden plane route then I would suggest buying David Finck's plane making book and build one. They are very easy to make. The book will also tell how to sharpen, adjust and use the tool.

Re: antique hand planes

#7

Good advice Bill


Re: antique hand planes

#8

Moses Yoder

Re: Wooden Planes- build one

Moses Yoder

One of the things David uses extensively in his book to build planes is other planes, especially a block plane. The wooden planes I have built I used a smoother and a jointer plane plus a block plane to build them. My first plane was a block plane, but I think it is easiest to learn to plane with a bench plane like the #4, get a good iron and make it really sharp, then you understand how a plane is supposed to work.

Re: antique hand planes

#9

agree mostly

roninkokomo

There is usefulness in messing with old planes, in that you can learn a lot. As Bill hints, that can take time.

Pat Leach sells some excellent wooden planes that will work wonderfully well.

Re: antique hand planes

#10

OLD STREET TOOLS

roninkokomo

These guys (formerly Clark and Williams) build wonderful wooden planes,

So does Tod Herrli.....

I much prefer a very good wooden plane to a metal one.

Ron

Re: antique hand planes

#11

Re: antique hand planes

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Darrin

As tempting as it must be to buy a plane or two in such surroundings, particularly when it is likely for many to be on sale, DON'T DO IT!

Attempting to educate you in 5 minutes as to what plane to purchase is like attempting to explain the rudiments of antique furniture, and expecting that this is enough to send you off with confidence. There are just so many different makes of planes, sizes of planes, parts of planes and their condition to evaluate. It is an impossible, ludicrous venture for you at this stage.

Far better that you purchase a vintage plane from a reputable vendor. Pay a little more but be assured that you get something that will work.

Or take your neighbour with you.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: antique hand planes

#12

Re: antique hand planes

Tony - Memphis

It wasn't THAT long ago that I was in the same boat. I bought a #4 Stanley from a reputable internet dealer. I paid a little more than flea market price, but I got something that was worth having. There are tons of good articles out there on fixing up a plane. I guess it really depends on what you want to do with a plane too. Phil Lowe uses a #4 for almost everything (even end grain). Recently, there has been a lot printed about low angle bevel up planes. I got one and love it (a new LieNielsen - thanls Santa!). Actually, I lied. My forst plane was a Lie Nielsen low angle block. I love that plane. It is great for edge trimming, corner breaking, end grain, etc. (and it isn't too expensive). A good reference is Chris Schwarz' book on hand planes. It is basically a collection of articles.

Yeah, sharpening is important. So you'll need to learn that and get some supplies.

But I guess to answer your question...I would suggest you do some research real quick on what to look for in a used plane (even particular to specific planes like a #4 or a shoulder plane - they each have unique typical failure or abuse modes). That way, you'll at least know what to look for. I have bought a couple of planes that turned out to be dudsl It happens. They make nice decorations in the shop.

There are some real good DVD's out there onplaning as well. Oh, I paid $75 for a nice #4 15 years ago. I haven't kept up with pricing. You might try Mr. Leach too. He is a good guy and is great to deal with.

Good luck in your hunt. I find it very rewarding to buy old and refurbish.

Tony

Re: antique hand planes

#13

Moses Yoder

Re: antique hand planes

Moses Yoder

If you buy a Stanley #4 plane for $20 today, you can still probably get your $20 back for it plus interest in 10 years. Plus, you will have learned a bunch from using it. I don't see how a person can go wrong doing it. Your philosophy is kind of like telling a man his first car should be a Lamborghini in order for him to understand what a good car is really like. That fine if you poop thousand dollar bills, but for the average person, paying for an education is the norm. My way of paying you would spend $20 for a plane, $15 for David Charlsworths book witht he article on plane tuning, and about 6 hours of spare time tuning a plane. Then you would have a good plane, you would know it, and you would be able to use it. If you spend $100 on a plane from a dealer, you still have to replace the iron, learn how to tune it, and learn how to use it. So it looks to me like you are out $80 so that you can think you started with a good plane, instead of using your brain and looking at a plane before you buy it.

Re: antique hand planes

#14

Re: antique hand planes

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Your philosophy is kind of like telling a man his first car should be a Lamborghini in order for him to understand what a good car is really like.

Hi Moses

Not at all. Me thinks you read into things a mite too much.

I thought of suggesting a #4. However there are #4s and #4s. Could the OP tell the difference between a plane with a mouth that is over-large, or has a warped sole, or a bust/cracked/reglued handle. There were over a hundred years of Stanleys made, and the various Types not only commanded different $$ but also were better or worse.

Using your car analogy, I would not send my 18 year old son off to purchase a car on his own. He would be vulnerable to salestalk, not know what to look for, and could come back with anything ... the mind boggles. Either I go with him, or he goes with someone I trust, or he goes to someone I trust.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: antique hand planes

#15

The problem

Bill Tindall

Suppose someone with little knowledge of planes buys a dud. Then they struggle with trying to get good results with it thinking it is their lack of experience that is the problem. They conclude planing is just too hard. Then they give up a an buy a Performax drum sander. My first plane was a piece of junk and it set me back 20 years in gaining the benefits of a working hand plane.

I am reminded of my first sheep purchase. I asked to buy some ewe lambs. The experienced shepherd asked what I knew about lambing. "Nothing", I replied. He replied, "then buy some older ewes that do". It was good advice for more than this situation.

Re: antique hand planes

#16

Allow me to paraphrase

Bob Hackett

"If you don`t know much about hand planes then go find some WWers who do".

I`m gonna fall back on one of my often repeated answers and suggest yet again that one of the best investments of time and money for people just getting into unknown areas of WWing is to seek out and join a local club,guild or WWing organization.

It`ll be the best value for money you`ll ever get and you`ll be able to find most of the answers you need to many of your questions there as well as the opportunity to experience some hands on help from folks who have been navigating for years in the same waters you are attempting to find charts for.

Don`t know of any WWers in your area? Ask at the local hardwood lumber supplier,saw mill or tool dealer. They`ll know who`s active in your area and how to contact them.

Re: antique hand planes

#17

Moses Yoder

Re: antique hand planes

Moses Yoder

Your car analogy kind of amuses me because when I went to buy my first car my dad didn't even know it. We had to give all our money to our parents until we were 21 years old, and at 21 I was a man. I was perfectly capable of using my head and buying a car, and if not, I learned a lesson which we called idiot tax.

Re: antique hand planes

#18

Danger:  Slippery Slope!

Jerry Nicholson

I have had a Dunlap plane for about 50 years and I have my dad's Craftsman which is over 60 years old. I have found these to be useful only on soft white pine (and to loan out). A few years back, I bought a rusty Stanley #8 in an antique store in Eureka Springs and actually found it to be useful, after a bunch of fiddling. So I bought a #4, another #4, a #3, a #4 1/2, a #5, a #5 1/4, a #5 1/2, a #6, a #7, ......... Now I have at least 35 Stanley and Sargent planes and probably that many wooden and transitional planes. And several Veritas blades and Hock chip breakers. So what are my "go to" planes? A Veritas bevel up smoother and a Veritas bevel up jack! I would have saved a bunch of money by buying the Veritas planes in the first place but all those Stanley's sure look neat on the workshop wall! So be careful of that first step - the rest of the path can be steep and slippery!

Jerry

BTW - I do grab one of those Stanleys on occasion.

Re: antique hand planes

#20

Re: antique hand planes

TomD

"borrowed my neighbors plane the other day to play with, and i loved it..

"This weekend i was going to a very large antique mart (its about 20 miles long... covers two towns)... im into antiques and have seen tons of planes and molding planes and other tools... some of the people have a fleamarket / garage sale type booth where u can find anything, like a harley made entirely of wicker, or i saw a hot air balloon gondola last time i went.. some sell just antique tools.."

So part of the question is how much do you want to mess with antique tools? You can entirely set up a shop with them, and this was popular years ago. Michael Dunbar wrote extensively on the subject and did a rather good book; "Restoring, Tuning & Using Classic Woodworking Tools". His interest is in the classic wooden plane phase.

"i was going to keep an eye out for planes, and was wondering what to look for in a antique plane that i can use in the shop.. I've seen stanley metal ones to very long wood boxy looking planes..."

I would personally not restore a metal plane. Unless you are a skilled metal worker. Of course you may find old tools that are in good condition. Or you can buy them from people who partially do the restoration. Modern metal planes are better anyway.

"whats the difference, and what kind of planes are usefull in a generic wood shop?"

This is too big of a question. And there isn't one correct answer anyway.

"some are around $20 up to several hundred for the really old ones.. but then antique shops are always expensive..."

Typically antique tools were not that expensive other than the few that have a lot of collecting going on around them. My best advice is to see if there is a tool collectors group in your area. You don't really have to join, but you might find that some of these people sell stuff and a few of those may actually get user tools. If you can find that person, then they will direct you to stuff that can actually be used. There is usually cheap user stuff around. A jack plane might be a good first plane. It helps in wood prep, is useful, and reasonably easy to operate.

Re: antique hand planes

#21

Re: Wooden Planes- build one

TomD

"All the wooden planes I have ever seen in my area were apparently used by carpenters. They have huge mouths and most are in rough shape."

I find that also, though I do at times wonder if they didn't know what they are doing. I think they would be surprised to see endless bench planes designed to take finishing cuts.

"If one wanted to go the wooden plane route then I would suggest buying David Finck's plane making book and build one. They are very easy to make. The book will also tell how to sharpen, adjust and use the tool."

I would actually not do that. It pains me to say so but the Krenov plane verges on a dead end. It was just one guy's idea of a good plane, and it isn't that good. I got in this game in the 70s from reading his books, and loved the look of his planes, but I have to admit it was a blind alley for the most part. I do have some I still use, I am making a few more to use-up useful blades, but for the most part they just don't clear shavings well enough. The video even shows the "experts" removing shavings by hand with every pass.

Re: antique hand planes

#22

I was taught the 4 1/2 was the go-to plane


Re: antique hand planes

#23

Late to the party (long)

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

After a disastrous early experience with a Craftsman plane bought new, I started buying used planes at yard sales almost 40 years ago, because that's what was available. I made some mistakes, but in this area garage sale prices are low enough that the tuition was more in time than in money.

I agree that, unless you live in a tool-rich area, it's easiest either to buy from a reputable dealer or to get one of the expensive new planes. But if you do live in an area with good garage sales, and/or you have very little money, you can get good at finding decent planes fairly quickly, I think.

In this, as in other things in life, there’s a time/money flow. If you have limited time but a little more money, buying high-end new or from a dealer makes sense. If you have very limited money, then to get going on hand tools, you need to apply time.

Generally, it's not a good idea to do your tool shopping in antique stores, if they're like the stores around here. Prices tend to be high, and the dealers usually sell on decorative value, not usability. Around here, at least, yard, garage, and estate sales are the better money value (at the cost of time, again).

My tips for bench planes (see picture below of bench planes):

1. At first, buy Stanley planes. There are other good makes – Millers Falls, Union, Sargent, for instance – but there are so many more Stanley planes around that it’s safest to start there. Once you know what to look for, you can even get good planes with the Craftsman, Wards Master (from Montgomery Wards – a Sears-like store, if you’re too young to recognize the name), or other “lesser” names. The comments below apply to Stanley planes.

2. Look for a plane with “Bailey” somewhere on the body. This was the almost-top-of-the-line Stanley plane. If you find one with kind of squared off sides and “Bedrock” on the lever cap at a good price, that’s even better; but they’re not common.

3. Look for a full oval tote (the handle at the back). That is, if you wrap your thumb and first finger around the tote, you'll be describing an oval, NOT a rectangle or a shape with flat sides.

4. Now look at the condition: light rust is no big deal; rust heavy enough to make flakes usually indicates a plane that will be a lot of work to clean up and that may never be right. Look for cracks and chips (especially around the mouth where the cutting iron [hereafter, “iron”] comes through), and set the plane down if you find them, although minor chipping with no cracks around the edges of the sole or sides isn’t a big deal. Other common problems include the horn on the tote being broken off (repairable, but work: move on to another tool), the iron being bent at the top because someone dropped it upside down, the lateral adjustment lever gone missing or hopelessly messed up, the tote or the knob at the front being cracked (use your judgment as to repairability on the tote or knob; they glue easily enough). I have occasionally, though rarely, seen the threads for the screw that retains the lever cap (the lever cap holds the cutting iron in place) being stripped out; this is a definite walk-away sign.

5. Finally, test out the adjustments for smoothness and range. Lubrication helps on these, but if they won’t move, you should probably move on to another plane, unless you can use this problem to talk the seller down to REALLY cheap.

People get into long discussions of plane types, and it’s true that planes in a certain range of years might be a smidge better; but, for a basic plane, as long as you stay in the range of planes made up to World War II, you’re probably OK.

Another point: sharpness is critical in hand tools. A marginal plane with a sharp iron is a much better tool than a top-of-the-line, $300 plane with a dull iron. Learn to sharpen, and recognize that it’s a little like learning a musical instrument: you’ll always be learning to sharpen, never really done, because your standards of what’s sharp will improve as your skills do.