Late to the party (long)
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
After a disastrous early experience with a Craftsman plane bought new, I started buying used planes at yard sales almost 40 years ago, because that's what was available. I made some mistakes, but in this area garage sale prices are low enough that the tuition was more in time than in money.
I agree that, unless you live in a tool-rich area, it's easiest either to buy from a reputable dealer or to get one of the expensive new planes. But if you do live in an area with good garage sales, and/or you have very little money, you can get good at finding decent planes fairly quickly, I think.
In this, as in other things in life, there’s a time/money flow. If you have limited time but a little more money, buying high-end new or from a dealer makes sense. If you have very limited money, then to get going on hand tools, you need to apply time.
Generally, it's not a good idea to do your tool shopping in antique stores, if they're like the stores around here. Prices tend to be high, and the dealers usually sell on decorative value, not usability. Around here, at least, yard, garage, and estate sales are the better money value (at the cost of time, again).
My tips for bench planes (see picture below of bench planes):
1. At first, buy Stanley planes. There are other good makes – Millers Falls, Union, Sargent, for instance – but there are so many more Stanley planes around that it’s safest to start there. Once you know what to look for, you can even get good planes with the Craftsman, Wards Master (from Montgomery Wards – a Sears-like store, if you’re too young to recognize the name), or other “lesser” names. The comments below apply to Stanley planes.
2. Look for a plane with “Bailey” somewhere on the body. This was the almost-top-of-the-line Stanley plane. If you find one with kind of squared off sides and “Bedrock” on the lever cap at a good price, that’s even better; but they’re not common.
3. Look for a full oval tote (the handle at the back). That is, if you wrap your thumb and first finger around the tote, you'll be describing an oval, NOT a rectangle or a shape with flat sides.
4. Now look at the condition: light rust is no big deal; rust heavy enough to make flakes usually indicates a plane that will be a lot of work to clean up and that may never be right. Look for cracks and chips (especially around the mouth where the cutting iron [hereafter, “iron”] comes through), and set the plane down if you find them, although minor chipping with no cracks around the edges of the sole or sides isn’t a big deal. Other common problems include the horn on the tote being broken off (repairable, but work: move on to another tool), the iron being bent at the top because someone dropped it upside down, the lateral adjustment lever gone missing or hopelessly messed up, the tote or the knob at the front being cracked (use your judgment as to repairability on the tote or knob; they glue easily enough). I have occasionally, though rarely, seen the threads for the screw that retains the lever cap (the lever cap holds the cutting iron in place) being stripped out; this is a definite walk-away sign.
5. Finally, test out the adjustments for smoothness and range. Lubrication helps on these, but if they won’t move, you should probably move on to another plane, unless you can use this problem to talk the seller down to REALLY cheap.
People get into long discussions of plane types, and it’s true that planes in a certain range of years might be a smidge better; but, for a basic plane, as long as you stay in the range of planes made up to World War II, you’re probably OK.
Another point: sharpness is critical in hand tools. A marginal plane with a sharp iron is a much better tool than a top-of-the-line, $300 plane with a dull iron. Learn to sharpen, and recognize that it’s a little like learning a musical instrument: you’ll always be learning to sharpen, never really done, because your standards of what’s sharp will improve as your skills do.