New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

How long to build a drawer?

Posts

How long to build a drawer?

#1

How long to build a drawer?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

As I am building a total of 12 drawers, I have been conscious of the total amount of time it will take to complete the lot.

It is difficult to be accurate about the time expended on each drawer since the parts were prepared in three sessions (first resawing and thicknessing the boards, and then their dimensioning, and finally building the slips).

The first drawer, nevertheless, must have taken about 6 hours from dovetailing and to fitting. In spite of the accurate sawing and all dovetails going together off the saw, plus the use of the chisel knife trick, chopping the Jarrah waste was very time consuming.

Even though I was aware that my speed would increase, at 6 hours x 12 drawers it could still take several weeks.

The second drawer took 4 1/2 hours.

I read an article by Richard Jones in which he wrote:

A drawer like this takes a skilled craftsman between seven and eight hours to make and to shoot in precisely to the drawer opening. If multiples of similar drawers of this basic pattern are made the time element can be brought down to about 6-1/2 hours per drawer. Staining and polishing procedures take about another hour.

If hardware involves fitting a lock and escutcheon in additiion to fitting a simple proprietary pull, about another two hours has to be allowed. Fancy veneered fronts with inlays and stringing and other traditional features such as cockbeads add yet more time. The skills required to build all these traditional drawer patterns need to be well developed, and it can be seen that a very elaborate drawer may take nearly sixteen hours to make.

Link: http://curve.phpwebhosting.com/~luka/articles/drawers/rjones1.html

I felt a little better after this, but there is still some way to go.

What time frames do you experience?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#2

Answer....waaaay tooooo long

Bill Tindall

Alan Batty, worked at an English factory making drawers, had a quota of 5 drawers per day (traditional mahogany/oak drawers).

Personally, I am afraid to make an accounting of how long it takes me. It would be depressing.

Now days I focus more on reliability than speed. My goal is to crank out a bunch of furniture for daughters and grand daughters that will last. And sometimes a reliable way of doing something for me isn't the fastest. Dovetails are a good example. I don't do them often enough to be sure I won't screw up something. So I proceed cautiously.

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#3

This post makes me feel so much better.

McKay

I started to study and practice traditional woodworking around 2000. (before that I thought that if it did not have a cord you should not pick it up) I have never told anyone how long it takes me to do a drawer because I thought that I was the only one that took a really long time to do dove tails. I love this site.

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: How long to build a drawer?

Moses Yoder

If you order a drawer box from Fryburg Door and get it finished, then use Blum Tandem undermount slides, install an applied front, it takes about 15 minutes or less to install a drawer box. I think maybe when you spend 8 hours building and fitting a drawer, you might have different goals than just being efficient.

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#5

Re: How long to build a drawer? *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, not a short process. I was aghast the first couple I built; so I started building a different design, the main departure being a central wooden runner purchased from Rockler at first, home made now that I'm out of the original stock of 20. My times now are about 3 hours each, maybe less.

Also, I see that they're now $9 each, much too expensive for me

Pam


Rockler center mount drawer slides

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#6

Re: Answer....waaaay tooooo long

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"Alan Batty, worked at an English factory making drawers, had a quota of 5 drawers per day (traditional mahogany/oak drawers)."

Production workers, even working by hand, will always be faster than one-off or occasional workers.

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#7

2-3 hours

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Derek,

If I'm not looking at a gallery piece of work, about 2-3 hours or so. I might be making a canted set of drawer fronts in the next week or two. I'll time the easy one, the double-canted one'll take a while.

Most of the work's not in the dovetails, but in the fitting.

CHeers,

Andrew

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#9

Re: What does double-canted mean?

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Bill,

A canted drawer has the front not parallel to the back.

http://books.google.com.au/books?id=oIP4pSHSnS4C&pg=RA1-PA179&lpg=RA1-PA179&dq=%22canted+drawer%22&source=bl&ots=6wCLNgDNjK&sig=sxLGKJC-PvLndSoJ6svQ3tEEEjI&hl=en&ei=ad6ETrS9Bc-jiQeRzYmNDw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CBsQ6AEwAA

A double-canted drawer has the front and back not parallel, with the sides not parallel as well. (looks a bit like a wheelbarrow.

CHeers,

Andrew F

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#10

Metal in furniture

Bill Tindall

Nothing personal mind you but I find modern metal things offensive in a piece of furniture. There is a high end gallery associated with Grove Park Inn, Asheville, NC (leave your knees weak room rates). Most of the stuff in the gallery is hinged with those large clunky looking European adjustable hinges. Do these young cabinet makers not know how to hinge a door with butt hinges? And, it is not uncommon to see "kitchen cabinet" hardware on the drawers. And all this will be inside an otherwise nice cherry or walnut cabinet, often of stunning design. It just seems so out of place and disappointing on something costing thousands.

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#11

Andrew - your link didn't work for me

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Good, clear explanation; too bad the link wasn't cooperating (at least with me).

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#12

Link  *LINK*


Google books

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#13

Bob

Re: This post makes me feel so much better.

bob

In F. Klausz video on dovetailing a drawer, he said he allows about 30 min. a drawer, and I believe it.

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#14

Re: How long to build a drawer?

TomD

"you might have different goals than just being efficient."

Every job no matter how refined, still has an efficient andinefficient path. I always wanted to be efficient, even if the goal was art. Like if I painted the Mona Lisa, I wouldn't set out to walk backwards to the truck with it when taking it to the dealer.

Franz Klaus says he bills 20 minutes of shop time for a complete drawer, consisting of a thorugh dovetail box in pine, properly cut and fitted, and an apllied front. I once made a drawer like that for a kid's desk, and I know it took me a lot longer than that. So why the difference.

These days my shop is so multi use it has almost become a joke to think of doing anything with efficiency a condition that verges on the un-healthy.

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#15

Drawer panels

Todd Nebel

That's what always surprises me. The time it takes me to make solid drawer panels. I resaw and glue up, flatten and smooth, then spend uber time planing the bevel just right (not to tight, not to lose). Then drill, saw and recess a groove for a screw to attach the panel to the drawer back. Maybe I'm to picky but just that process takes me hours.

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#16

Re: How long to build a drawer?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Franz Klaus says he bills 20 minutes of shop time for a complete drawer, consisting of a thorugh dovetail box in pine, properly cut and fitted, and an apllied front. I once made a drawer like that for a kid's desk, and I know it took me a lot longer than that. So why the difference.

Hi Tom

Why the difference? With all respect to FK, I could argue that your drawers were better made ... if one uses his drawer making video as a benchmark. Those were not the type of drawers I associate with quality furniture. They were not rough, but they were just basic and functional - thick sides, tablesawn grooves for a plywood bottom and finished with a plywood facing with taped edges.

One of the reasons I started this thread was to seek a realistic estimation for the time to build a drawer. Of course there are drawers of differing degrees of complexity, which will require greater or lesser amounts of time. Estimating a realistic build time is just a reality check for those who feel intimidated ...

Perhaps others have estimates for both the various "styles" of drawers. I am sure there are recommendations from both vintage and modern eras.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#17

Moses Yoder

Re: 20 minutes to hand dovetail a drawer?

Moses Yoder

I am in charge of getting quotes to build our cabinetry from various manufacturers we have in our stable now. We shut down our manufacturing plant last fall, since the boss thought he could make more money by just having our competition build cabinets for us. One of the things that strikes me as odd is the variation in price from one manufacturer to the next. One single cabinet can vary in price by $400. These prices are from 4 different builders, all using basically the same techniques and joinery. When i look at this Frank Klausz statement, he bills 20 minutes shop time per drawer, instantly I have to wonder if that drawer is 4" tall or 8" tall. Wouldn't an 8" box take at least 50% more time than a 4" box? Also, does that time include installing stretchers for the drawer to ride on? Apparently not. So I kind of get what he is doing. If he charges 20 minutes at $200 per hour, that's $66.67. If the actual craftsman takes 1-1/2 hours to assemble the drawer at $20 per hour, that's $30 labor. Say $10 per hour for overhead for 1-1/2 hours, thats $15. So if you take $66.67 that was billed, and subtract $45 for labor and overhead, you have $21.67 profit for billing 20 minutes for a box that actually took 1-1/2 hours to install.

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#18

more comment than time estimate

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

Derek

I think there are all sorts of reasons why there are great differences in the time required to build a dovetailed drawer

If the drawers are all the same height, all the sides can be sawn as a stack and the waste removed with repetitive chiselling -- as demonstrated by FK

If the drawers have applied fronts, you're only cutting through DTs and close enough is good enough for the basic box as small errors will be hidden by the applied front.

Half blind DTs will always take considerably longer

Timber selection is also a factor -- if the box is made of soft poplar, chiselling is a breeze (again as demonstrated by FK), if they're of Jarrah then chiselling is time consuming

apart from the properties of the wood, the biggest variable is the drawer design and construction technique. Traditional drawers need to be individually dressed to exactly fit their openings -- the process of plane, uncramp, check, recramp, plane some more (in both width and length), check again, is time consuming as a very significant amount of time is spent clamping and unclamping the piece.

My observation is that you put too much effort into getting the pins just so for finess and spacing, and the inside corners of the sockets exactly square and perfect. My personal opinion is that places that are completely hidden within the finished article don't need to be perfect, only good enough to perform for a century or two. Chamfering 1mm from the inside edges of the pins will not compromise the integrity of the joint but will dramaticaly reduce the amount of fiddling needed to get an exactly square inside corner on the socket.

There's a place for very fine work -- say a jellewery box where the drawers are left extended or fully extracted while a selecton is made -- and a place for neat functionality where the pins are set out by eye, the cuts are all straight, but there is some variability in pin spacing and width.

Please note that in no way is this comment intended to imply that I'm a better or more skillful furniture builder than you, or that your design and construction asthetic are wrong. I'm more trying to draw you away from comparing your speed at drawer building with others who have completely different drivers for the work they do, work with different woods, and to a different standard of what is acceptable.

As always, I find you work and posts inspiring

regards from Sydney

Ian

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#19

I didn't understand a step

Bill Tindall

"Chamfering 1mm from the inside edges of the pins will not compromise the integrity"

You said this technique saves fitting time. I would like to understand it.

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#20

Can't say exactly...

Brad Chenoweth

but even I know it needs to be shorter than the depth of the carcase :D :D :D

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#21

I would like to say I never made that mistake

Bill Tindall

but then my nose would grow.........

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#22

Re: How long to build a drawer?

TomD

"Hi Tom

Why the difference?

Mainly practice was my implication. I think mine were a neat job, I just don't take much pleasure in that kind of woodwork, but it served it's purpose.

"With all respect to FK, I could argue that your drawers were better made ... if one uses his drawer making video as a benchmark. Those were not the type of drawers I associate with quality furniture."

Well high end anyway, I don't know that there was anything wrong with the quality.

" They were not rough, but they were just basic and functional - thick sides, tablesawn grooves for a plywood bottom and finished with a plywood facing with taped edges."

Right. But the thing is that the other stuff does not take any more time. I think it is too bad that that video didn't have a part two in which he demoed doing a harder piece. I have seen him cut dovetails in several video settings, and it was always softwood. But then it is obvious that he can cut them in hardwood also. In the 70s and early 80s there was a lot of studio furniture with pretentious dovetails, like tiger maple sides in ebony fronts with the contrast showing. I even saw some filler in a multi thousand piece once. I have to imagine that if it came to cutting that set, that FK would get it right, and not take that look doing it. It is actually hard to slow down once you have the chops.

So in your list, thin sides are faster. Most drawers just have a plowed groove in them, and the plywood is a little faster than a proper panel, but not much. Of course the panel takes time, but that is a separate issue. Most the art furniture I used to look at was actually about the same complexity. Half blinds are another mater. And I don't know how long that would take him.

In fact. I have done the FK thing in maple, and it worked out just the same, though the chopping is a little slower. So I wouldn't expect it to slow him down much.

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#23

Re: 20 minutes to hand dovetail a drawer?

TomD

That's interesting, Moses. The German apprenticeship system involves one year doing estimates, as I once heard it described. That is the part I am missing for sure. I never know what to charge people, so I prefer not to do stuff, or forget to ask for the money. :) I imagine given the speed FK got up to speed in this country, that he didn't have that problem.

That said, I think he is taking about 20 minute per drawer to do what is shown in the video, which is do the final milling on the stock; cut it to length; dovetail 4 corners; glue; fit it to the hole; cut out front, tape and apply hot veneer, and screw the front on. As a rough list. The drawer is a standard size, there is a large file drawer also, and maybe that one has a per inch boost, or something.

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#24

Firstly, an apology for being away for a few days

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

Bill

I hope the two attached diagrams showing the setion through a drawer side to drawer front dovetail will explain what I mean

the first shows a "perfect" socket where the waste has been chiseled out to create a perfect 90° inside corner. The edge of the pin would be chamfered a little to avoid bruising the pin and to ease assembly.


the second shows a socket where some of the waste has been left in the inside corner of the socket and the pin has a slightly larger chamfer to clear that waste. Depending on the timber, the second socket should require a lot less "fiddling" and be faster to cut without making a meaningful difference to the joint's strength.


I hope the above resolves what I meant

AND depending on the softness of the wood used for the drawer side compared to that used for the drawer front a "perfectly" matching joint between the pins and sockets could be achieved by slightly compressing the wood fibres in the drawer side as the drawer is assembled.

Someone I've read about or come across (I'm sorry but I don't recall who) said that a DT joint cut by a skilled craftsman shouldn't be tested until final assembly

regards from Sydney

Re: How long to build a drawer?

#25

Thanks got it.....

Bill Tindall

Timely too. I had a recalcitrant drawer side and indeed there was a previously undetected "crumb" on the inside edge that prevented complete seating of the side to the front. Your suggestion would have rendered this problem unimportant.