New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

dovetail pin size question

Posts

dovetail pin size question

#1

dovetail pin size question

Bill Tindall

Andrew stated in a post below:

"Traditionally, all pins are the same width at the thickest point, with the skinniest part of the lowest dovetail pin being a little wider than it's mates. Gives a stronger drawer back and visually is a lot less significant."

I have a lot of faith in the reliability of "tradition". Hence, I like to understand the traditions and benefit from them. I don't understand the sizing of this lowest pin. If all the pins have the same major width and this pin has a larger minor width, does the statement mean that the dovetail angle is different on this pin? Does anyone have a picture to illustrate?

Re: dovetail pin size question

#2

Duh!  I have the answer

Bill Tindall

I retired to the shop to lay out the last three drawers and the answer revealed itself immediately. These pins are only angled on one side so if the major dimension is the same as one angled on both sides the minor dimension must be larger.

Re: dovetail pin size question

#3

Re: dovetail pin size question

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Bill,

In my former day job, I was a rapid change agent where, often things weren't being done in accordance with best practice. Whilst I know that you don't have a lot of faith in tradition based upon your common lines of questioning, it is based upon 300 years of practical experience, so I find it's usually the correct option and approach things with an open mind.

I was referring to the drawer back when I said: "Traditionally, all pins are the same width at the thickest point, with the skinniest part of the lowest dovetail pin being a little wider than it's mates. Gives a stronger drawer back and visually is a lot less significant."

I don't understand the sizing of this lowest pin. If all the pins have the same major width and this pin has a larger minor width, does the statement mean that the dovetail angle is different on this pin?

No, see picture (Will have to repost separately - sorry)

Back to preparing for a five hour coaching session

Re: dovetail pin size question

#4

Image

Andrew F in Australia

See attached image.

Depth of the lapped dovetail tail sockets is 2/3 the thickness of the drawer front.

The pin slope is also historically significant, Bill.

Carcase dovetails are typically 1:6 slope, show dovetails are typically 1:8

I think even those that eyeball the slope, Frank Klausz (?sp) is one, are about this.

It's not a science, but a visible difference.

Cheers,

Andrew


img

Re: dovetail pin size question

#5

Links - layout techniques

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Bill,

Noticed you were having some trouble on dovetail layout.

Links below are the easiest way I've come across.

Cheers,

Andrew F

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3106/pro/search/pmd/sread/srchid/27555iTnbJQkW37HHgKD1317002286/spage/3/sanc/99400/sbid/3106/md/read/id/99313/sbj/from-handtool-chat-how-to-lay-out-a-dovetail/

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3109/pro/search/pmd/sread/srchid/27555iTnbJQkW37HHgKD1317002286/spage/2/sanc/135541/sbid/3109/md/read/id/135571/sbj/the-rest-of-the-rules/

Re: dovetail pin size question

#6

Re: dovetail pin size question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Andrew

The slimmer lowest dovetail is a result of maintaining the same outside width for all the dovetails. I decided to go with this since (a) it was easier to mark out, and (b) the extra strength of a wider dovetail is unnecessary here.

The slope is 1:7, the same as the half laps.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: dovetail pin size question

#7

rear end of a traditional drawer

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

Hi Bill

this is what you're refering too

(Andrew will recognise the project)