New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Question about chisels

Posts

Question about chisels

#1

Question about chisels

patrick gibbons

There has been a lot of talk about the necessity of chisels having thin sides on a beveled chisel. Is this really necessary on larger sizes that will never be used to chop out a dovetail? Seems to me that anything over 1/2" doesn't need the thin sides.

Re: Question about chisels

#2

Re: Question about chisels

TomD

It is to a large extent not necesarry on smaller ones either. If you draw it up, and take into account the kerf of the sam, plus the ability to can the chisel, it isn't always necesarry to have tapered, sides, or certainly heavily beveled sides. But it is an easy feature to add so why not. SO long as the chisels don't get wobbly. Als some folks may not do many dovetails, the Japanese chisels did not always come with much slope to the sides. It is one of those things where in the absence of the single feature, no other positives. Makes the chisel, less comfortable to hold, less stiff, less bearing, etc...

Re: Question about chisels

#3

Experience

Bill Tindall

When I made chisels I strongly beveled all of them right up to the 1 1/4" size. I have not had any occasion to regret doing so. I have in the same rack as these beveled chisels 2- square sided chisels. I have never had any occasion to need the square side and they are rarely reached for.

The bottom line for me is that the bevel has never been a disadvantage and occasionally it has been an advantage when reaching into a corner.

Re: Question about chisels

#4

Re: Question about chisels

Bob Lang

It all depends on what type of cut you want to make. When paring the corner between the cheek and shoulder on a tenon, or cutting into the corner of a mortise that teeny-tiny bevel tends to pull the chisel into the corner. That can add some ugliness and slow the process down. There was a time when firmer chisels were available as well as the currently trendy paring chisels. There's a good reason for both forms.

Bob Lang

Re: Question about chisels

#5

Re: Experience

TomD

I agree with that also. If you ask the question can one do without, or will it hurt to have bevels, you get different answers, no contradiction. For myself, I have massive sets of chisels, and yet maybe 3 of them get used regularly to make small dovetails, where space could be a problem. I have them by 1/16th, but the 1/4, 3/8, and 1/2 get most of the work. Really if all the rest had no bevels at all, I doubt I would care. Also on soft woods, I prefer piercing chisels, and they are so narrow that bevels are irrlevant.

The other question is how much bevel does one need if on wanted all the chisels to be dovetail ready, and one used narrow kerf Japanese saws. And the answer is something minimal like 86 degrees. So a lot of the bevel is ther for show. There is no one right answer for this, if all one's angles were very steep. But the angle is less than often assumed.

On mortising chisels I don't want much bevel.