New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Straight Razor Users in the HT?

Posts

Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#1

Straight Razor Users in the HT?

David Weaver

I have seen Warren mention (I think) previously that he shaves with a straight razor.

Does anyone else here use one as their regular razor? Not too long ago, I stopped using anything other than a straight razor - just a plain 6/8 razor that's about 100 years old, not one with disposable blades or anything.

If you do, too, what do you shave with and how do you finish your edge (loaded strops, stone only and bare strop, palm stropping)?

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#2

Re: Stropping- Part of Motivation for the Question

David Weaver

One of the reasons I bring this up is because I used to be one of the biggest discounters of stropping (especially for woodworking). Reason for that being that my finest stones really don't gain much or anything by anything other than a palm swipe, and in reality, probably nothing even from that.

But shaving every day with a straight razor has really given me the opportunity to understand stropping a lot better.

I still don't do it on woodworking tools if I stop with a fine stone, but the value of it on a razor edge is much more easy for me to understand, where the effects of the edge condition are instantly described (and sometimes displayed) on your face.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#3

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

Frank D. in Montreal

I only use a straight razor. My favourite one is a Filarmonica 7/8 (really heavy, with an ugly handle); I have no idea what the steel is, but it sure holds an edge better than any other stright razor I've tried, including several Dubl Ducks.

Now I strop with a piece of horse butt from LV. I used to load it with Flexcut compound, but Joel's posts convinced me not to, and I prefer the edge now. I find that simply wetting my whiskers with hot water a few minutes before shaving (and keeping them wet) makes the most difference in the shave.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#4

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

David Weaver

Wow...7/8 filarmonica! Nice. They bring big money from any of the standard places, I figured there was probably a reason why, but they are too high for me to find out on my own - uncommon-name german razors are what I've been able to get cheap.

For a while, I was stropping with compound once a week or so (bare leather after each shave) and then going back to the hone every several compound cycles for a touchup, but I have been using an old japanese barber hone (not one of the big monster super expensive ones, just a little old antique one - hand size) for about a month or a little more now, and I just give the razor ten very light swipes across it with water after each shave, and then bare leather or hand strop before the next shave, and the consistency of the edge and shave has been a lot better.

Agree 100% about warm hydration. Definitely a difference in noise level with or without on an extra hollow razor.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#5

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

TomD

I use a piece of leather with Green compound. I use the replaceable blade ones a lot also, because they are cheaper to loose and I'm not sharpening while traveling. I once took a blade I had been using for a month on vacation for 2 months, and forgot to take spare blades, it was still working OK at the end of two months. But some of the disposables only last a day.

I have one of my dad's razors, and one I bought. I got into it a long time ago, so I don't really know what they are, there wasn't any hype at the time. I also have used those Japanese razors Lee Valley sold. They will rip you if you try to shave the same way, seem to need a very low angle. I have bid on a few Japanese razors on ebay, but so far not won.

I'm like Jimmy Hendrix, I can do the back of my neck and use either hand. I see some videos were guys are taking tens minutes. It isn't a ritual for my I use them for practical reasons, and a little because they are hand tools.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#6

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

Greg B�tit

I have a nice lilly white I got from TFWW and an Ern razor. I suppose I should try stropping, too. I only do it when I feel adventurous, because I'm taking blood thinners. It's not as bad as riding a motorcycle.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#7

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I use a clean linen strop and a clean horse hide strop. Neither has ever been dressed. I hone on an Arkansas stone occasionally, if I feel the razor is not cutting well. I use a clean leather strop for woodworking tools.

I think that if a fellow does not have a fine stone, then strop paste can be helpful to smooth the edge. Otherwise it is unnecessary.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#8

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

David Weaver

Warren, same stone that you use for woodworking? I sold off my black ark stone, but figure if I had left the surface alone, it would've made a nice razor stone the way it cuts.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#9

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

David Weaver

I think a couple of years ago when I first started, I nicked my face a little bit when I was placing the razor (not really bleeders, just little nicks that showed up as irritated spots for a day or two), but I've only ever had one ding that was more than a very temporary weeper.

If you have a styptic, the thinners shouldn't be a problem.

Washita might make a rough ride on the razor, though, don't know because I've never used an oilstone on the razor.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#10

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

David Weaver

hmm...i missed what they were selling. Maybe it was feathers? I've never used disposables other than the current cartridge types, or 20 years ago, those yellow bics, but from what I've seen and heard of the feather blades, they have torn up a lot of people who used regular pressure and angle.

I'm with you on the speed. I only do one pass and "buff" a little bit with the razor in the spots that tend to not get close on the first pass. Only takes a couple of minutes that way.

I have seen videos of guys on youtube who call 10 minutes a "hurried" shave. :b

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#11

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

Schtoo

I want to, but regrettably I never seem to have the time to do it properly, and rushing it, they don't call them 'cut throat razors' for nuttin'!

When I made a concerted effort, I found that my face was much happier since I have pretty tough whiskers, but also very susceptible to ingrown hairs. When using the straight, the ingrown hairs were virtually eliminated and I had less skin trouble.

For stropping, I used my jeans. That's it. A swipe up, a swipe down and that was enough.

I don't know why stropping does what it does on a razor, but I have suspicions and hope to find out soon. I'm thinking that because the bevel is so acute you naturally get a feather edge and the strop doesn't remove it, but rather straightens it out and that's what you shave with. Stropping simply keeps that feathered edge in good shape without needing to abrade it at all. There's probably a measure of work hardening in there as well just for good measure.

But I don't know. I do know what gets my razor sharp and at the very least, that's enough. ;)

Stu.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#12

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Yes, I use the same stone as for woodworking. The black stone remains awfully flat. I have seen Belgian stones used by barbers that are quite hollow end-to-end, but because they are only used for razors, they are probably flat from side to side.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#13

Re: stropping

David Weaver

Stu - watch this video of honing and then stropping by Alex Gilmore. Not because you'll find much interest in the honing, but because of the quality of the pictures of the wire edge breaking off and revealing a smooth edge.

I know a lot of us get interested in seeing the scratches on the face of the bevel, but what's going on at the edge when alex gets to stropping is really enlightening. I'm not sure I've ever had the magnification and clarity at the same time to be able to see this level of detail. The edge loses its straightness, but what it gains in smoothness is really something.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rf6v5DXjsmA

I gave the sigma power 13k a whirl on a razor last week. It works pretty well, nicer to use than the shapton because it's a bit more muddy/soft and maybe a bit finer and the edge isn't as harsh as a result. Shapton and chosera are a bit too aggressive on my face without using the greenie stuff to calm the edge down, and I kind of like to go straight off the stone and use plain leather/palm - and avoid all of the hocus pocus stuff.

My hand held finisher is an antique one that alex sold me. I asked him if he had anything cheap, effective and ugly (ugly so that it could be effective and cheap), and he sold me kind of an ugly little asagi stone that is incredibly fine, one that came out of a barber shop over there. Unlike new asagis, it is not scratchy at all with a slurry, but it's hard enough to not yield grit unless you abrade the surface, and with plain water it is the finest cutting stone I have ever seen - finer than green stuff maybe, but a different and more pleasant feel to the edge. The antique stones are really nice, I think there's a lot to the claim that the mines are a bit played out and the older stones from farther up the mountain are more pleasant to use.

I have / had extreme trouble with skin sensitivity on my face also. A harsh stone will turn my face bright red for two days, and I've always had to shave with the grain or slightly across. I envy the people who can just rip straight against the grain with a razor and have no razorburn or consequences (like my dad, who uses a very harsh against the grain stroke to start, and with a lot of pressure and repeated strokes over the same area).

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#14

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

David Weaver

I don't worry about the flatness, either - not like on the woodworking stones where I pay attention either by lapping or by working the high spots on a stone when sharpening. Seen several hard barber hones that were hollow, just like you mention. It's pretty easy to tell if they're working, the razor tells the story on your face with one stroke on each side of the bevel.

My WW stones are a bit too harsh for a razor (hard ceramics), they tend to pull a deep narrow scratch in edges, which is OK for woodworking at their level of fineness, but it's hard on the face off a bare strop - and I don't use the powders/pastes either. I figure they are for guys who don't have good stones - and they change the shape of the edge over time in a way i don't like.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#15

Worst of both worlds

CJ in MPLS

I'd like to try a straight razor, but frankly, they scare the shit out of me. But, and this is the odd part, I don't have a problem using a safety razor. I have been messing about turning handles for badger brushes as well (still haven't replaced the second poplar test handle).

Having no one to actually show me how to do this (I'm going to exclude youtube videos on account of the fact that they explain how to do a lot of things one should never do), how would you reccommend getting started?

CJ

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#16

Re: Worst of both worlds

David Weaver

I have seen people describe enough of their trials with DEs to never try them. But I'm sure it's like anything else, you can get better with it.

I wouldn't buy a straight razor from someone who says it's shave ready unless it is someone who is known for selling a "shave ready" razor that is actually that. Apparently, shave ready is a term that is used for a razor that is not necessarily there yet. I learned that by buying my first one years ago from some guy who claimed all of his razors are "shave ready" and that he "enjoyed a close shave with every razor he sells". What I got was a razor that was very marginally sharp ( no more so than what our tools are when we sharpen them ), pulled hair like a tractor and had a huge frown in the edge.

Anyway, straight razor designs (google it) sells dovo razors sharpened by a guy who actually hones them to useful levels for about $80. I'm afraid I don't know of anyone who sells anything much cheaper that's known to be shave ready, most of the guys who sharpen razors seem to be interested in making money at it.

If you find a good razor that's not damaged and doesn't have gobs of hone wear on it (no rust, etc), and the $80 scares you off, I'd be glad to hone one for you for free to get you going. It is a tad more technique and touch/experience dependent than honing woodworking tools, but not as difficult as its made out to be.

If they scare you, i've seen folks suggest starting by just shaving the flats from your sideburns down the side of your cheeks for a bit until you get comfortable with placing the razor. Most of the nicks I got early on were from handling the razor carelessly before I put it on the skin, or accidentally coming in contact with the face when trying to turn the razor over. It takes *very* little time to learn to not nick yourself - like maybe a week, and IIRC, maybe a little longer to get comfortable around the chin.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#17

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

Frank D. in Montreal

That's interesting. I omitted a few details: I use up to a Norton 8000 when I get the razor, and haven.t had to re-sharpen (in about a year of use). That's probably because i was using compound on the strop; I'll have to see how it goes with no compound.

What's the Japanese barber hoen made of, natural stone?

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#18

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

Frank D. in Montreal

I figure they are for guys who don't have good stones - and they change the shape of the edge over time in a way i don't like.

I agree with the part about changing the shape of the edge. That's one factor that made me drop the paste from the strop. All of a sudden I understood why some razors on Ebay had a similar (albeit more proeminent) shape.

My logic for using paste was that I'd basically have a freshly sharpened edge for each shave without the hassle of using the stone; the sharpness is comparable to my Norton 8000. So it's just a different/handier technique, not a better edge than my stone.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#19

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

David Weaver

There's another group of guys who use pastes a lot, too, and I can understand why they do it...the guys who send their razor away once a year to have it honed, I fully understand why they're using the paste - it helps them get the most out of the $30 or whatever it costs them to get a razor honed, and it ensures they've worked off enough of the edge to make sure the person doing the honing has to do a little work :D

I like a maintenance hone instead, and keep two razors going generally in rotation, in case something isn't quite right with a razor in the morning - I don't have to fiddle with it at the time. I haven't had to go lower than the maintenance hone since switching over - it's a nice routine, takes about the same amount of time as just stropping and the razor always has the freshly honed sharpness.

I thought it a bit odd that there are people who would regularly use straights and do it for years without ever honing their own razors, but someone pointed out that honing was a service a lot of barber shops would offer folks 100 years ago, so it's not like it's something new, I guess.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#20

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

David Weaver

Yes, the hone is just a hard natural stone that's only about 5 1/2 inches long and 3 inches wide. It goes to a very fine slow cut very quickly if you don't abrade it to slurry (it will cut a lot faster than, like any hard natural stone - oil or water - would do). Less stropping after using it, so it takes about the same time to give a razor 10 licks on it and strop half as much as it would to strop more.

It cuts so slow with plain water that I think you could use it every day on a razor for decades and still have a lot of razor left. We'll see. I like to experiment with woodworking tools and sharpening them, but not quite so much with razors, so i'm hoping that i can wear out both the hone and the razor after some thousands of shaves or tens of thousands.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#21

Re: Worst of both worlds

TomD

Get a disposable razor and merkur blades. Only because you will probably use it for travel some time, and while learning you will know for sure the razor is not the problem. Then just shave easy parts. For most of my life I have been clean shaven. But when I grew a beard I found the straight razor much easier to shave with more comfortable, and precise. I cut myself less with it, because one never gets that situation with the bad blade. I was doing advance work for our Chairman at one point. And he showed up for a TV media comference with 30 tiny pieces of toilet paper on his face. I bet I know what happened. He decided to use a new blade to get a close shave. Bad idea. The other major comfort thing is that waste hair does not drag with the razor, which is the major problem with modern razors, and major cause of irritation. This is what make the who SR thing so instantly comfortable for me. One thing though, do not allow the razor to go diagonally, a shear cut really wiil cut you. you can press the razor against your skin quite hard, so long as you don't drag it. Of course you can get a better cut with a shear. And being cheap, I do do it. And normally regret it.

You do have to realistically judge how compatible your face is. How rough and lump covered. Some of that stuff might not take to the SR.

Right at the moment I am using this for a disposable, after loosing my usual travel razor. Razor/holder is fine, but the blades are not sharp for long:

http://www.amazon.com/Parker-SRW-Stainless-Razor-120/dp/B002ONHBBW/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1316241634&sr=8-1

I could probably get about 5 years out of a pack of these:

http://www.amazon.com/Merkur-Double-Edge-Razor-Blades/dp/B000JPMHWK/ref=sr_1_2?s=hpc&ie=UTF8&qid=1316241746&sr=1-2

I kinda prefer this handle, but the Parker is in some ways better:

http://www.amazon.com/Dovo-Stainless-Shavette-Straight-Replaceable/dp/B000ZXB94I/ref=sr_1_2?s=hpc&ie=UTF8&qid=1316241876&sr=1-2

Then once you have the mechanics down, you can expand into the all steel razors.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#22

Re: Worst of both worlds

TomD

Wait till the weekend or hollidays. I don't think you will hurt yourself, but you can end up with a few nicks the first time, so make sure you aren't giving a TV interview, or something, right after.

Re: Straight Razor Users in the HT?

#23

Re: Worst of both worlds

CJ in MPLS

I already have that box of blades for use with the safety razor. I'll have to get the blade holder and give this a shot.

Cheers,

CJ