Re: Shave horse design
TomD
I built both an earlier version of the Boggs, and the Langsner version in his chair book. I kinda like the latter best, but it is sorta a country mouse and city mouse situation. I use the Langsner at the farm where I have trees, and might attempt any old thing. And I use the Boggs in town where I am supposed to be making the chairs.
The Boggs is a highly sophisticated design that has apparently two major purposes within the context of the not-windsor chairs he makes. One has to do with his posture, repetitive use injuries. The other his flashy method of getting around the pieces. I'm not sure either of these really works for non-expert folks who are working in a totaly different way. For instance Boggs made the decision at one point to use power tools for some of his work, and to do the hand stuff for final surfaces. So hypothetically he has this great veneer grade wood, he is finishing, and he is going fast, making lots of mouth adjustments. On the other hand, in my banjo music kind a setting, I sometimes wish I had a sliding seat, as when I was rowing at Princeton, to really crunch off some big strips.
I took a course on Windsors done by an alumnus of Windsor Institute who makes full time, but I don't know if this is there method or not. He didn't use a horse at all, he used a very high vise, about collar bone height. He broke out all the spindles in what seemed like 20 minutes. He was using the method where the reductions for the taper and final size are as a result of reducing the square to an octagon a few times. WIth this method, he just held a piece in the vise, and used the tools around it without moving the part. Very fast, accurate, and nice results. Most of the parts ar enot going to be made in a horse, basically just the upper chair, and he did most of it in either the lathe or the vice. So in that model you really don't need a horse.
In theory a dumbhead design ought to be better for long parts like spindle and bow backs, but I don't know what people are using these days. Here is a vote for the dumbhead, around 8:00
http://www.pbs.org/woodwrightsshop/video/3000/3005.html
And another:
http://www.pbs.org/woodwrightsshop/video/2600/2606.html