New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Shave horse design

Posts

Shave horse design

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Shave horse design

Jack Guzman from Maine

I am setting up my shop to start building windsor chairs. I plan on building a shave horse for making spindles and other spokeshave/drawknife work. My problem is that I have no experience with these tools.I have a plan for Brian Boggs' english style adjustable horse but before I start building I'd like to hear from anyone who has experience with this or other styles. Will the dumbhead style fit this type work better? Is there anything else I should consider?---Jack

For the present I'm using a leg vise mounted to the side of an upright 6x6 post in my shop.

Re: Shave horse design

#2

Re: Shave horse design

Larry Barrett

Either style, bodger bench or dumbhead, will be an improvement over the upright leg vise you are currently using. One advantage cited for a dumbhead style is that it is easy to flip long pieces end for end; this could be a plus when you are working on the long back piece of a Windsor. But for shorter pieces like spindles it is easy to flip end for end with either style. I like the bodger bench style because it seems to hold the piece you are working on more firmly.

If you build a Brian Boggs style shaving horse, one suggestion would be to mount the seat at an angle. If you make it slant at about 10 degrees or so up from the horizontal you will find it is easier on your back and generally much more comfortable.

Re: Shave horse design

#3

Re: Shave horse design

roninkokomo

Love my Boggs style horse

Re: Shave horse design

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Shave horse design

Jack Guzman from Maine

Thanks Larry,

Boggs mentions tilting the seat as an option in his plans. Unless I hear otherwise I will proceed with the plan and build this thing.---Jack

Re: Shave horse design

#5

Re: Shave horse design

Mike in Suffolk Virginia

Jack,

Several things to keep in mind. The comment made earlier about either style shave horse being an improvement over the vise is correct. I have been building Windsor’s since 1989. I have two shave horses. My first one is the one that is on Drew Langsner's web site, Coutryworkshops.org. It is a good basic design, however it has one drawback. If you are working spindles I have to clamp a piece of 1x material to the bridge in order to have support for the length of the spindle. It is a little inconvenient. My second shave horse (which is my go to horse) is an antique (ca 1820 to 1840) is rather unusual. It has a long bridge and has a hand forged iron head. When I did the last Woodworks show as a demonstrator in York, Pa I had a gentleman to approach me and asked to photograph and measure the horse. In talking with him I found out that he was a Shake Maker. He felt certain that the horse was used in the shake making trade. He felt it was used in tapering the shingles with the drawknife. I find it perfect for doing Windsor chair parts. About a month after the show he sent me a copy of the drawing that he made. It was fairly well done. The bench is unusual in its design. It has 4 legs, seat plank, foot pedal, arm, and for the bridge a large limb that has an unusual bend with the arm coming through the branch at one of the bends. I am not certain, but I believe they got the unusual shape by getting the piece out of a fork and cutting one of the legs of the fork off. I am at work right now and do not have access to any pictures, but if you would like, I will try to post some pictures this evening when I get home.

Mike in Suffolk, VA

Re: Shave horse design

#6

Re: Shave horse design

Terry in Ottawa

I'd like to see pictures of your shaving horse.

Re: Shave horse design

#7

Re: Shave horse design

Larry Barrett

Like Mike, below, I have two shaving horses. The first one I built is an Alexander style. The second is smiliar to a Boggs horse. I made it after reading a brief article in FFW about 10 years ago, before the plans were publiished. I like it a lot. It has three legs, an advantage on uneven floors. The pivot point for the arms is off-center, which makes it swing open easily. On mine, the part that clamps the work is rectangular, rather than square, and has a couple of v-notches of different sizes. This provides an additional degree adjustability in addition to raising or lowering the table. The table is short, which makes it easy to accomodate bent pieces. Some like to have a longer table for support, but I find that a short table is adequate as long as you have good clamping force to apply to it.

The major drawback to this style is that the fairly short distance between the arms limits the width of the piece you are working on. I addessed this by using longer bolts; I just loosen the wingnuts, slide the arms further apart, and work this way if I need to. So all in all, I like this style alot.

There are plenty of good chairmakers who use different styles, so it is mostly what you get used to.

Re: Shave horse design

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Shave horse design

Jack Guzman from Maine

I would like to see those pictures.thanks---Jack

Re: Shave horse design

#9

Re: Shave horse design

Mike Jurnigan in Suffolk, VA

Here is my shavehorse. I had to pull it out of the trailer and by pulling it out that guaranteed it would start to rain If I do this right the first picture is the shave horse. The second picture shows (not too clearly) why I believe this was cut from the fork of a tree. If you look closely adjacent to the mortise for the arm you will see evidence of a knot that I believe was the other part of the fork. If you have any questions please feel free to give me a yell.

Mike in Suffolk, VA


Re: Shave horse design

#10

Re: Shave horse design

TomD

I built both an earlier version of the Boggs, and the Langsner version in his chair book. I kinda like the latter best, but it is sorta a country mouse and city mouse situation. I use the Langsner at the farm where I have trees, and might attempt any old thing. And I use the Boggs in town where I am supposed to be making the chairs.

The Boggs is a highly sophisticated design that has apparently two major purposes within the context of the not-windsor chairs he makes. One has to do with his posture, repetitive use injuries. The other his flashy method of getting around the pieces. I'm not sure either of these really works for non-expert folks who are working in a totaly different way. For instance Boggs made the decision at one point to use power tools for some of his work, and to do the hand stuff for final surfaces. So hypothetically he has this great veneer grade wood, he is finishing, and he is going fast, making lots of mouth adjustments. On the other hand, in my banjo music kind a setting, I sometimes wish I had a sliding seat, as when I was rowing at Princeton, to really crunch off some big strips.

I took a course on Windsors done by an alumnus of Windsor Institute who makes full time, but I don't know if this is there method or not. He didn't use a horse at all, he used a very high vise, about collar bone height. He broke out all the spindles in what seemed like 20 minutes. He was using the method where the reductions for the taper and final size are as a result of reducing the square to an octagon a few times. WIth this method, he just held a piece in the vise, and used the tools around it without moving the part. Very fast, accurate, and nice results. Most of the parts ar enot going to be made in a horse, basically just the upper chair, and he did most of it in either the lathe or the vice. So in that model you really don't need a horse.

In theory a dumbhead design ought to be better for long parts like spindle and bow backs, but I don't know what people are using these days. Here is a vote for the dumbhead, around 8:00

http://www.pbs.org/woodwrightsshop/video/3000/3005.html

And another:

http://www.pbs.org/woodwrightsshop/video/2600/2606.html

Re: Shave horse design

#11

Ellis Walentine

Another "shake horse"

Ellis Walentine

I attended a period reenactment at the Daniel Boone Homestead in Birdsboro, PA, in 2007 and took some shots of a shake-maker in action. His shave horse had that long bridge you are talking about, Mike. Here are a couple shots...

Ellis



Re: Shave horse design

#12

Re: Shave horse design *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer

Really interesting old horse. Is the link below to the Country Workshops mule you said required a 1" brace?

Pam


Improved Shaving Mule

Re: Shave horse design

#13

Re: Shave horse design

Mike Jurnigan in Suffolk, VA

Pam,

I believe I may have made a mistake in my first post. Drew use to have a free downloadable plan for a dumb head shaving hore on his site. It is no longer there. The one that you linked to appears to be identical to the Brian Boggs version. What I was referring to in my first post was that with the dumb head style is there is only a small working area between the dumb head and the edge of the bridge, If you are working something long and thin e.g. chair spindle, it is not supported. I take a piece of 1" x 2" or 3" and "C" clamp it to the bridge to extend the bridge and give support to what I am working on. If this is not clear I will see if can get you some pictures.

Mike in Suffolk, VA

Re: Shave horse design

#14

Re: Shave horse design

Pam Niedermayer

The reason I asked is that I'm very impressed with Boggs' newer horse, and, therefore, Drew's. I plan to build one of these very soon now, assuming it works as advertised and doesn't require braces and the like.

Pam

Re: Shave horse design

#15

Re: Shave horse design

TomD

Yeah, I built that one using drews plans just for reference, and the article in FWW on Bogg's horse for everything else. I made mine out of maple That was before his videos and does he now have plans?

It works fine I guess, I would probably build it again if I was after that kind of horse, keeping in mind that it has a faily specific unitility, The other one I built was probably similar to the free plans one, Drew's dumhead horse from his chairmaking book, and he has been working on that one his who career, and various versions pop up in various books. I was just surprised that I felt that if I had both of them in a shop, I might go over to the dumbhead one more often.

One thing though is that I am 6'1", and the dumhead one seems pretty large. Another time I would make it, but not install the rear legs, maybe prop them up on something. work with it a while, and then cut for length. The working end is all right, just the sitting end is possibly long. I was sorta proud of the dumbhead one I made as it was made out of tamarack and red oak off my property, and I even made the tapering tool using pretty basic gear I had around. I also cut out the basic parts on the farm for a dumbhead to have at home, though I haven't done that one yet. But you can tell I like it. It is a space issue, I would have it if I could have it out and use it. In fact I was sorta thinking of leaving it out of doors.

Re: Shave horse design

#16

Re: Shave horse design

Mike in Suffolk Virginia

Tom and Others,

Drew's dumb head shave horse may seem long, but you will use every inch of its length. When you are working on a long item, you will scoot to the back in order to get nice long cuts with either the drawknifew or spoke shave. The only disadvantage to my antique shave horse is that it is kind of short on the seating end. There has been a few times that my butt has been hanging over the end of the seat plank. I have not seen him post in a while, but I believe Greg Betit sp? will suport me on this.

Mike in Suffolk, VA

Re: Shave horse design

#17

Re: Shave horse design

TomD

It is hard to tell how one might miss the length if it were gone. On the other hand there is a limit as to how far back one can go and maintain pressure on the foot. And people vary in stature so there should be some customization. One thing about the Drew style horse is that the legs are held on by tapered through tenons, and one does not want to be sliding around on those if one values one's pants. So there will naturally be some overhang if one doesn't vary the design in some way so that the legs don't come up.

Re: Shave horse design

#18

Re: Shave horse design

Pam Niedermayer

Thanks, Tom and Mike, you've raised some very interesting points. I plan on a sliding leather seat, probably with a stop to hold it in place.

Pam

Re: Shave horse design

#19

A nice old Harley saddle?


Re: Shave horse design

#20

Re: A nice old Harley saddle?

Pam Niedermayer

Heh, heh, not far off, the one I toured with on my old Beemer ('71 R60/5), east coast to Mexico (San Blas) via Canada, and back to DC through the south.

Pam

Re: Shave horse design

#21

Jack Guzman from Maine

varying in stature

Jack Guzman from Maine

I was wondering about the dimensions on Boggs' plans. I am pretty sure that he is taller than me. I am only 5'4".I will have to do some fitting on mockups before I build the actual horse.---Jack

Re: Shave horse design

#22

Re: A nice old Harley saddle?

TomD

Anyone have a link to the Boggs plans? Or are we talking the Langsner Mule plans?

Re: Shave horse design

#23

Re: A nice old Harley saddle? *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer

Sure, Google's your friend. :)

Pam


Google link

Re: Shave horse design

#24

Re: A nice old Harley saddle?

TomD

I doubt that. :)

I was looking at those and the dimensions seem off. I checked on his version of the Langsner plan, since I have the dimensions for that one, and built it. They don't seem right either, but to know for sure I would have to load the file, and I don't think my CAD uses sketch-up. Have other people built form his plans?

Re: Shave horse design

#25

Re: A nice old Harley saddle?

Pam Niedermayer

Interesting, I'll be careful about testing a model before committing.

Thanks,

Pam