New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Do I need to glue

Posts

Do I need to glue

#1

Do I need to glue

patrick gibbons

I'm building a small bookcase that will be about 4 ft high and 2 feet wide roughly. The two shelves will be enclosed by face frames and a solid back. Do I really need to glue the shelves in their rabbets and toenail them in or can they just float inside the rabbet? I'm leaning toward just floating but all plans for other similar cases have called for glue and nails. I'm wondering if wood movement would be a problem.

Re: Do I need to glue

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: Do I need to glue *LINK*

Dale Lenz

If I visualize your book cabinet correctly, two verticals sides, grain running vertically and two horizontal shelves, grain running side to side, wood movement should not be a problem. You will get less shelf sag if the shelves are fixed, normally. See link below to plug in your cabinets information into a sagulator.

Good luck and enjoy the journey.


Sagulator

Re: Do I need to glue

#3

Yes, it would be a good idea...

John in NM

As Dale says, wood movement is not a concern as the grain is parallel on all the parts and you will end up with a stronger build if you glue it.

Given that it is a face frame design, you might consider veneer plywood for the shelves and sides, face frames are a modern trend intended to mask the plywood or particle board. Solid wood construction rarely benifits from things like face frames or attempts to hide the end grain.

Re: Do I need to glue

#4

Re: Do I need to glue

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Most of the period pieces like this that I have taken apart have not had glue. The backing boards are nailed on to both the carcass and to the shelves. Nailing like this helps to support the shelves, and the back helps stiffen the entire piece. The face frames are usually mortise and tenon and either nailed or pinned to both the carcass and the shelves, also helping with stiffness. Occasionally there are nails going into the shelves from the sides (through the carcass sides), but I don't think of this as high quality and some may be later additions.

I use hot hide glue and like to get the carcass together in a hurry, then slide the shelves in after the glue is dry.